“The ambiguity of his charisma remains” (p. 53). The last sentence of Katherine Bowie's excellent article on famous, early twentieth-century, northern Thai monk Khruba Siwichai could be the title of this entire edited volume: Charismatic Monks of Lanna Buddhism. Bowie is one of the world's experts on Khruba Siwichai (1878–1938). He remains, without question, the most important Buddhist monk in northern Thai history. Bowie, in this article, previous publications, and her recent book Of Beggars and Buddhas: The Politics of Humor in the Vessantara Jataka in Thailand (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 2017), reveals the importance of this monk politically, regionally, and in the pattern of chedi and monastery building he established in the region. However, it is her hesitation about how to define his “charisma” that illustrates the problem with this collection. Neither she nor any other individual author in this volume is to blame for this; rather, the problem of the collection is that it is not more than the sum of its parts. Each article stands on its own as a valuable contribution to the field, but, as a whole, the volume does not move the field forward theoretically or confront major issues lurking over it.
I should preface my critiques by stating that this is an important volume in the study of northern Thai, Shan, Karen, Lao, and Tai (Khoen, Leu, Dara'ang) Buddhism. The articles in Charismatic Monks of Lanna Buddhism help illustrate the importance of understanding the term barami, ethnic diversity, the influx of urban central Thai money, and material culture in the study of this region's religion. The articles should be read as a set, and editor Paul Cohen should be praised for his tight control of the content. I will offer a few thoughts on field-wide issues that could have been better addressed, limiting myself to a consideration of the words and concepts found in the title of the book.
First, the term “charismatic” is mentioned in each article and the introduction, but is never really defined or given cultural nuance. It is also often paired with the equally complex term barami, which adds to the confusion since these two terms do not clarify each other. Cohen's short and largely perfunctory introduction (in contrast to his very interesting article later in the volume) offers little attempt to define charisma and barami, and I believe any serious student of religious studies, Buddhist studies, or Lanna Buddhism will be left unsatisfied. He writes:
Max Weber defined charismatic authority in terms of ‘a certain quality of an individual personality by virtue of which he is set apart from ordinary men and treated as endowed with supernatural, superhuman, or at least specifically exceptional powers or qualities’ (Weber 1964: 358). The various studies in this volume of relationships between Lanna charismatic monks and their followers are consistent with Weber's seminal definition but also highlight the distinctive character of Thai Buddhist cosmology, in particular the concept of barami.… According to Patrick Jory, the term barami is derived from the Pali word parami and ‘is rooted in a Theravada Buddhist scriptural tradition in which a Buddha-to-be (Pali: bodhisatta) vowed to “accumulate” ten kinds of barami in order to achieve the state of moral and spiritual “Perfection” that enabled the attainment of enlightenment and Buddhahood’ (Jory 2002: 37). (pp. 1–2)
Weber is a controversial scholar in the history of religions (not to mention the history of Buddhist studies), and his theory of charisma has been studied and criticized extensively, but none of that critical history is brought into this discussion, apparently with the expectation that readers should take Weber's Greek-derived definition as sacrosanct. “Charisma,” from the Greek, refers to a gift given from the gods, meaning that a higher power or powers “endow” or give charisma. However, throughout this book, “charisma” is made into a gloss for “barami,” a Thai word, which is in no way a gift given by a higher power and thus hardly equivalent to charisma. Putting aside the problems with Jory's use of the terms “Theravada,” “scriptural,” and “tradition,” and even placing “the” in front of these terms, Jory is right to state that barami can be “accumulated.” It can also be displayed and earned. But it is not endowed or given. The term “barami” in Thai, Shan, Lao, or Kham Muang (Lanna Thai) is also not equivalent to the Pali term pāramī (spelled without diacritical marks as parami in the volume). This assumption of an equivalence between vernacular and Pali concepts is a problem in the field of Southeast Asian Buddhist studies more broadly. Jory adds more complexity to the term's definition in his original article, but that is not provided here.
Throughout the volume, neither charisma nor barami are given much more clarity or critical engagement. Amporn Jirattikorn associates charisma with “mystic power” (which is also not defined) (p. 210). Cohen in his article defines barami as “personal charisma” and “perfection,” but leaves it at that (p. 69). Mikael Gravers states that “these monks, followers and communities constitute a trans-local network of charisma and moral communities across borders” (p. 124). The term “charisma community” is not defined, and the reader is left wondering if “charisma” is somehow equivalent to “moral.” In another section, Gravers actually gets closer to a more accurate understanding of barami by associating it (if I am reading him correctly) as a type of “power” accumulated through certain types of virtuous, meditative, and physical acts by writing, “The world and morality depends on persons with barami, with charisma and special supernatural powers (phalang saksit)” (p. 134), but does not expand on this. Sean Ashley and Anthony L. Irwin offer more nuance. The former, drawing on Pierre Bourdieu, writes that the “dynamic between these [Dara'ang] communities and charismatic monks encourages us to look beyond charisma as something inherent within particular holy men to those characteristics that make them socially predisposed to address the needs of their supporters” (p. 186). This is important, because barami is always something that is accumulated through working in social networks.
