Lesley Lababidi and Nadia El-Arabi have written one of the first English-language studies of disability in the Middle East. The authors note that between 2 and 6 percent of the Egyptian population have disabling conditions, whereas only 5 to 7 percent of them “receive support services” (p. 22). As the book testifies, Egyptian society is moving toward better reaching its disabled members, although the larger and more radical project of reforming society remains elusive. Dr. Alaa Shukrallah, a leading advocate for special needs people in Egypt, declares in the early pages of the book, “The focus of rehabilitation has been on the individual and how the individual must ‘fit into’ normal society: in other words, on making the disabled normal enough to fit into normal society. And I think this is a great failure, because I personally believe the focus should be more on changing society to accept diversity and difference than on changing the individual to fit into society” (p. 16). In their book, Lababidi and El-Arabi provide rich documentation of the range of efforts both to rehabilitate and support individuals with special needs as well as to alter social thinking and institutions to accommodate disability.
Silent No More begins by outlining some historical trends in social attitudes toward disability in Egypt. The authors stress, for example, that before 1970, society had little concern for those with physical and mental disabilities (p. 2), and that families tended to hide their disabled members to protect the marriage prospects of siblings (pp. 2, 23). Prior to 1950, the majority of services available to disabled people came through private and religious charitable organizations, many run by the upper classes or expatriates in urban areas. Along with much of the private sector and civil society, these groups were nationalized after the 1952 revolution. According to the book, decentralized care only expanded again after the United Nations began awareness-raising campaigns in the 1970s (these U.N. declarations are usefully included in the appendices of the book), international research emerged on the importance of early detection and intervention and normalization, and President Hosni Mubarak and his wife, Suzanne, began advocating for children with disabilities in the 1980s. Lababidi and El-Arabi do note that Egypt has a long institutional history of serving people with disabilities (i.e., the 13th century Qalawun hospital's section for the insane, or the section for the blind at al-Azhar which began in the 8th century), and they also detail several important histories of more recent institutions. In light of the expanding field of social and cultural histories of insanity and disability (including a broad range of scholars, such as Michel Foucault, Paul K. Longmore, Gelya Frank, Mark Priestley, Marian Corker, Tom Shakespeare), one wonders what this history of Egyptian disabilities might contribute to broader conversations about the social model of disability, the disability rights movement, gender and disability, postmodern disability, disability in global contexts, and so forth. A number of scholars have also recently begun working specifically on disability in colonial and postcolonial contexts, such as Anita Ghai on India, Sandra Sufian on the Middle East, and Mark Priestley on the global context.
Although Silent No More works to raise community awareness of the prevalence, treatment, and political issues of disability, this book is largely a compendium of resources in Egypt for people with disabilities, their families, and educators. The authors write that “[t]his volume is a blueprint for Egypt's work and a testimony to tireless community leaders. Ultimately, it is a tribute to Egyptian families… who strive to assure the disabled of their right to a better quality of life” (p. xv). The authors have identified and conducted interviews at more than forty schools and associations in Egypt (run by the government, NGOs, and private associations) as well as with a number of individuals. Organized by institution or program serving different disabilities (deafness, blindness, mental retardation, and physical disability), much of the text represents largely transcribed interviews with school or association administrators, teachers, and occasional students. The subjects explain the available facilities, the program's history and mission, its targeted population, current strengths and challenges, and future plans. Perhaps as a way to extend the model of self-empowerment, the authors' “vision was that the story would be told primarily by the people involved—people with special needs and their caregivers and friends within the community at large” (p. xiii).
Some of these listings open broad questions about the social and political relations of disability in Egypt: the need for unification of rights for the mentally retarded among different governorates in Egypt, the lack of resources for the multiply disabled, the problem of accessibility and movement in Cairo, the need for more programs to serve rural and lower income communities, and the desire to create residential communities for disabled people whose parents or caregivers die. Many of the transcribed interviews make for quite engaging reading, demonstrating the richness of the interview encounter with the authors (especially the organizations involved in community-based rehabilitation, the Right to Live Association in Heliopolis, and the pediatricians working with learning disabilities). A number of the entries demonstrate that the various organizations and schools are in dialogue with each other. Other entries provide a public forum for groups to voice their specific needs and concerns (i.e., a bus to transport students, improved dental care, more stable funding, higher teacher salaries, more Braille printers or computers). Overall, the interviews, often rich in detail, raise many important issues. One hopes that the book has been also published in Arabic.
Silent No More initiates a social and academic conversation about important issues of special needs, social support, accessibility, and the definition of “normal” that represents an original contribution to the study of Egypt, disability, and civil society, as well as an essential directory for people with special needs and their advocates. Making disability a visible category of study and society is an important step in ensuring social enfranchisement.
