David Fieldhouse’s Western imperialism in the Middle East is essentially a political history of colonial rule by League, latterly United Nations mandate. It focuses primarily on systems and frameworks of governance within each mandate in the region. Yet despite the attention paid to the colonial periphery, this book is one which fits in well with issues concerning the relationship and interaction between the universal and the local, a theme which has recently been given attention by global historians. The one constant of rule by mandate which Fieldhouse identifies as present in each of his case studies, and indeed, one which he argues was inherent in colonial rule in general, is collaboration between rulers and ruled. Indeed, in the case of these ex-Ottoman territories, Fieldhouse argues that there was no possible alternative for the imperial powers to take. For instance, the great degree of continuity of the class structure and the continued socio-political prominence of large landed groups from the period of Ottoman rule to rule by mandate in Iraq is intertwined with the reliance of Britain upon these more or less existing indigenous class and political hierarchies for the application of power. It is this relationship, the interaction between a broader force, and the way in which it adopts and is adapted to on a local level, which for Fieldhouse acts as a useful means for explaining the different outcomes of rule by mandate in each of the countries concerned. Furthermore, Fieldhouse draws a broader distinction between French and British rule, based upon the greater tendency of Britain to attempt to govern through existing social and political structures, whereas the French were more distrustful of indigenous forms of rule, thus making more difficult, if not impossible, any sort of workable collaborative arrangement. This point should only be drawn so far, however, and it is important that ‘Western imperialism’ should not be depicted as a force more homogenous than it was. This implies the need for a greater focus on the domestic and global forces driving both British and French imperialism in the Middle East in this period, and an attempt to distinguish specific factors and aims which influenced the form rule by mandate took in each case. This is in no way a criticism of Fieldhouse’s study, but rather is suggested as a theme which could be usefully explored further by global historians. Such an approach would also allow for a greater analysis of the importance of the Middle East for the Western Powers within a global framework, both in terms of the geo-political and strategic significance of the area and as a region of interest for various economic groups and networks.
Despite these wider themes being implicit, this book is in fact a tightly focused study in which ‘Western imperialism’ could be usefully read as ‘British and French colonial rule’ and the ‘Middle East’ as ‘colonial mandates’. The study is a synthesis of the existing literature concerning each mandate, usefully brought together here, with the focus being upon explaining the impact of rule by mandate on the political and social structures of each country. The book is structured around three parts. The first deals with the period predating rule by mandate and contains two chapters. The first chapter is concerned with the pre-war period. Here Fieldhouse argues that narratives of an inevitable Ottoman ‘decline’ down to the First World War are misplaced and that the impact of internal disturbances in the form of Arab Nationalisms was very limited, such groupings being very much in their infancy. The concomitant of this argument is brought out in the second chapter, where emphasis is placed upon the events of the First World War, which acted as a disruptive external factor causing the fragmentation of the Ottoman Empire. The second, and by far the longest, part of the book is concerned with the period of rule by mandate. The first four chapters consider those countries placed under British rule, Mesopotamia/Iraq, Palestine and Transjordan. The remaining two chapters in this part evaluate French rule over Syria and Lebanon. Palestine emerges as Fieldhouse’s main concern, being the subject of two chapters, the first being specifically dedicated to evaluating the origins of the mandate and the role played in this process by Zionism. The final section contains a single chapter entitled ‘Conclusions’, where the successes and failures of British and French rule by mandate are placed in comparative perspective and an attempt is made to relate the forms of rule imposed in this period to the development of post-mandate forms of governance.
Fieldhouse describes this book as a ‘by-product’ of his earlier (2002) work on Wallace Lyon. However, Western imperialism in the Middle East, as a book which engages with the broader themes discussed above, can also be usefully read and considered in the context of the number of influential studies of imperialism produced by Fieldhouse. Particularly noteworthy in the context of the interaction of imperialism, as a globalizing force, and the colonial periphery, is his broad study, The West and the Third World (1999). Fieldhouse’s most recent work, then, lends itself well as an introduction to, and synthesis of, a very broad literature on the Middle Eastern mandates. Especially valuable for those new to this subject is the bibliography, usefully subdivided by the focus of each chapter. However, for those new to the topic, this book is not the most easy to read, dealing as it does in great depth with diplomatic minutiae. It is also, on occasion, somewhat confusing, as the way in which the book is structured means certain key events are often repeated at different points throughout the text. These, however, are minor points. Fieldhouse has produced an excellent book, one of appeal to both specialists and a more general audience alike.
