What does it mean to take on Said? And why is it that every time scholars who have been shaped by Said's work critique Said, they use Said to do so? When critiquing the hypothesis in Orientalism they use his contrapuntal reading in Culture and Imperialism or his discussion of etymology in Humanism and Democratic Criticism. There is something symptomatic about taking on Said that implies that they're always in Said. So they read Said against himself, doubling and multiplying him, critiquing the excesses or dogmatic appropriations of his corpus. They break him up into different positions and concepts, playing them against one another but always avoiding a confrontation with Said and Said's work as a whole. Though their critique appears as an act of betrayal of Said's oneness, it is the only critique that keeps them in Said, in his corpus, carrying the weight of his legacy. Such an act of betrayal, which makes the very critique possible, implies that they can never revisit Said without Said himself, or revisit orientalism without Orientalism.
This process of breaking apart, repositioning, juxtaposing, and contrasting is at work in Joseph Allen Boone's queering of orientalism—and Orientalism. The Homoerotics of Orientalism reexamines classic orientalist texts (Flaubert, Loti, Gide) as well as European and Middle Eastern literary and visual material from the early modern period to the present, much of which would be unfamiliar to readers. Boone moves from different historical contexts and genres—from T. E. Laurence to the film 300—to interrogate the fixity of notions of tyrannical virility and its homoerotic implications and modes of dominance. His impressive archival research and reading strategies engage the complexities of the object of representation thought to be constitutive of the orientalist fantasy. Boone seeks to disturb the interpretive overdeterminacy of the binaries of East/West and colonizer/colonized, acknowledging their power yet refusing to reduce literary and visual works and cross-cultural interactions to their dynamic. Instead, he looks at inconsistencies, contradictions, and incongruities that might alter the ways in which the orientalist canon has been established and critiqued.
“The Homoerotics of Orientalism probes the deep history of homoerotic fascination and homophobic aspersion that has played no small role in contributing to this mythic divide” (p. xxi). Boone's work seeks to counter what has been firmly established as a “European heterosexual fantasy” that has been projected onto the Middle East more specifically. “[T]he practice of Orientalism theorized by Edward Said has frequently been viewed as a heteroerotic one,” Boone argues, “in which an all-powerful, masculine ‘West’ seeks to penetrate a feminine, powerless, and sexually available ‘East’ in order to possess its resources” (ibid.). What is to be retained from Boone's formulation is “mythic divide.” The word “mythic” mines the “divide,” opening it up to myth, and in so doing puts in question its stability and epistemological claim. Critiquing the heteroerotic framework, which depicts the ways in which Said's Orientalism “has frequently been viewed,” opens up the possibility for other modes of viewing, other perspectives—blurry images in need of close readings.
The instability Boone identifies in orientalism is thus in Orientalism. He engages this instability through a queer reading of orientalism, starting with Orientalism's book cover (Gerome's “Snake Charmer”) and moving to the works of Lawrence Durrell and Norman Mailer. Then he claims: “For the deconstructive entrance of homoerotic desire into this genre brings into focus ‘situations, experiences, people and objects’ often overlooked in readings predisposed to locate a demonstration of Said's thesis (whereby West equals male and East equals female)” (p. 340). Exploring poses (painting, photography), following textual drifts, recognizing gestures, and capturing echoes, Boone seeks to queer Orientalism and open it up to its multiplicity of meanings and implications.
Boone's book inhabits the space that separates yet brings together orientalism and Orientalism, an inescapable space of complicity, haunting, and resistance because the negation or affirmation of Said's work as a whole is always elusive, romantic at best. Boone attributes this romanticism to those critics who read literary and cultural production in order to demonstrate Orientalism's hypothesis. Stuck in Orientalism rather than in Said, these critics are no longer able to see the implications and scope of Said's work. Seeking to confirm in each text Orientalism's hypothesis, argues Boone, “paranoid readings” have not only closed down interpretation but have also rendered Said stable and one with himself, missing his drift and the drift of the literary and visual texts that he engages. Boone, however, gives too much credence to these dogmatic readings that, for instance, deny Middle Eastern homosexuality. In order to refute their argument, he turns to Najib Mahfuz, Youssef Chahine, and Alaa Al Aswany as proof of an alternative perception. This quick turning to the Middle Eastern text for evidence or counterevidence often reifies the latter, undermining Boone's comparative and “contrapuntal” practice.
In the end, what Boone offers us is not a linear history of the homoerotics of orientalism, but rather a history that evolves through ruptures and jumps, from 17th-century Turkish and English narratives of homoerotic love and desire to the Queen Boat Affair in 2005. The book outlines a critical direction for reading and research at the intersection of scholarly traditions involving European literary studies, Queer Theory, and Middle Eastern Studies. It is an engaging and well-researched book that would be relevant to academics and a nonacademic audience interested in this subject matter.
