Evelyn Tribble mounts a strong case for the power of an integrated approach to the humanities and challenges traditional assumptions about how Shakespeare's Globe might have worked. Seeking to answer the question of how playwrights and players came together and, in such a short time and night after night, put on a play for a demanding audience, Tribble looks for an answer not in the individuals, but in the system – the playing space, plots, parts, playbooks and apprentice system. She points out how many of our readings are anachronistic and back-formulating, based on our assumptions that subtext is more important than text, for example. Extending the cognitive anthropological work of Edwin Hutchins and the cognitive theories of Andy Clarke, among others, Tribble approaches the Globe as a site of distributed cognition, where the cognitive load of the event is spread over and through the people, the environment, the system, so that ‘historical shifts in tools and practices can also be construed as cognitive shifts’ (p. 7). She uses the science, along with a deep knowledge of what the period has left behind (and what it has failed to leave behind, such as particular stage directions) and an acute reading of the plays, to help reimagine Shakespearean performance as a cognitive event, weaving a story impossible without both fields lending their best insight to the mystery at hand.
The early modern theatre created a system that worked to produce theatre, ‘often off-loading the attentional and mnemonic demands of the enterprise onto technological and social structures’ (p. 8). Chapter 1 examines the theatre as a ‘workplace’ and therefore can be informed by contemporary research on how workplaces support, indeed are, the work. Chapter 2 discusses the relationship between language, gesture and action in memory and the craft of the actor. Chapter 3 focuses on the role of hierarchy in the plays and in the company and how that facilitated ‘enskillment’, or scaffolding techniques used to ‘induct novice actors’ (p. 22). Her analysis of the backstage plots as cognitive artefacts that reveal through what they omit insightfully highlights the ‘complex interaction of its component parts and is regulated neither by master-text nor master-director’ (p. 20). The plots needed to be incomplete to be efficient – like a chart or map, they must be read with the ‘skilled vision’ (p. 52) of a player. Seeing the play at a glance was important for an actor playing many small parts; plots could be ‘a calculating device’ and could facilitate ‘shared attention’ like a large whiteboard (p. 52).
We understand our history from within the categories we have created to make sense of the world; cognitive science is redrawing the limits of categories such as mind, body, memory and cognition, and Tribble's book is key text in the effort to rethink, reread, and reimagine what were/are/can be Shakespeare's plays in performance.
