In the United States, millions of students have relied on financial aid from the federal government to pay for college. As the “sticker price” of college has risen over time, the percentage of students depending on Pell Grants and student loans has increased as well. As Congress debates its current reauthorization of the Higher Education Act, Deondra Rose’s important book brings to light a consequence of higher education policy that has not received attention: the advancement of women.
Prior research has attributed women’s progress to the women’s rights movement, their entrance into the labor force, and advances in contraception. Rose shifts our attention to federal higher education policy. She provides a fascinating account of the ways in which the federal government’s policies generated policy feedback, leading to increases in women’s college attendance and political engagement. Specifically, she shows that by offering grants and loans to students regardless of sex, the National Defense Education Act (NDEA) of 1958 and the Higher Education Act (HEA) of 1965 made college affordable for women who otherwise might not have attended, while Title IX of the 1972 Education Amendments banned sex discrimination in college admissions. These policies were a “one-two punch sequence in an assault against gender inequality in higher educational access” (p. 3). Rose argues that by opening up college to women, these changes transformed women’s place in society, granting them political and socioeconomic independence, or “first-class citizenship.”
In the first chapter, Rose documents that women’s participation in the economy and political engagement has increased since the 1960s. She lays out her dependent variable, “first-class citizenship,” which she defines as “full inclusion in American social, economic, and political life” (p. 2). However, the use of this concept is one of the book’s weaknesses. The concept is too broad, and Rose cannot fully test whether women achieved it. Moreover, by defining her outcome as first-class citizenship for an entire group of people—a high bar for any society—she invites the criticism that only a portion of the population attends college. Did women not attending college also gain first-class citizenship? Less educated women might not have experienced the same “inclusion in American social, economic, and political life” as their college-going counterparts. More explanation for the mechanisms connecting higher education policies and first-class citizenship for all women is needed.
The second chapter provides a useful history of U.S. higher education. Rose shows that U.S. higher education policy was not made for women. However, the first schools to include women were midwestern land-grant colleges and state universities, which accepted women because women taxpayers demanded it. Land-grant colleges in sparsely populated areas were more likely to accept women because it was economically advantageous. This foreshadows the author’s argument about the unintended consequences of federal higher education policy to come.
In Chapters 3, 4, and 5, Rose carries out case studies of the passage of the NDEA, HEA, and Title IX. These are the book’s strongest chapters. She relies on a rich array of qualitative sources, including in-person elite interviews, subcommittee notes, commission reports, and oral histories. In Chapters 3 and 4, Rose argues that the consequences of the NDEA and HEA for women were unintended. She shows that the NDEA was passed on the heels of Sputnik, prior to the women’s rights movement. It was marketed as a defense bill that would allow the United States to better compete with the Soviets. The fact that income was the only financial aid criteria was meant to placate Civil Rights advocates wanting nondiscriminatory language, while the bill’s transfers directly to students appeased Southern Democrats wanting to avoid pressure to desegregate. As a result, the bill was the first welfare policy to provide benefits to citizens in an ungendered way. Similarly, the HEA was pushed by President Lyndon Johnson as an antipoverty measure, not explicitly for the benefit of women. Title IX, addressed in Chapter 5, was deliberately meant to address the problem of sex discrimination in higher education. Together, the three bills made college accessible to women by providing redistribution while preventing discrimination.
The only shortcoming in these excellent chapters is that Rose does not sufficiently address the role that policy feedback may have played in between the bills. It is possible that each policy generated its own positive feedback, making each subsequent bill more likely. For example, she attributes the passage of Title IX to the work of elites becoming increasingly aware that sex discrimination in education was a problem. She argues that absent their work, this legislation would not have occurred because “sex discrimination was largely conceptualized as a matter of individual misfortune” (p. 103). Moreover, women were not participating in politics at the same rates as men, and the women’s rights movement was not yet active.
Still, policy feedback may have already been at play. Even if women were not participating politically at the same rates as men, they may have been participating politically more than prior to the passage of the NDEA and HEA. Rose’s own evidence supports this possibility. She shows in Chapter 6 that federal student aid increased attendance rates among women more than among men, and in Chapter 7 that women with more education during this period were more politically engaged. If these findings are true, then by the time that Congress was considering Title IX, many more college-educated, female, financial-aid beneficiaries would have been politically engaged than before. On the other hand, if policy feedback played no role in the passage of HEA and Title IX, that is also interesting and has important theoretical implications for the timing of policy-feedback activation. Rose might have addressed this point.
Chapters 6 and 7 test the author’s theory that federal higher education policy led to first-class citizenship for women by drawing on three national surveys. As mentioned, Rose cannot actually measure or test citizenship, but she shows compellingly in Chapter 6 that student aid increased women’s educational attainment. She also argues that because these policies impacted women’s college attendance, it raised their socioeconomic status, although she does not directly test this connection.
Chapter 7 uses a difference-in-differences design to examine whether federal financial aid generated policy feedback. Rose finds that eligibility for financial aid increased political participation among women. She attributes this to resource effects as a result of additional years of education. The author determines financial aid eligibility by cohort. She does not distinguish whether actual aid receipt shaped political participation. While this may be because of data constraints, it is an important limitation. While also not perfect, in order to increase the validity of her comparison groups she might have used a regression discontinuity design (RD) similar to Croke et al. to examine college-going cohorts right around the years that the NDEA, HEA, and Title IX were implemented (see Kevin Croke, Guy Grossman, Horacio A. Larreguy, and John Marshall, “Deliberate Disengagement: How Education Can Decrease Political Participation in Electoral Authoritarian Regimes,” in American Political Science Review 110(3), 2016).
Overall, Citizens by Degree is a novel contribution to our understanding of women’s advancement, and it offers a new case of policy feedback that scholars in this tradition can add to the well-known work of Andrea Campbell, Suzanne Mettler, Joe Soss, and others. This is a valuable study that should be read by scholars interested in the politics of education, policy feedback, and American political development.
