For more than five decades, country music studies have been shaped by one foundational text: Bill C. Malone’s Country Music, U.S.A. Beginning as a doctoral dissertation at the University of Texas and first published as a book in 1968, Malone’s narrative quickly found its way into citations across the fields of folklore, ethnomusicology, popular music studies, and southern studies, among others, in an era when a single monograph could stand as all we really needed to know about a subject.Footnote 1 Surprisingly, despite the disciplinary diversity of country music studies, few scholars have attempted to write alternatives to Malone’s magnum opus, with the notable exception of Mary A. Bufwack and Robert K. Oermann’s Finding Her Voice (first published in 1993 and revised in 2003), which stands as a much-needed corrective to the cishet white male bias of Malone’s text.Footnote 2 In the past twenty years, many scholars have sought to chip away at Malone. Historians Diane Pecknold and Kristine McCusker have edited several significant collections focusing on gender, sexuality, and race in country music production, consumption, and reception.Footnote 3 In their respective work, Karl Hagstrom Miller, Stephanie Shonekan, and Charles Hughes meticulously demonstrate how the very notion of “country music” is rooted in the systemic institutional racism of the culture industries and provide case studies that complicate the eugenic notions of racial and musical purity that surround production, consumption, and reception of the genre.Footnote 4 More recently, a special issue of Journal of Popular Music Studies, edited by Nadine Hubbs and Francesco T. Royster in 2020, brought together a remarkable group of BIPOC and queer scholars to call for the inclusion of diverse viewpoints not only in country music studies but in the country music industry, as well.Footnote 5 Paula J. Bishop and Jada E. Watson’s powerful collection, Whose Country Music?: Genre, Identity, and Belonging in Twenty-First-Century Country Music Culture, extends this ongoing work, presenting provocative counternarratives and showcasing the work of country songwriters and recording artists alongside the academic research of some of the leading voices challenging Malone’s biases, and crafting a more inclusive and historically accurate representation of the genre’s contemporaneous dynamism and complexities. As they note in the volume’s introduction, to address these issues they deliberately set forth to create a space in which the gates are wide open: “the chapters in this collection… pose questions about diversity, representation, and identity as an act of cultural remediation and as they relate to large concepts of artist and fan communities, stylistic considerations of the genre, and modes of production from a twenty-first-century perspective” (4).
Building on Watson’s prior scholarship on the structural biases of the Billboard chart system and her activism within the country music industry, Bishop and Watson call attention to the powerful role that gatekeepers play within the country music industry and country music studies alike and the ways that implicit and explicit biases are replicated within both arenas.Footnote 6 Examples of biased and bigoted gatekeeping are made clear in several essays, including those by songwriter Alice Randall and recording artist Rissi Palmer, who discuss the many ways that their gender and race were expressly commented upon, exoticized, and used to prevent them from being afforded entry into the industry. McCusker’s compelling historical account of the business and legal factors that might have contributed to Clear Channel’s 2003 ban on the music of the group then known as the Dixie Chicks offers a powerful example of how to conduct research using public documents in spaces that are silenced by nondisclosure agreements and old boys’ networks. Watson, too, digs into the practices of the music industry and country music scholars, documenting the ways that racial and gendered biases in the Billboard charts unfairly lead to similar biases in legacy sales and lifetime awards such as induction into the Country Music Hall of Fame; put another way, Watson makes it clear that country music scholars should no longer rely on chart success as a marker of an artist’s importance. Sociologist Rachel Skaggs presents an exceptional ethnographic essay that explores how the so-called “360º deals” that artists began to sign following the rise of digital downloading have made the songwriting community in Nashville more creatively conservative as they attempt to place songs in an increasingly competitive marketplace that has little room for new voices. These essays offer an often uncomfortable glimpse into the sausage factory, and, for scholars of a genre that is often deliberately opaque and superficial, they present powerful examples of the role that oral history, data science, and unconventional archives might play in crafting more inclusive histories of country music.
In addition to demonstrating ways that industry leaders have kept the metaphorical gates of Music Row closed, Whose Country Music? contains several essays that call for the opening of country music studies. In particular, Sophia Enríquez’s theoretically rich essay “Why Country Music Needs Latina Feminism” calls country music scholars—particularly those of us who write about women and women’s perspectives—to account for their ignorance of (at best) or silencing of (at worst) the feminisms of Black, Latinx, and Indigenous writers. Drawing on Mariana Ortega’s notion of “loving, knowing ignorance,”Footnote 7 Enríquez notes that:
The loving, knowing white feminist, if not held accountable, wields the power to construct the very realities she may claim to abhor…. The potential harm, then, is not in white women scholars writing about white women in country music. Rather, the harm is in scholarship that is not intersectional—that does not consider the voices, experiences, or perspectives of women of color alongside issues such as gender and class. (77–78)
Adding to Enríquez’s call for Latinx feminisms in country music studies is Nadine Hubbs’s essay on “country Mexicans”: Mexican and Mexican American country music fans who find country music to be reflective of their cultural values and esthetic preferences. White feminism simply falls short here, and Hubbs’s intersectional work offers a powerful model for paradigm-shifting research.
Several focused case studies offer useful insights into the ways that gender, race, and sexual orientation shape the production and reception of country music. Leigh Edwards, extending her ongoing work on Dolly Parton, examines the ways that Parton uses a variety of media to nuance, complicate, and revise narratives heard in her compositions and seen in her public personae, while Stephanie Vander Wel traces the developments of musical humor in women’s country music of the past to the comedic strategies of contemporary acts, specifically the Pistol Annies, aimed to challenged white patriarchal and middle-class expectations.Footnote 8 Kristina Jacobsen’s essay examines the ways that Navajo country musicians and their music are interpreted through the framework of contested land claims in unceded Indigenous lands, showing that the musical performance is always already shaped by individual audience members’ attitudes toward the occupation of Indigenous lands. And Rebekah Hutten’s exploration of audience reactions to Beyoncé and the Chicks’ performance of “Daddy Lessons” at the 2016 Country Music Association Awards illustrates how white supremacy and misogyny shape the construction and maintenance of genre boundaries in country music, even as artists onstage “[invert] surveillance through acts of resistance as part of the broader effort toward racial equity…” (227).
Bishop and Watson’s Whose Country Music? is an important contribution to the ongoing efforts to rewrite country music history and to affect change within the country music industry. As the studies presented here indicate, there is much work to be done, and it is essential that future scholarship and activism take the philosophical underpinnings of this transgressive work seriously. Malone’s Country Music, U.S.A. will undoubtedly remain the standard for another half-century without such interventions. As the contributors to this volume forcefully argue, there seems to be little economic or political incentive for the industry to challenge Malone’s narrative since it continues to be mined for comforting—if historically false—stories by everyone from the Country Music Hall of Fame and Museum to documentarian Ken Burns.Footnote 9 Whose Country Music? is a much-needed challenge to current scholars, from undergraduates to established professionals, and a call to prospective contributors to country music studies to imagine country music as the vibrant, inclusive, and creative space that it has the potential to be.
Travis D. Stimeling (1980–2023) was a professor of musicology at West Virginia University. They authored or edited several books on country music, including Nashville Cats: Record Production in Music City (Oxford University Press, 2020) and The Oxford Handbook of Country Music (Oxford University Press, 2017).
