Christian Encounters with Iran is a significant book because it challenges conventional wisdom. Although it is no groundbreaking statement to say that Iran is not as fundamentalist as it has been portrayed in the media in recent times or that the Islamic Republic is not the rogue state that George W. Bush claimed it was, Sasan Tavassoli introduces us to a facet of life in Iran that is not well known, having neither received much attention nor been documented in as much detail as in this book.
Tavassoli dedicates his book to Christian–Muslim encounters taking place in Iran on a number of different levels. He lists the institutions, progressive as well as conservative, engaged in Christian–Muslim dialogue and discusses their backgrounds, strategies, and aims. His book covers mainly the 1990s, although for sources he makes use of books that were published as late as 2005. There are currently four centers in Iran—three organizations in Tehran and one in Qom—that have been founded for the specific purpose of interfaith research and dialogue. Although these centers have been established to promote academic interaction with all major world religions, so far, Tavassoli writes, the vast majority of their contacts have been with Christians. Of the four institutions, two are government sponsored, namely, the Organization of Culture and Islamic Relations, established in 1995, and the International Center for Dialogue among Civilizations, established in 1999. The remaining two are independent and nongovernmental, namely, the Institute for Interreligious Dialogue, founded in 2001, and the Center for the Study of World Religions, which was established in 1996 in the city of Qom. The latter center has close ties to the Shiʿi seminaries of Qom and was started as a specialized library, although, according to Tavassoli, it has now developed into the most active research and publication center. This center is now seeking accreditation from the Ministry of Education to offer advanced graduate degrees in the study of various religions. This is the very first such attempt in the history of higher education in Iran.
Tavassoli looks at the goals and publications of all these centers, both governmental and nongovermental, as well as at the events they have been organizing over the years and considers the guests who have been invited and who have taken part in the conferences. He also examines the closing communiqués. The activities of these institutions alone offer an interesting insight, as the picture that emerges of the conferences is one characterized by an open and intense atmosphere of mutual respect.
Even more interesting is the description and analysis of the literature written and published on Christianity in Iran in the last decades before and after the revolution. In introducing and describing works that were written before the 1979 revolution, Tavassoli shows how most of these books were characterized by polemics and a lack of interest in appreciating a different point of view. He adds that such insular points of view became rare in the 1990s and later. Instead, today, books are being written that show not only a deep understanding of Christianity but also a real desire for an exchange of ideas and understanding another faith. Tavassoli takes much care to document this change in people's mindsets and perceptions. To highlight how things used to be, he reminds his readers of the founding of the Dar al-Tabliq Center in Qom in the 1960s. He further points to the ignorance and lack of interest of important intellectual figures like ʿAli Shariʿati regarding all things Christian.
Tavassoli then discusses some of the new attitudes that have become apparent among contemporary Iranian religious thinkers in their interactions with Christian thought. He points out how similar positive changes can also be detected in the trend of publications, which in recent years has tended toward a more informative and dialogical approach to Christianity. Pointing to the two government-sponsored centers mentioned previously, he underlines how such organizations have become committed to dialogue and cooperation with Christian churches. Furthermore, he makes the observation that “prominent intellectuals not only express their deep appreciation for many aspects of the Christian faith but are also being deeply influenced in their own theological outlook through their engagement with Christian theology” (p. 188).
This comes as no surprise to anyone who, over the last several years, has studied the works of ʿAbdolkarim Soroush and Mohammad Mojtahed Shabestari. In fact, the influence of modern Christian approaches on Soroush's and Shabestari's reformist thought is quite well known. Shabestari compares Paul Tillich's approach to that of Ibn ʿArabi and tells his readers in his books Iman va Azadi (Faith and Freedom) (Tehran: Tarh-e naw, 1997, p. 115) and Hermenutik, Ketab va Sonnat (Hermeneutics, the Book and Tradition) (Tehran: Tarh-e naw, 1996, p. 144) how deeply impressed he was by Tillich's book Systematic Theology. Shabestari, concerned about the consequences of religion becoming an ideology, was looking for new ideas about religion, and he found them in the works of German Protestant thinkers. Karl Barth is another German theologian who influenced Shabestari very much. As a result of the crisis of the modern man, Barth developed the idea of God being the total other, der ganz Andere. And Shabestari compares this idea to one he knows from Persian mysticism. In Rumi's poems, too, God is described as the total other, an chiz-e digar.
