The role, size, and nature of the slave trade from Africa to the Islamic world have understandably been controversial topics. Some accuse historians of Africa of downplaying this long tradition of “internal” oppression in favor of the more spectacular “external” traffic across the Atlantic; others criticize the conflation of many types of servitude into an image based on the American South. No one, however, can deny the importance of the slave trade in African–Middle Eastern relations throughout history.
John Wright has written an overview history of the “western” side of this slave trade, the one across the Sahara (other important avenues were down the Nile and across the Indian Ocean). Although his time span is vast, from the coming of Islam until today, the main emphasis of his study is on the 19th century and the efforts of European, in particular British, travelers and officials to describe it and to end it. At this time, the three major routes ended in Morocco, Tunis, and Tripolitania. The focus is thus here, drawing not least on the author's established authority as a historian of modern Libya.
By focusing on the trade, rather than the employment, of servile groups, the book avoids the discussions about “what is a slave.” Here it simply means people used as a trade commodity, captured or bought south of the Sahara and marched north to North Africa for resale. A common issue for debate, both empirical and moral, is the extent of this trans-Saharan trade compared to that across the Atlantic: was it of comparable size, and was it in some way more “benign” than the trans-Atlantic trade? In some ways such comparisons are meaningless, because the contexts are so different, but at least a comparison in numbers can be made. It is, however, only in the last century or so of the trade that we can get reliable figures. For the first nine centuries of Islamic presence in the Maghrib, estimates of the full number of slaves imported vary from 4 million (Ralph Austen) to almost 6 million (Raymond Mauny). Wright presents a somewhat lower total of about 3.5 million without giving much detail on how he arrived at that number. Added to the more secure figures of an average of 6,000 to 7,000 per year for the later centuries, he arrives at six million total across recorded history, similar to Austen's figures (which are slightly lower for the 18th century) but less than half of Mauny's earlier estimate. If so, the trans-Saharan routes carried less than half of those moved across the Atlantic but over three times as long of a period.
Still, the suffering was horrendous. Slaves habitually had to walk across the desert, often carrying heavy burdens with little nourishment, and perhaps one in five died along the way. Nineteenth-century travelers tell of mountain passes white with the bones of slaves that succumbed during the transit, and many more died after arriving north due to disease or the climate. In fact, Wright notes (from Austen) that the total number of black slaves in the Maghrib was never very large, as there was not really any great use for slave labor; the need for replenishment came primarily because death and manumission quickly reduced the slave population. The average “active time span” of a slave was only about seven years; thus, perhaps 15 percent of the slave population had to be renewed every year to maintain their number. About two-thirds of the traded slaves were female, and because few of them married male slaves, there was little internal reproduction (offspring between master and slave were born free).
Wright's main sources for the later centuries are travelers' accounts and reports from the activist British representatives in Tripoli, Tunis, and Morocco, and his presentation is marked by their interests. Thus, like them, he gives detailed statistics of observed slave trade in the various main entrepôts at various points during the century, and by totaling these he can make fairly comprehensive estimates of the trade. He also follows some of the retraded slaves across the Mediterranean to the central Ottoman regions, noting that the majority of the slaves in this period appear to have stopped in the Maghrib. He also follows the efforts of the Europeans to substitute “legitimate trade” like ostrich feathers for the slaves. Although he notes the utopian and idealistic nature of the “legitimate” alternative—the slave trade was so important to the trans-Saharan trade that when the slave trade ended, the trade routes withered away—he clearly identifies with his actors in their aspirations. Thus, there is no discussion of what role the antislavery campaign may have played in the wider power struggle between European and Middle Eastern actors or in European efforts to gain access to the local markets.
It is rare today to see a study where the European presence is pictured as so unequivocally positive, albeit often idealistic and ineffective. Perhaps this is one topic where it can be argued that European ideals were not just a cover for imperialist aspirations but an independent factor that should still be applauded today. Yet, placing the abolition issue in the wider historical and political context of the 19th century would no doubt have enriched the analysis.
Some minor editing matters also catch the eye. There is some repetition of arguments, and in some cases the discussion ranges up and down a time line, forcing the reader to make sure what point in time is being discussed. The author has also adopted each colonial power's spelling of the place names in its respective country, thus (Italian) Giarabub and Agedabia for Jaghbub and Ajdabiya in Libya but Djerid in Tunisia (and Ouargla but Waddan). For an English-speaking audience a unified spelling system would have made some names more recognizable.
These minor quibbles aside, this book is a very useful summary of our knowledge of the extent and distribution of the slave trade across the Sahara and in particular a thorough study of the existing British sources for the 19th century and the efforts made to stop the trade. The author's remarks about the slowness and ineffectiveness of abolition and his final remarks about how this topic is perhaps not yet relegated to history only add to the relevance of this study.
