The republication of Thorstein Veblen's 1918 classic, The Higher Learning in America, allows us to revisit Veblen's gift for satire, his powerful analysis of the American university of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era, and the continuing relevance of his critique to the multiversity of our own time. Richard Teichgraeber's introduction and annotated edition helps students and scholars appreciate all three dimensions by filling out Veblen's academic context, explicating textual references, and comparing present with past conditions.
The rightful and only purpose of the university was the advancement of knowledge, Veblen argued, an ideal that modern society had come to recognize as its deepest value. Veblen based this analysis in the evolutionary theories he had laid out in his books The Theory of the Leisure Class (1899) and Instinct of Workmanship (1914).Footnote 1 His modern scientists and scholars were successors to the medieval elites whose universities had been only practical in spirit: their chief concern was for individual advantage, that is, the salvation of their own souls. The scientific bent of modern university elites reflected rather the technical, matter-of-fact character of modern civilization and was fueled by an instinct of “Idle Curiosity” (39).
Veblen's complaint was that this “disinterested pursuit of knowledge” had been corrupted, particularly in America, by “the current system of private ownership” with its business principles of “pecuniary gain,” competitive advantage, and corporate control (67, 88). Universities were governed by boards of trustees composed largely of wealthy businessmen. Through control of the budget and appointment of a university president who controlled faculty appointments and who was “one of their own kind,” they transformed what should be “intimately personal contact and guidance, in a community of intellectual enterprise” into a “business house dealing in merchantable knowledge, placed under the governing hand of a captain of erudition” (92, 232, 94).
Swayed by the business principles of constant growth and competitive advantage, universities had become large aggregates of extraneous function—an undergraduate college, professional schools, extension courses, training programs, undergraduate activities, athletics—all of which distracted attention and absorbed resources that should go to graduate education and research. Maintaining growth and advantage required “the visible success of the concern” and “the esteem of the unlearned,” hence fulsome presidential oratory and academic displays, large fake-Gothic buildings, and the approval of a segment of the leisure class, who were given over to dissipations like Greek-letter fraternities—“competitive organizations for the elaboration of the puerile irregularities of adolescence” (109, 210, 120).
Even more damaging was the need for central control of this unwieldy aggregate. The control of appointments by the president and the stultifying bureaucratic organization introduced by the business-minded administration turned faculty into compliant subalterns and produced “low-cost, perfunctory instruction” (153). Faculty obeisance to business values was particularly damaging in the moral and social sciences, where “the estimate of the unlearned is necessarily in the wrong” (160).
Veblen's Higher Learning is recognizably the product of his own lifetime. Although he looked back on his graduate study in philosophy with Noah Porter at Yale College in the early 1880s as emblematic of true learning, the 1870s and ‘80s also marked the moment when a new group of businessmen alumni, at Yale and elsewhere, were breaking through clerical control. They championed the introduction of modern sciences, providing the support as well as funds for the new, often German-educated faculty. Veblen became a creature of that alliance when he went to the new University of Chicago in 1892 as a fellow in political economy.
It did not take long, however, for points of conflict to emerge. Founded with Rockefeller money and led by the ambitious William Rainey Harper, the University of Chicago was an easy model for Veblen's caricature of the ever-expanding, miscellaneous, hierarchical, and publicity-conscious university. By the 1920s, when Veblen's texts were most popular, and by the end of Higher Learning, his Captains of Industry and Erudition and their acquisitive culture take on the coloration of Mencken's Booboisie. Women suddenly appear as the most active segment of the university's unlearned constituency: “the class of moderately well-to-do and serious-minded women” who enforce the university president's “canons of circumspection” and “sterilization of the proprieties” (215).
Teichgraeber shows that Veblen drew on a substantial faculty critique of university governance. What made his version memorable, however, was his unique combination of relentless logic and brilliant satire. Making repeated warnings that his work not be taken “as an expression of praise or dispraise,” he spun out his analysis in ponderous, convoluted prose laced through with bright threads of wit (188). If some of it belongs to an earlier age, much of it continues to ring true. Any member of a current university faculty will recognize Veblen's sharp contrast between the institutional concerns of the administration and the academic concerns of the faculty, the proliferation of bureaucratic rules, and the description of committees as “in effect if not in intention, designed chiefly to keep the faculty talking while the bureaucratic machine goes on its way” (212).
Teichgraeber points out that Veblen was uncertain about the future—at times he paints a dark picture of the deepening, seemingly inevitable commercialization of the university, and at other times envisions “a fluctuating state of compromise,” so that business control can never be wholly removed but a better balance can be struck (65). Teichgraeber thinks that Veblen's “considered position,” like his own, was the pragmatic one (28). That leaves out, however, the utopian strain in Veblen, the hope that evolution might be leading science's instinct of workmanship to triumph over pecuniary gain and bring the system of private ownership to an end. It was that utopian streak in Veblen that drove both his relentless logic and his satire.
Nonetheless, a “fluctuating state of compromise” seems to have been the reality over the last century. What Veblen did not foresee is that graduate education and research could flourish in the multiversities, so that a new tier of “research universities” emerged at mid-century. That development was largely the result of the powerful role of the federal government in university education and research since World War II. Still, the government's combination of support and control, heavily weighted to national security and economic growth, could easily be assimilated to Veblen's argument. Where Veblen is most lacking is in his dismissal of the value of educational democracy. His advance of knowledge had nothing to do with undergraduate or professional education, which he believed instilled only practical and business values in the culture. The democratic scope of higher education in the United States, however, has spilled over vocational channels. Faculties now have greater power than in Veblen's day, and a century of college and university education has done something to insinuate values favorable to the advance of knowledge into segments of the wider culture.
At the turn of the twenty-first century, however, commercialization appears to have entered a new phase as universities—with needs exceeding the resources of federal and state governments—aggressively seek private funds, cultivate closer ties with business, and embrace their vocational functions. At the same time, business has become increasingly organized by information technology and come increasingly under the control of the financial sector of the economy. The Board of Trustees of the University of Chicago now numbers fifty-five, with about half coming from financial firms and another third from other kinds of business.Footnote 2 Just as their Gilded Age predecessors marked the shift of higher education to the new sciences, these current boards represent the digital, short-term values of today's business culture. Whether a balance can be struck—even at the research universities—is still unclear. Veblen would be disappointed, but not surprised.
