In this book, the author analyzes Japanese youth and foreign migrants in Japan under a unifying theoretical framework, i.e., a conflict-labeling perspective, which relates inequality to deviance. The opening chapter provides the outline and aims of the book. Characterizing those two groups as “powerless and yet perceived to be a major threat to the status quo” (p. 1), the author attempts to demonstrate how they are excluded from society and how their deviant behavior is generated and reproduced through various social mechanisms. He is particularly interested in depicting how the images of the two groups are shaped by governmental and corporate control over the mass media. In describing the two groups in these ways, he wants to shed light on how “conflict is an integral and dynamic feature of Japanese society” and thereby to challenge the nihonjinron (discourse of Japanese culture and people) model (p. 1). The author is particularly interested in showing the interconnection between inequality and deviance, which in his view has not been studied much and has been mostly neglected in the mass media. The analysis is based on the author's observations throughout his residency in Japan over a total of 30 years and a review of relevant literature and popular media. The author focuses on the experiences of youth and foreign migrants and tries to portray their lives “through their eyes rather than [the eyes] of those who wield power over them” (p. 17).
Chapter 2 on Japanese youth examines their limited rights and powerlessness, discriminatory social controls over them, and their rebellion against adult authority. The author describes how youths’ behavior is controlled through the national police agency and the national educational system as well as through community and police crime prevention activities at the local level. Institutional delinquency controls are characterized by inequality, and what is called delinquency prevention is actually characterized by “surveillance activities and apprehension and monitoring the youth offender” (p. 22). In school education, youth confront the system of hierarchy and authoritarianism, which, manifested especially in secondary schools, begins at the prime minister's office and the Ministry of Education and shapes educational practices under local authorities. Inequality integrated into social institutions produces various forms of deviance among youth, ranging from bullying and school refusal to gang formation and juvenile crimes. Though stressing that youth as a group are the recipients of numerous adult control measures, the author is attentive to internal divisions, particularly to class distinctions. He points out that delinquency prevention activities mostly occur in working-class communities and that middle-class values prevailing in schools affect lower-class children negatively.
Chapter 3 on foreign migrants describes tight social controls over them, their limited rights, discrimination against them, and the types of deviant behavior often found among them. The basis of inequality for them is their lack of Japanese citizenship. They have limited employment opportunities due to their visa status, and are employed in particular occupations with each foreign group occupying a certain niche and forming a certain class status. Focusing on this aspect, the author offers a brief description of each of the foreign migrant groups, starting with relatively large groups like Koreans, Chinese, Japanese-Brazilians, and Americans, and then discussing smaller groups such as Malaysians and Iranians. The author also discusses foreign migrants based on ascribed traits and social standing, delineating the types of discrimination experienced by foreign instructors in Japanese schools, professional baseball players, laborers, migrant sex workers, and children of foreign descent. He then explicates how the mass media, influenced by those in power, plays a central role in creating negative stereotypes and other barriers to foreign migrants’ adaptation to Japanese society on one hand, and what kinds of deviant behavior they resort to in the face of discrimination on the other.
In chapter 4, the author analyzes the plight of the two groups, using a labeling conflict theory. This theory involves three elements of conflict and labeling: entry, participation, and replication. Members of youth and foreign migrant groups enter the condition of inequality through ascription: by age and nationality. The two groups have limited choices and opportunities as they participate in interpersonal relations and group life within predetermined conditions of inequality, characterized by a set of pre-delinquency criminal laws and middle-class school rules or a set of immigration laws and social controls. The limitations on what group members can and cannot do result in deviant behavior. Their subordinate status within the social structure is institutionalized, replicating the interrelation of inequality and deviance for them.
Chapter 5 summarizes the discussions in the previous chapters and makes suggestions for future research. While admitting that the research he has done for the book is far from complete, the author points out that the field of conflict, inequality, and deviance has received little attention despite the importance of the field for understanding the dynamics of everyday life in Japan.
In my view, the analyses of inequality and deviance revolving around the two groups are not always very convincing. Though analyzed under the same framework, the two groups are discussed separately. A discussion of interrelationships between the situations of the two groups could have enriched the book's argument. Yet, the value of this book lies in demonstrating, through the analysis of youth and foreign migrants, the importance of the field of conflict, inequality, and deviance. As the author stresses, there should be more studies on the working class, student failures, single-parent mothers, physically disabled people, and gays and lesbians, among others.
