Secrecy in the Sunshine Era challenges a facet of what might be called the Bush–Cheney hate doctrine, the idea that between 2001 and 2009 America became a closed society obsessed with the imposition of secrecy in the name of national security. Reacting to a whole series of claims that the Bush administration had what the New York Times called “an extraordinary mania for secrecy,” Jason Ross Arnold cautions that the Bushite malpractices should be considered in historical perspective (7).
Arnold outlines a chronology of secrecy. For him, the main turning point in recent times came in the 1970s, in his estimation a rare period of “punctuated change” (2). In the wake of Watergate, the Pentagon papers and federal enquiries into intelligence abuses, Congress passed a Privacy Act that empowered citizens to request files that the government had compiled on them, amendments that strengthened the Freedom of Information Act, the eponymous Government in the Sunshine Act, the Presidential Records Act, and the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA). They amounted to a statement in favour of the right to privacy at the individual level, and against the federal right to privacy in public affairs.
There was also digitalization. The digital revolution that was under way would soon empower the government to snoop more effectively on private citizens, but, in the “sunshine era” of the 1970s, it empowered citizens to use search engines to find out about developments in the darker crevices of national politics and administration. Even the most manipulative officials recognized the legislation's power. Secrecy in the Sunshine Era has the following acknowledgement by Secretary of State Henry Kissinger: “Before the Freedom of Information Act, I used to say at meetings, ‘The illegal we do immediately; the unconstitutional takes a little longer.’ But since the Freedom of Information Act, I'm afraid to say things like that” (1–2).
The author's main contribution is to show how it all went wrong. Successive American Presidents deployed a “secrecy toolbox” to frustrate the intent of the 1970s legislators (5). The facts about Agent Orange (the US's chemical warfare weapon) and about antibiotic resistance in Mid-western hog farms were amongst the many that were repressed. Arnold uses the 1970s term “out of control” to describe what happed both to the secrets classification system and to President Barack Obama's use of the National Security Agency to pry into the affairs of one and all (4, 370). A Bush administration official remarked in 2004 that it might be possible to get rid entirely of the 1970s judicial process that governed secret searches and wiretapping: “We're one bomb away from getting rid of that obnoxious court” (49).
His deployment of such evidence indicates that Arnold does not shy away from saying that the Bush–Cheney administration greatly undermined American civil liberties and open government. He also judges that Democratic Presidents have been more transparent than their Republican counterparts, and that Presidents Bill Clinton and Barack Obama were ahead of the transparency pack. His overall thesis remains, however, that American openness has been on a steady downhill trajectory since the 1970s. This, especially in the case of the Bush–Cheney administration, he attributes to an “expansive view of presidential power some would deride as monarchist” (137).
Arnold's book is a comparative study of the records of post-1970s Presidents. But, he tells us, that was not his original goal. This was “to track the globalization of freedom of information laws and then compare how they fared in practice” (xi). An investigation on these lines would have yielded some interesting evidence. On the one hand, government in the sunshine is not an American invention. Scandinavian nations pioneered the practice in the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. On the other hand, it is clear from the available evidence that the American reforms of the 1970s did have a major influence internationally. Arnold authoritatively shows us what has gone wrong since the 1970s; nevertheless, the revolution that his country started in that decade is still going on worldwide.
