Megan Warin's Abject Relations, an ethnography based on the author's extensive fieldwork among people with anorexia in Adelaide, Edinburgh and Vancouver, is a significant volume that expands the possibilities for anthropological engagement in eating disorders research. Problematizing ideas of ‘culture’ in eating disorders, and bringing to the fore space, kinship and sensory experience, Abject Relations goes beyond the familiar terrains of body image and discipline to make anorexic embodiment the centre of analysis.
The anorexic body of Abject Relations is not the body that readers might have come to expect. Although low body weight is present in many of the experiences Warin analyses, she positions the senses, rather than thinness, at the centre of the book. Warin suggests that, while the anorexic body may be disciplined and (at times) thin, it is, above all, a living, sensing, experiencing body. To understand anorexia, therefore, we must conceptualize it as rooted in the body's dynamic being – in pain and longing, scents and flavours, proprioception and touch. Warin guides the reader into and within this sensory world, revealing how the anorexic experience, even at its very extremes, has a ‘logic of practice’ (p. 177) that relies on, and indeed shares, normative societal values. These values, however, transcend conformities to body image ideals or the imperatives of a physicality-abnegating, male-dominated Western society (such as the explanation promulgated by Bordo, Reference Bordo and Bordo2003 [1993]). Rather, Warin analyses anorexic practice as shaped by embodied understandings of the clean and the abject.
Central to Warin's analysis is Kristeva's concept of abjection, which she draws on and transposes from the psychoanalytic realm to the interconnected spaces of sensory and relational experience. Warin charts classificatory, spatial and relational maps of anorexic disgust, weaving together the abjection inherent in the transgression of bodily boundaries with anorexic categorizations of bodies and foods. Abjection, as Warin explicates it, is embedded deeply within the mundane domains of anorexic embodiment, shaping the sensory life thereof. For example, Warin shows how, to many of her study's participants, fat is not merely a ‘bad’ substance, but rather a slippery, seeping, dangerously contaminating material; felt intensely on the skin, the lips and the tongue, fat is to be cleansed away. The body, similarly, is subject to abjection, threatened by food, bodily processes and the porosity of its own boundaries: threats mitigated mainly through dietary restriction and purging, which Warin analyses as practices of cleansing. Significantly, she ties abjection to the reconfigured spatiality and altered forms of sociality and relatedness entailed in anorexic practice. Arguing that ‘[r]elatedness is at the very core of abjection’ (p. 5), Warin shows how abjection inheres in the inversions of public and private, the tensions between kinship and solitude and the formation of communities through the shared embodied knowledge that shapes the everyday lives of people with anorexia.
Positioning abjection and relatedness at the core of the anorexic experience, Abject Relations also raises potential for new questions on the globalization of eating disorders. As Lester (Reference Lester2004) argues, the analysis of eating disorders as globalized phenomena must ask what ‘culture’ is (presumably) transported, and how it might interact and coalesce with local values and structural conditions. In Abject Relations, Warin moves the discussion away from the geographic localities of anorexia and toward a conceptualization of anorexia itself as a ‘transnational process’ (p. 26), winding through (sometimes conflicting) intellectual, institutional and communal fields. Warin's analysis, though based on multi-sited fieldwork, emphasizes not the nation as the variable for cross-cultural comparison, but rather the small-scale spaces in which anorexia plays out. While the geographies of fieldwork often fade into the ethnographic background (indeed, the nationality of many participants remains unspecified), Warin positions the differing spaces that participants inhabit – from their home environments to hospital rooms, recovery group settings, community-based care facilities and normative social locations – as the fields crucial to the lived experience of anorexia. This conceptualization of the field, Warin suggests, reflects the plurality of disciplines, epistemologies and forms of treatment that define anorexia, as well as the anorexic experience itself, with its multiple, non-linear directions and the practice-based kinship it forges across geographic boundaries.
The significance of Abject Relations extends beyond eating disorders scholarship. As an account of innovative fieldwork approaches to embodiment research, Abject Relations enriches the anthropology of the body and the senses, strengthening the engagement between anthropological methods and phenomenological theoretical approaches. Moreover, Abject Relations excels as an ethnography, masterfully weaving together rich ethnographic data, theory, original and insightful analysis and compelling prose. It presents a significant contribution to anthropology and to the wider field of eating disorders scholarship, and has great potential to engage students – across the social sciences, the medical sciences and the humanities – with anthropological analysis, ethnographic writing and the possibilities they hold.