Soroush's book Saratha-ye Mostaqim (Straight Paths [Tehran: Sarat, 1999]), which was influenced by John Hick's advocacy of religious pluralism, has been translated into English (The Expansion of Prophetic Experience: Essays on Historicity, Contingency and Plurality in Religion, trans. Nilou Mobasser [Leiden: E. J. Brill, 2009]). In his interaction with people of non-Christian faiths, Hick began to move toward his pluralistic outlook on religion. He notes that, as he came to know these people who belonged to non-Christian faiths, he saw in them the same values and moral actions he recognized in fellow Christians. This observation led him to begin questioning how a loving God could sentence non-Christians who espoused values that were revered in Christianity to an eternity in hell. Soroush was very impressed by this attitude (Saratha-ye Mostaqim, p. 20).
However, to state that the attitude of governmental institutions and of Iranian intellectuals regarding Christianity has changed is a novel proposition, and Tavassoli provides sufficient examples to prove it beyond a doubt. He quotes, for example, the Iranian Ayatollah Mustafa Mohaqqeq-Damad stating that most Iranian Shiʿi thinkers no longer look at the Trinity as polytheism but have come to understand that Christians look at this doctrine in a mystical way to express their belief in one God (p. 112). He also gives the example of Ataʾollah Mohajerani, Minister of Islamic Culture and Guidance between 1997 and 2000, who, in his opening message at the first dialogue with the Armenian Christians of Iran, “made an emphatic point that religious believers could no longer view themselves as the sole standards of the truth and others as outside the realm of truth” (p. 112). Similarly, Grand Ayatollah Mohammad Ebrahim Jannati is mentioned as another instance of a highly positioned Shiʿi scholar criticizing those Muslims who thought they were completely right and non-Muslims all wrong, at a conference of the World Council of Churches.
Tavassoli's book is a contribution to a new way of looking at Iran: it traces the changes in the Islamic Republic's thinking and discourses and shows how there is an intellectual revolution taking place there. Mehran Kamrava's Iran's Intellectual Revolution (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008) makes a similar argument, although Kamrava distinguishes between three different discourses: the conservative religious discourse, the reformist religious discourse, and the secular-modernist discourse. Tavassoli, for the most part, focuses on the religious discourse that is new and innovative.
Both books provide tremendous insight into today's Iran by detailing what is read, translated, written, and even thought there. Although, due to current circumstances, we have no empirical studies on the extent of the changes in Iranian society, studies like the ones mentioned at least give us an inkling of the profound changes and the democratic, tolerant, and pluralistic potential that has developed within Iranian society in recent years. One is tempted to think that a society in which Tillich, Bultmann, and Pannenberg are translated and read cannot be too narrow-minded. Of course, this is not to say that ex occidente lux, but it throws a favorable light on a society willing to admit foreign intellectual influences and engage with them.
Tavassoli indeed praises the Muslim–Christian encounters in Iran to the point that at times he sounds somewhat biased, as in this line: “The impression received when comparing the general trends in the Iranian thinkers’ attitude toward Christianity with that of many Sunni Muslims is the extent to which Iranians are more open to dialogue and positive engagements with Christians” (p. 192). That sounds rather simplistic, especially because there is no indication what this comparison between the general trends of Sunnis and Shiʿis is based on, as Encounters with Christianity in Iran offers no analysis of Sunni Muslims and their encounters with Christianity. A comparison, therefore, seems uncalled for and thus appears as more of a judgment. Another of his statements, however, is based on much better proof, namely, that the evidence from Iran strongly indicates that the “irenic approach” toward the possibility and necessity of dialogue is the dominant and mainstream approach of the religious organizations, publications, and intellectuals (p. 193)—and that in itself is significant.
The keyword here is dialogue. Tavassoli, who converted from Shiʿi Islam to Christianity over twenty years ago, at no point suggests that Iran's Muslims have become more favorably inclined toward Christianity because Christianity's moment in Iran has come or that many are ready for conversion. Even though Tavassoli himself evangelizes and hosts TV shows broadcast to Iran in which he promotes Christianity, this has had no detrimental effect on his scholarly standards.
In short Tavassoli offers deep insights into a field that, thus far, has been neglected by Western academia. Scholars of Iranian studies and others who are interested in intellectual trends, especially Muslim–Christian dialogue in Iran, will benefit greatly from this book.
