Amina Jamal's concern is to examine “the possibilities and the limitation of the Islamist project for women in contemporary Pakistan”. To do this she engages with over fifty women associated with the Jamaat-e-Islam and conducts in-depth interviews with fourteen of them. Between 2002 and 2008 many of these women served as elected representatives in local, provincial and national political bodies. She begins with a review of the feminist approaches utilised by Muslim women, working in Western universities, when theorising on women in Islamic movements – a strong knowledge of arguments in the field and a punctiliousness in dealing with them, is a feature of her book. She goes on to delineate what she terms the “public religious space” which has opened up in Pakistan as a result of the engagement of the Jamaati project of an Islamic state with the global discourses of women's empowerment. There follows a description of women's involvement in an urban development project in Karachi which is compared to the activism of two remarkable early Jamaati women, Hameeda Begum and Maryam Jameelah. Moving on she examines women's current activism. She concludes that “it is a mistake to see the struggle in civil society as a struggle between religious conservatism and secular modernity”. Far from it: the battleground is modernity itself. Jamaati women aim to frame the debate themselves. They use not simply Islam but also ideas about citizenship, women's rights and progress, to challenge the modernisers’ claims to be the protagonists of the national interest and national development in Pakistan. Jamal continues by demonstrating, through many excellent quotes from her interviewees, how Jamaati women use the “Jamaati ideological and philosophical compass” to guide them through current global discourses on women and development. This is followed by a fascinating analysis of how the somewhat unforgiving and discriminating approach of Jamaati women to the issue of “enjoining the good and forbidding the evil” flows, in part at least, from the great ruptures brought about in South Asian Islam by colonial rule.
Jamal offers two major conclusions to the issue of the possibilities and limitations of the Islamist project for women. First, Jamaati women make good use of their class and cultural location “to challenge the dominance of liberal/secular social and political groups and to claim the leadership of working-class rural and urban women”. Second, their modernist project, while liberating for some women, is threatening to others because of the way in which the Jamaat discriminates against so many expressions of being Muslim in Pakistan. “Indeed, I have argued”, she declares, “that the Jamaat's conception of Islam is an interruption rather than a progression in the customary and traditional modes of understanding Islam in South Asia”. With these arguments she hopes “to shift the focus of feminist theory away from the secular-versus-religious or the modernity-versus-tradition framework that continues to underpin what constitutes Islamic-religious or liberal-secular discourse in Pakistan”. She hopes, too, that the debate might focus “on bringing together the best traditions of Islam and the best traditions of regional culture [by which she means Sufi traditions] in the interests of emancipatory political discourse”. So, having analysed the achievement of her Jamaati women with affection and respect we must infer that she would rather they did not make much further progress but paid attention instead to the more liberal and inclusive traditions which run in her blood, those of the ulama of Farangi Mahall and the Sufis of Rudauli Sharif.
This is an important book. It not only excavates much new evidence about Jamaati women activists but it also brings significant support to that group of scholars who see the Jamaat-e-Islam as an essentially ‘modern’ project whose followers are striving to make aspects of modernity serve their understandings of Islam. The argument is supported by impeccable scholarship. As a contribution to our understanding of women's religious activism in Pakistan it is an excellent companion to Sadaf Ahmad's Transforming Faith: The Story of al-Huda and Islamic Revivalism among Urban Pakistani Women (2009), which was also published by Syracuse University Press.
