Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T00:39:25.225Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Racial Segregation and the San Francisco Musicians' Union, 1923–60

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 May 2007

Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The practice of segregated union locals, common in the American Federation of Musicians (AFM) during the first half of the twentieth century, led to racial confrontation in San Francisco. In 1934, black Local 648 sued its much larger counterpart, Local 6, which had attempted to control all musical employment in the Bay Area. Though Local 648 eventually withdrew its suit, its charter was revoked and black musicians were placed in “subsidiary” status. A new “colored local” (669) was chartered in 1946 and worked alongside Local 6 until the state forced amalgamation in 1960. Many other segregated locals did not merge until the late 1960s or early 1970s.

The saga of Locals 6, 648, and 669 brings into focus the complex social and economic forces buffeting the working musician in the early twentieth century. Racialist attitudes in the US labor movement, mirrored in the musicians' union, forced blacks to organize separately and accept lower wages in order to secure employment. The AFM, for its part, was constrained by its dedication to local autonomy. Black union musicians were themselves divided—torn between outrage at their second-class status and the apparent benefits of working for change from within the organization.

Information

Type
Articles
Copyright
© 2007 The Society for American Music
Figure 0

San Francisco in the 1930s: D = Dawn Club, E = Edgewater Cafe, L = Liberty Theater, T = Tip Top Club.

Figure 1

Earl Watkins, 1947 (photographer unknown).

Figure 2

Left to right, Vernon Alley, Bob Barfield, Wilbert Baranco, 1938–39 (photographer unknown).

Figure 3

San Francisco Superior Court Record of Action, case no. 252613, 1934.

Figure 4

Three Local 6 officers, 1934: Walter Weber, Eddie Love, Clarence King (photos published repeatedly in shape The Musical News, photographer unknown).

Figure 5

Post–World War II clubs in San Francisco's Fillmore district. Dots indicate club locations. Specific references mark clubs highlighted in the article: J = Jack's Tavern, C = Club Alabam, M = Minnie's Can-Do, B = Bop City.

Figure 6

“Colored” musicians' locals in 1954. Data are taken from the AFM shape Proceedings of 1954. Los Angeles's Local 767 had merged with its white counterpart, Local 47, the previous year. Locals and their memberships changed monthly; therefore this information represents the situation in the middle of this particular year, when the convention took place. Membership numbers are given in the shape Proceedings for locals sending representatives to the convention. Where such data are missing, the listing from the previous or succeeding year provided an approximate size. Charter dates are not listed in the shape Proceedings until the 1950s. Where an earlier colored local existed, its number is given in the fifth column. For comparison, the corresponding white local number and membership in 1954 are given in the sixth column.