Irwin tackles the issue more than any other contributor is his excellent chapter. He notes that barami can not only be accumulated by humans, but also be found in “powerful objects or non-human beings” (p. 89). He writes further that:
The charismatic powers of these virtuoso forest monks, derived from their mental prowess and their moral virtue (barami), were tapped to sacralize and empower Buddhist images and amulets as well as a community of devotees. This is a process that Tambiah identifies as ‘objectification of charisma’ (a form of fetishism) (Tambiah 1984: Ch.22) and reflects the ‘paradox of power’ in Buddhism (Mendelson 1965), that is, ‘the more the monk exhibits ‘other-worldly’ reclusive tendencies, the more he is pursued by a fervent laity seeking the mystical attributes. (p. 70)
Irwin's discussion shows how complex the term “barami” is, but one wishes he had gone further to scrutinize the “paradox of power.”
Throughout the entire volume and introduction, terms like “holy,” “moral,” and “power” are not interrogated or even defined. Furthermore, there is hardly any discussion of the common term “bun” in Thai, which is left shockingly unexamined. But staying on terms used in the title, while the adjective “charismatic” appears much more commonly in the volume than the noun “charisma,” the fact that “barami” is a noun in Thai and is used as a noun is not discussed. Could “barami” be used as an adjective in Thai or Pali? Certainly not in the same way. Furthermore, how can “barami” be “perfection,” “power,” “mystic power,” “moral virtue,” “charisma,” and more? Certainly, “barami” is an overdetermined word, like charisma, but that issue is never confronted squarely in this volume, and that is a missed opportunity for the editor and the authors to contribute to a major problem that has plagued Southeast Asian Buddhist studies and that has clearly not been resolved here.
A second problematic concept in the book is “monks.” Many of the individual monks who appear in this volume—including Khruba La, Khruba Intha, Khruba Wong, U Thuzana, Khruba Thueang, and Khruba Bunchum—are understudied, and the articles provide a rare opportunity to learn about their histories; indeed, Charismatic Monks of Lanna Buddhism is one of the only non-Thai sources that can expose students to these important religious, political, and community leaders. (There are hundreds of Thai sources on these and other regionally important monks.) Kwanchewan Buadaeng, Gravers, and Cohen all mention “hermits” (another problematic term) who might have been former novices or monks, but became famous as nonmonastic figures (not bound by the Pātimokkha precepts or living in monasteries). The book itself is dedicated to Phra Pho Pan, a “hermit” or ruesi who was not an ordained monk. (He also appears on the cover.) These figures who are neither ordained nor laypeople are prevalent in Southeast Asian Buddhism, indeed in Buddhism more broadly (see, for example, lamas in Tibet or yamabushi in Japan), yet few scholars have looked closely at them. In various publications they are referred to with vernacular terms harkening back to Indian Brahmins but neither are they Brahmins. Some are called “wizards,” “holy men,” or “sacred healers” in English. In this book, only one footnote (p. 5n8) attempts to explain these figures, and Cohen refers to them once as “hermits” as “cenobites” (p. 2). This was a chance to explore the difference between the cenobitic (monastic/communal) and anchoritic (eremitic/lone ascetic) religious paths in the region; however, it was not explored. Moreover, the book makes no mention of locally powerful religious women, who would further complicate the category.
Third, the term “Lanna” is also problematic. I have written about this term at length before and will not discuss the larger issues here,Footnote 1 but this is where this book could have made a major contribution to the field, because the individual articles are so strong in discussing the importance of this amorphous region and how, even though it is associated with northern Thailand, it actually overlaps with parts of modern Burma/Myanmar, Laos, and China, and even small parts of Vietnam and India. I think it is good that northern Thai monks were not the sole object of study in this volume. Kwanchewan, Gravers, Cohen, Irwin, Tatsuki Kataoka, Ashley, and Amporn all discuss figures that traveled over borders, have followers in multiple countries, and are respected by people of diverse ethnicities. Kataoka writes one of the most impressive articles in terms of range, research, and clarity. He highlights the diversity of the region when writing: “The uniqueness of the Bunchum movement lies in its multi-ethnic composition. Indeed, this movement crosses boundaries not only of nations but also of ethnic groups” (p. 218). He also shows, like Irwin, that pagoda/chedi construction was a “means to attract ethnic minorities” (p. 221). Gravers writes about monks in the Karen region crossing the Thai and Burmese borders. Ashley discusses the Silver Palaung (Dara'ang) ethnic people and their relation to Theravada Buddhism. Amporn shows how Khruba Bunchum has had “diverse groups of followers” from the Lahu, Shan, Karen, Palaung, and Lao, as well as “middle class and wealthy Thais” (p. 192). Kwanchewan's study theorizes the very idea of ethnic diversity in Lanna monk followings by drawing on Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari and Manuel DeLanda's idea of an “assemblage” (p. 149).
