History monographs typically are driven by chronology or thesis. Less often, single-author historical monographs contain a collection of independent thematic chapters dealing with a common subject. Moran's book, American Genesis, fits this third, less common, type. Following an orientating, largely derivative, twenty-four-page introductory essay on the history of the relations between science and religion beginning with ancient Greece and running through the 1925 Scopes trial, the book consists of five chapters addressing historical topics in the American controversy over creation and evolution. Although at least some of these chapters have previously been published as journal articles, read together they offer insight into a fundamentally American phenomenon.
My favorite chapter is the fourth, which deals with the ideology and strategy of the antievolution impulse from the time of William Jennings Bryan's crusade against Darwinism in the 1920s through the spread of creation science during the 1970s to the Discovery Institute's Intelligent Design project of the past two decades. At every stage, Moran depicts antievolutionism as a reactionary impulse to save America from social disorders by safeguarding the biblical account of human creation and Jesus' essential role as the second Adam sent to redeem that fallen creation. For example, he argues that the Christian right adopted antievolutionism as a cause because it provided a ready explanation for social ills (such as legalized abortion, increased acceptance of homosexuality, and woman's liberation) that it abhorred. This chapter concludes by unpacking the Discovery Institute's so-called wedge strategy currently being used to promote the concept of intelligent design. Moran presents this strategy as failing to influence science but somewhat effective in impacting education policy and public opinion.
Chapter 5 is narrower in focus. It begins by trying to debunk the idea that belief in evolution leads to disbelief in religion and concludes with an analysis of various Christian intellectuals – most of them evangelical Protestants – who have publicly reconciled their faith to Darwinism and battled antievolutionism within the church or at Christian colleges.
The first three chapters deal with the role of American women in supporting antievolutionism, the disproportional strength of antievolutionism in the American South, and participation of African Americans on both sides of the struggle. Except for the second topic, which is widely discussed, these issues are both potentially significant and largely unexplored.
Moran's chapter on gender and the antievolution impulse is at once tantalizing and frustrating. Moran uses the proclamations of male antievolution leaders and scattered surveys of popular opinion on Darwinism to depict antievolutionism as a female-dominated reform movement (40). Yet he concedes that virtually all of the antievolution leaders were male. For the modern creationism, he exaggerates the importance of two female activists, Nell Segraves and Jean Sumrall. Sumrall had at best a bit part in the surge of modern creationism and Segraves quickly deferred to her son, Kelly. As Ronald Numbers establishes in his definitive work on this issue, The Creationists (2006), men have dominated modern creationism. When dealing with modern creationism in his other chapters, Moran never mentions either Segraves or Sumrall. Instead, he gives due credit to Henry Morris.
In chapter 3, Moran provides the most comprehensive account so far on African American responses to the Scopes trial. He finds this key group deeply divided, with the black elite backing evolution and many black preachers backing creationism. Unfortunately, the chapter does not systematically analyze either group, relies on anecdotal accounts, and (unlike the other chapters) does not carry the issue forward beyond the 1920s.
In his chapter on regionalism, Moran defends the traditional characterization (dating back at least to H. L. Mencken and the Scopes trial) of antievolutionism as a Southern phenomenon. This stands in opposition to Numbers's emphasis on the broad national sources of creationist leadership from the 1920s to today. Morris's Institute for Creation Research was based in San Diego during its prime and the Discovery Institute is still in Seattle. Further, as Moran concedes, the two best-known evolution-teaching battles of the past fifteen years were fought in Kansas and Pennsylvania. Although I tend to agree with Moran, these points weaken his conclusion.
Despite their limitations, the five chapter essays in American Genesis address significant questions in the history of American antievolutionism and advance answers that should forward the ongoing scholarly discussion of the overall topic.
