The introduction to Freddie Rokem's Philosophers and Thespians begins with an epigraph by Walter Benjamin, which suggests that it is characteristic of philosophical writing to “confront the question of representation” (1). The book itself offers profound and diverse territory for exploring the dialectic relationship between the ways in which an event is incorporated into the philosophical discourse on the one hand, and the ways in which it is enacted theatrically on the other. Rokem represents in its own discourse the question of representation by staging the performance of encounter between “philosophers” and “thespians.”
The book is divided into two parts: Part I, “Encounters,” consists of four chapters; Part II, “Constellations,” of two. In these six chapters, Rokem offers his reader a variety of agones featuring the philosophical and the dramatic in conversation: the classical, semifictional context of Plato's Symposium (Chapter 1); an internal debate featuring Hamlet, who aspires to be both a philosopher and a thespian (Chapter 2); and an exchange of letters between two personages who never met face to face, Nietzsche and Strindberg (Chapter 3). Part I ends with meetings between the dramatic thinker Benjamin and the philosophical man of theatre Brecht (Chapter 4). Key concepts from these meetings reappear in the first chapter of Part II, “Accidents and Catastrophic Constellations: Performative Agendas” (Chapter 5); the book concludes with Chapter 6, “Wishes, Promises, and Threats: The Performative Storytelling of Walter Benjamin,” in which Rokem discusses Benjamin's Denkbild.
Despite Rokem's clear and accessible writing, the sketch above could create the general impression that his book is a little eclectic and scattered; to my mind, its underlying rationale could be expounded in a more declarative way. Rokem's framework can nevertheless be seen as an invitation by which readers are challenged to fulfill the book's encounter-creating function themselves, locating the connections among Rokem's interlocutors. All the interactions, and most strikingly those between Benjamin and Brecht, are not strictly an interchange of forms and ideas but are placed in a multilayered context; in fact, Rokem's selective editing of the encounters ultimately creates a cohesive narrative.
It is possible, and even easier, to understand Rokem's journey in time if we reverse the book's chronology (which starts with the classical ground of Plato and ends on the edge of World War II). The writer, and with him the reader, not only follow the measured backward walk of the angel of history—Benjamin's image, which is frequently discussed in the book—but find themselves at a stage where the archive has imploded and become a constellation of images and stories. Benjamin's Denkbild story, which ends the book, offers an attempt to hold on to history after experiencing it as a catastrophe that has realized the potential for accident; this potential finds its foundations in Nietzsche's modernist drama of madness and in the symbolic battle between the Dionysian and the Apollonian, the latter of which finds its precedence in turn in Hamlet's premodern hesitation. As the classical foundation, Socrates possesses this story, including knowledge of his own imminent death a priori. His character knows the indispensable value of the dramatic embodiment that is performed through the network of encounters and contests throughout the book—between philosophy and drama, between the genres of tragedy and comedy, and between the types of desire engendered by Eros.
Rokem's is ultimately a move of theatricalizations, encounters that take place on the stage of the fictional or the real/historical, and which are realized in representations or images such as Hamlet's monologue, in which he likens himself to a risible actor (in Hamlet, act 2, scene 2). The theatrum mundi metaphor is not directly discussed by Rokem; however, throughout the book, the dialectic between philosophy and theatre allows us to understand the thespian as a philosopher and the philosopher as someone who understands the theatre of the world as founded on the act of “staging […] the self” (87)—or what I may also call “theatrum persona.”
Another of Rokem's focal points is the critical image—a crucial state of bodily, mental, or political crisis and disruption; I would argue that he makes a connection between the krisis (the Greek form of the crisis), and the critical stance of the kritikos (or judge). The most explicit expression of this is the “accident,” a gestus that takes on several forms throughout the book. The accident discussed in Chapter 5 is specifically the social and historical distillation of a potential threat, which since the end of the nineteenth century is connected to technological acceleration and transport. The ascription of the discourse of the accident to the prewar period is relevant and disturbing; however, it seems to me that it should have been augmented, within this modern context, by some contemporary elaboration.
The most significant constellation in Rokem's book, in my view, is the incisive connection he makes between the crisis revealed in the accident and the question of identity that accompanies both the thespian-philosopher and the philosopher-thespian. In the book's first chapter, the riddle of the Sphinx becomes a pattern of investigation that ties Oedipus’ identity to his misfortune. In Chapter 2, “‘Who's There?’: Hamlet as Philosopher and Thespian,” Hamlet is torn between these two poles without finding wholeness. In Chapter 5, which features further discussion between Brecht and Benjamin, Kafka's short text “The Next Village” offers a concise example of the bond between identity and crisis as it indicates different ways in which man is subject to a potential accident while traveling to a neighboring village—a journey for which an ordinary lifetime will not suffice.
Despite the gestus of crisis, the riddle of man is shifted in this book from simply being human to the challenge of being humane. Reading Philosophers and Thespians is an invitation to move from performative embodiment to philosophical insight, to see beyond particular histories but also to examine the stage of “I” on which one can act.