Bowie and others also show how these regional monks served to promote local identity in contrast to growing central Thai/Siamese hegemony from the mid-nineteenth century to the present. Ashley and Kataoka make similar arguments. Ashley shows how Dara'ang challenge dominant Thai stereotypes about their marginal participation in Buddhism through their strict adherence to the teachings of Khruba Thueang, while Kataoka argues that Khruba Bunchum “has managed to minimize” the efforts at uniform state sangha organization intended by the Thai Sangha Administration Act of 1902 (p. 223). Cohen highlights this argument when he writes about Khruba Bunchum, Khruba Siwichai, and some of the other figures studied in this volume as symbols of defiance or of an “ethno-regionalism (and a sense of being despised by metropolitan middle class and elites)” that is “a dormant phenomenon susceptible to arousal…” (p. 22). He points out, for example, that “almost every home in northern Thailand has a photo or image of Siwichai, numerous village temples have his statue, and his shrine at the foot of Doi Suthep is still a focus of popular worship and even of political protests” (p. 22).
Cohen clearly needs to be lauded here for choosing contributors that speak to such similar and mutually reinforcing themes like the importance of “charismatic monks” to regional identity, cultural preservation, and even some degree of political independence. However, his introduction (and the volume as a whole) does not question the very idea of the region of Lanna as a unified area. Moreover, it promotes some rather dated ideas about how local and translocal cultures interact, such as when Cohen writes:
The Lanna Buddhist tradition burgeoned under the influence of Chiang Mai rulers.… The spread of Lanna Buddhism to neighbouring Tai-speaking peoples (such as the Khuen and Shan of Chiang Tung, the Lue of Sipsong Panna, Yunnan, and the Lao of upper Laos) went hand-in-hand with Tilokaraja's political expansion and hegemony over these regions. Lanna cultural and literary productivity waned during more than two hundred years of Burmese rule (1558 to 1776) but was revived in the nineteenth century. (p. 3)
Yes, Buddhist monasteries and their royal support in places like Chiang Mai, Lampang, and Lamphun were influential in terms of having large, wealthy educational centers and libraries from the late fifteenth century onward, but this idea of a singular Lanna Buddhism “spreading” to the other regions is not accurate. Oftentimes monks from outlying Shan, Khoen, Leu, Lao, Khmer, Mon, and other areas brought new ideas, texts, and rituals to central Lanna. These areas did not simply “receive” Lanna culture and religion. This region was a vast network of exchange. The manuscript and epigraphical evidence makes this clear. Moreover, the very idea that Burmese rule was the cause of “decline” or the end of the Lanna Golden Age or that it was a unified entity that could be “revived” is questionable.
Finally, the last word in the title and volume to consider is “Buddhism.” This is where the volume really makes a significant contribution to the field. The idea of Buddhism or even “Theravada” Buddhism as a unitary religion is thoroughly questioned by several chapters. The most vocal critic of the idea that these charismatic monks represent the Theravada is Kataoka, who describes the multiplicity of ways in which Bunchum's activities “by-pass the official category of ‘religion’ … regulated by the state” by situating his headquarters in a pagoda site rather than a temple, which allows him to regularly incorporate Tibetan, Chinese, and Mayahayana practices and sutras (pp. 223–24).
Gravers, Cohen, and Bowie all discuss the importance of Christianity in the region as well as showing well how Buddhist communities, even in rural areas, were quite cosmopolitan in terms of ethnicity, language, and competing ritual and religious systems. So while the scope of the volume could have been expanded to more explicitly consider “religion” rather than simply “Buddhism,” it already goes quite far in helping students of Buddhism see the complexity of religion in the Lanna region.
Overall, despite some missed opportunities and a bit of theoretical or conceptual risk-aversion, these chapters are wonderful additions to the field. Charismatic Monks of Lanna Buddhism is edited extremely well and written clearly. The high quality and originality of each article is impressive. In fact, unlike most edited volumes that emerge from conferences (this book is comprised of several papers from the 12th International Conference on Thai Studies in Sydney in April 2014 and an academic seminar at Chiang Mai University in January 2015), these articles are amazingly cohesive and coherent in terms of subject matter, time period, and region. They work well read together, and the order is also well conceived. I highly recommend it to all students and scholars of religion in the region.
