No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 24 February 2006
The Enlargement of the European Union and NATO: Ordering from the Menu in Central Europe. By Wade Jacoby. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004. 287p. $70.00 cloth, $23.99 paper.
The enlargement of Europe has proven a lush garden for researchers to cultivate new approaches and theories of international and comparative politics and reengineer older approaches and theories. Many of these studies fit under the larger rubric of the “Europeanization” of the Central and Eastern European (CEE) countries and focus on the external impact of the European Union on the political and economic reforms of the new members of the EU and/or NATO. Good examples include the works of Frank Schimmelfenning and Ulrich Sedelmeier (The Europeanization of Central and Eastern Europe, 2005) and Milada Anna Vachudova (Europe Undivided: Democracy, Leverage, and Integration After Communism, 2004). Wade Jacoby's piece fits squarely into this large and excellent body of growing literature—theoretically sophisticated, methodologically sound, and well written.
The enlargement of Europe has proven a lush garden for researchers to cultivate new approaches and theories of international and comparative politics and reengineer older approaches and theories. Many of these studies fit under the larger rubric of the “Europeanization” of the Central and Eastern European (CEE) countries and focus on the external impact of the European Union on the political and economic reforms of the new members of the EU and/or NATO. Good examples include the works of Frank Schimmelfenning and Ulrich Sedelmeier (The Europeanization of Central and Eastern Europe, 2005) and Milada Anna Vachudova (Europe Undivided: Democracy, Leverage, and Integration After Communism, 2004). Wade Jacoby's piece fits squarely into this large and excellent body of growing literature—theoretically sophisticated, methodologically sound, and well written.
Impressive in his attention to detail, smooth writing style, and adherence and familiarity to notation and the body of literature, Jacoby brings his rigorous analytical approach to the question of how and why policy elites in CEE countries often emulate or chose (“ordering from the menu”) established Western practices in various policy arenas (regional policy, agriculture, consumer protection, health care, civilian control of the military, and military professionalism). As he notes on page 5, “the book explains two patterns: the kinds of emulation CEE elites attempt and the outcomes of reform that follow from these efforts.” He develops a typology of emulation “modes” that seeks to make sense of what is often a complex, disordered process of borrowing from Western structures. In addition to the modes of emulation, the range of outcomes vary according to the density of the rules involved and the density of the actors involved. For example, high density of actors involves well-established patterns of state and social actors, and the high density of rules implies a large extent of international organization demands. From these typologies, a number of labels are used to describe the emulation modes and outcomes underway in CEE countries.
Some of these labels are more easy to understand than others. Problematic for me was the use of the terms “scaffolding” and “homesteading” as two types of outcomes. Jacoby recognizes some of the problems associated with such labels, but they do demonstrate the inherent complexity and difficulty in coming up with easy-to-understand labels, and they raise some concern about the face validity of these concepts. Whether one agrees or not with the typologies and the various labels, the author is systematic in his approach and application of the model in the rest of the book.
The primary case studies (forming Chapters 2–6) are largely drawn from the Czech Republic and Hungary, although there is some discussion in the last chapter that includes Poland, Bulgaria, and Ukraine. The Introduction and Chapter 1 lay out the analytical and theoretical models that seek to explain the process of emulation. These chapters also help us understand when emulation results in more effective and efficient institutions and when it results in less efficient and effective outcomes. Both areas—following the causal trail of emulation and answering the question of effectiveness—are central to our understanding of the enlargement of the EU and NATO and democratization more broadly.
The strength of the work lies in its focus on the detail of policy arenas that do not always receive as much attention in the Europeanization literature, such as consumer protection and health care. Crossing the border between enlargement of the EU and NATO and drawing out the similarities and differences in this experience (especially noted in the chapters on civilian control of the military and military professionalism) are also helpful to scholars sometimes too narrowly focused on their respective areas (EU Studies, Security Studies, etc.). Jacoby allows scholars from respective area studies both to learn from each other and to draw some generalizable explanations of the process of democratization in differing policy arenas (security policy, social policy, agricultural policy). In a scholarly world often criticized for overly narrow research, in this regard the author opens up the door to communication and dialogue that is very welcome indeed.
Jacoby is cautious in his claims and understands the various limitations to his approach. He is aware of the potential methodological and theoretical pitfalls of his model and the theoretical basis—“embedded rationalism” (the focus of Chapter 2)—employed. In many ways, embedded rationalism relies on older, less complicated concepts of the two-level game and even older versions of the external–internal models employed by Wolfran Hanrieder, James Rosenau, and others in the 1960s and early 1970s. Jacoby notes this point on page 20 in his discussion of embedded rationalism: “CEE elites acted rationally in the face of two kinds of broadly material incentives: from their voters and from the IO's [international organizations] themselves.” Why do the typologies have to be so complicated in order to reflect this basic interaction? One related and additional concern with this study focuses on the attempt to synthesize various “institutionalist” approaches to come up with an explanation for emulation modes and outcomes. While I commend the attempt to synthesize, at times one gets the sense that the author is theoretically “ordering from the menu” of institutionalist approaches. Is this an “integrated paradigm” (p. 29)? As Jacoby himself admits, he does not seem quite ready to go that far.
The audience for this work is clearly at the advanced graduate level and scholars operating in the field of European studies, international relations, and comparative politics. This study contributes to the enriched conceptual and theoretical debates that focus on Europeanization and institutionalism. Students and scholars familiar with these debates will have much to digest here (especially in the examination of embedded rationality and institutional theories) and likely will have much to pick apart as well. More importantly, this study has illuminated a larger part of the map that is the Europeanization of the CEE countries—a map that still has many unexplored areas to uncover.