Within twenty-four hours of Husni Mubarak's historic resignation on 11 February 2011, a video weaving together a wide array of content surfaced on YouTube. Based on its caption, the moving montage originally appeared on Facebook four months earlier and foreshadowed the Egyptian Revolution. The production opens with the Egyptian government's decision the summer prior to extend the country's much despised state of emergency, under the pretext of combatting terrorism and drug trafficking. It then shifts to Khaled Said, a young Egyptian man who reportedly choked on a packet of drugs in police custody, shortly thereafter, but whose fractured face told a different story. In the footage that follows, scenes from “V for Vendetta,” a major motion picture set in a totalitarian future Britain, accompany local events in Egypt that evidence injustice under Mubarak. The result is a powerful storyline that renders the Egyptian Revolution readable. Narratives, like this one, are central to Nathaniel Greenberg's latest book, which illuminates not only what took place during the “Arab Spring,” but why media coverage of it matters.
How Information Warfare Shaped the Arab Spring is an original inquiry into the writing and rewriting of the recent past. Throughout the study, Greenberg carefully examines the construction of narratives and the ideological underpinnings of this collective endeavor during the first three years of the “Arab Spring” in Tunisia and Egypt. On these grounds, it is no wonder the book begins with Mohamed Bouazizi, a Tunisian fruit seller whose self-immolation drew worldwide attention, before moving to the murder of Khaled Said, whose violent death went “viral” online. Instead of detailing how these two separate incidents unfolded, Greenberg calls attention to their transformation from singular events into broader storylines at the hands of multiple actors, from unknown activists to well-known writers. Contrary to the forms of discursive analysis practiced by members of the US intelligence community, Greenberg “refuses to gauge language in a vacuum,” placing texts into context throughout the monograph (pp. 32–33). Among the myriad of materials he examines are newspapers, social media sites, and diplomatic dispatches. The resulting investigation offers key insights into the “Arab Spring” and its aftermath.
By exploring both political developments and discursive shifts, Greenberg effectively unpacks the “reformulation of reality” in revolutionary moments (p. 5). In Chapter 2, he charts the divergent tactics adopted by Egyptian newspapers during the first few days of mass demonstrations in 2011. These rhetorical strategies ranged widely from downplaying protests and underscoring instability to documenting the very same events and publicizing online activism. The military's rise as the guardians of the Egyptian Revolution, Greenberg reveals, was one among many early narratives, in which enduring themes, like chaos, security, and the West, first emerged. Later, in Chapter 3, Greenberg chronicles the ascent and retreat of Abu Ayadh, the leader of Tunisia's Ansar al-Shariʿa, a militant Salafist group that made its presence known following the fall of Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali. He highlights how media outlets competed to characterize Ansar al-Shariʿa and contributed to Ayadh's multi-layered mythology, at times casting him as a government informant and in other moments as a subversive jihadist. Ayadh's story, accordingly, captures the dynamism of Tunisia's mediascape. In subsequent chapters, Greenberg similarly scrutinizes a series of other stories that compel us to rethink several aspects of the Arab uprisings, including the presence of the United States, the role of religion, and the place of armed struggle. Together, these narratives, which read as separate case studies in the book, constitute “the ‘poetry’ that was the Arab Spring” (p. 3).
In covering these complex narratives, Greenberg excels on a few different fronts. First and foremost, he seamlessly places concrete events into conversation with media coverage (in print, over the air, and online). In so doing, Greenberg skillfully navigates important developments “on-the-ground” and in public discourse. Additionally, he uncovers the connections between local and foreign media outlets. By mapping the little studied links among WikiLeaks, news blogs, periodicals, and satellite stations, to consider only some platforms, Greenberg elucidates how words traverse national borders and move across highly interconnected mediascapes. Lastly, the author captures how narratives come into being, compete with one another, and evolve over time. The result is a series of stories that shed new light on some of the major themes of the “Arab Spring,” including activism, nationalism, and Islamism. For all of these reasons, Greenberg succeeds in documenting the creation of select storylines during a time of tremendous change.
At the same time, there are a couple of missed opportunities. First, the author refrains from engaging with relevant scholarship on narratives, mass media, and misinformation in Middle East studies. The absence of this secondary literature is no more apparent than in the monograph's introduction, where Greenberg cites only two related works in passing: Marwan Kraidy's The Naked Blogger of Cairo and Linda Herrera's Revolution in the Age of Social Media. Of particular note, in this regard, is Laurie Brand's Official Stories. A comparative study on national narratives in Egypt and Algeria, Brand's book surfaces a single time in Chapter 4 (p. 95), leaving us to contemplate how Greenberg's findings may productively expand upon Brand's discussion of the stories told by ruling regimes intent on securing their legitimacy and longevity. Instead of intervening in scholarly debates, Greenberg elects to address members of the US intelligence community who analyze texts without taking into account their respective contexts. This choice positions the book well to reach an audience outside of academia, but ultimately limits its contributions to prevailing discussions in the field of Middle East studies.
Second, the histories of many media technologies in the Middle East remain to be written and the author does little to remedy this lacuna. On this front, Greenberg's brief historical insights into censorship (pp. 89–90), oppositional periodicals (pp. 101–3), and cinema as an educational tool (pp. 158–9), are very much welcomed. His overall exploration of information warfare, however, rarely departs from the realm of the present. On more than one occasion, Greenberg introduces Donald Trump's 2016 election when addressing misinformation and “Arab Spring” narratives. In the spirit of reaching a wider readership and highlighting the book's timeliness, this reference is understandable. But what about the history of information warfare in the Middle East? What may competing radio broadcasts during the 1967 War, for example, teach us about misinformation today? After all, narrative battles are not new. In the absence of this broader historical backdrop, it is difficult to assess Greenberg's claim that the “Arab Spring” in Tunisia and Egypt ushered in “an information war of historic proportions” (p. 34).
Notwithstanding these critiques, Greenberg does break valuable ground by offering a detailed exploration of activism, media, and information warfare in relation to the “Arab Spring.” He complicates straightforward accounts of the Internet empowering revolutionaries across the Middle East and bridges multiple lines of intellectual inquiry, including narratives and counter-narratives, digital dissent and surveillance, revolutionary and counter-revolutionary currents. Greenberg's writing, moreover, is engaging. Although some chapters would be easier to follow with a roadmap at the start, and a stand-alone conclusion would afford the author a chance to revisit and reflect upon some of his contributions, the book is well written and would make an excellent addition to courses on journalism, media, and the “Arab Spring.” In the end, those interested in the power and politics of narratives will enjoy this book not only for the content it covers but also the questions inspired by it: How did ordinary people, as opposed to only members of the intelligentsia, construct, contest, and conserve narratives of the “Arab Spring”? What efforts will political authorities in the Middle East continue to take to write, rewrite, and erase recent revolutions? And what is at stake in the stories we tell in and outside of Middle East studies?
