Shirdi Sai Baba (d. 1918) and Anandamayi Ma (1896–1982) were highly revered saints of the modern era who presented strikingly divergent socio-religious personas. Shirdi Sai Baba stands out for his interreligious ambiguity: his parentage was unknown and his religious origins were disputed, but he followed practices from both Hinduism and Islam, had devotees from both religions, and could be readily approached through Hindu and Islamic traditions. Anandamayi Ma, by contrast, was definitively a Brahmin, acculturated to orthodox ways even as she sometimes ignored them. If her behavior was often idiosyncratic and her spiritual presence was felt, like Sai Baba's, to transcend any religion, she nevertheless honored conservative traditions, with her ashrams running according to Brahminical rules that suited her many old, high-caste disciples—but which could alienate more ordinary devotees and the expanding number of foreign seekers who came to her.
The two saints, moreover, behaved differently as holy persons in the world. Sai Baba first appeared as an aloof, young mendicant, showing up sometime in the 1850s in Shirdi, a small village about 80 miles from Aurangabad, Maharashtra. Some say he stayed for a few years and left for a while, while most agree at least that he came there (perhaps a second time) in 1858, never to stray long or far again. Slowly, he attracted devotees and eventually a large following as the towering saint of Shirdi, a lone ascetic rooted in a place. Anandamayi appears by contrast as someone who moved in the world while still transcending it. Recognized as special while a girl in rural East Bengal, she was married off young to an older husband who recognized her spiritual nature and eventually became a helper in her work—without, they say, ever consummating their marriage. She went with him to Dhaka, where she gained a following, and then left on her own initiative to settle for a while in Benaras, but she kept moving—increasingly, as her following developed, within a network of ashrams maintained by her disciples. And even as the number of her devotees kept growing, she continued to forge individual relationships with some of them.
The two saints nevertheless had important commonalities: in contrast to the majority of those revered as spiritual masters in India, neither of them claimed (or actually seemed to have had) distinct spiritual lineages of their own, a fact that helped make each of them appear to their own devotees as a unique divine presence. When each died, their perceived uniqueness meant that there was no serious possibility of a successor arising who was able to play a role equivalent to the past saint, while their lack of lineage meant that devotees were faced with the task of maintaining (and/or propagating) their gurus’ spiritual presence and moral legacy with no explicit traditions to guide them.
Karline McLain and Orianne Aymard each tell the story of the transformation of one of these figures from a living holy person to a saint whose presence remains effective in the world. The different developments they show us depend on the contingencies of the holy persons themselves and of their main followers, as well as the varying timespans the authors cover. But they also depend on the distinctive stories that the authors aim to tell.
Writing nearly a century after Sai Baba's death, McLain is able to take a long view, looking at how different religious interpretations of Sai Baba developed and the significance of Sai Baba movements for contemporary Hinduism. In particular, she takes issue with scholars who see the increasing Hinduization of Sai Baba (who was most likely born a Muslim) as an index of his ownership by Hindu rightists. Although she agrees that increasing Hinduization of the saint's image is happening as his cult continues to spread in India and abroad, she argues that the people doing the Hinduizing are not Hindu rightists but moderate reformists who want to make a place for a more open, composite culture within a wider Hindu world. By telling the stories of several of the most important past and current Sai Baba enthusiasts, she makes a convincing case.
The different Sai Baba enthusiasts treated by McLain have had, to be sure, their own visions of what a wider, more open Hindu world should look like and hence of Sai Baba's place within it. Das Ganu, a professional religious entertainer who toured Maharashtra during Sai Baba's lifetime, sang hymns to the saint of his own composition amid those to traditional Hindu deities. Thus placing Sai Baba among the divinities, he spread awareness of the saint throughout Maharashtra, advocating inter-communal harmony if only moderate reform to Hindu caste traditions. Much later, in 1936, Narasinghaswami, a retired Indian nationalist—after an eleven-year search for a living guru—visited the Shirdi shrine and found his guru in the spirit of the Sai Baba there. Never losing his political consciousness, Narasinghaswami saw in the worship of the religiously ambiguous saint an antidote for the sectarian strife troubling the India he knew. Successfully spreading his vision of Sai Baba's message among a mostly South Indian Hindu population, he taught an approach to the saint through Hindu ritual that he had found effective himself. Then, in the 1970s, Bollywood writers and directors saw in Sai Baba a saintly hero who could provide religious succor to all Indians (Shirdi ke Sai Baba [1977]) or a key supporting player in a story of national integration (Amar Akbar Anthony [1977]). Other notable spiritual personages, such as Sai Baba's younger contemporary Meher Baba or Satya Sai Baba of Puttaparthi, who claimed to be his reincarnation, would give the widely revered saint a particular place in their own visions of the workings of the divine on earth, while less well-known enthusiasts continue to spread versions of his message across India and the globe.
All the figures described by McLain have linked Sai Baba to their own agendas, but most often in ways that seem sincere or at least understandable. In unpacking their different visions, McLain is schematic in her outline—neatly identifying her actors’ key roles in the spread of Sai Baba worship—but she is not simplistic in her presentation, respecting the complexities of her religious subjects, their limitations, and their inevitably mixed motives. In doing so she has produced a clearly written and artfully crafted book that tells us much about how religious movements can take shape.
Aymard tells a story that is in many ways more intimate. Writing much closer to the time of her subject's passing, she is able to talk with people who knew Anandamayi during her life as well as those who encountered her later. Her book is thus thick with long quotes from devotees describing what their guru's death made them feel and think. Nothing here is particularly neat or clear, but much can be moving and some offers rare insights into the workings of religious minds under stress. This is particularly so in the three last chapters of Aymard's five-chapter book—on devotees’ experience of Anandamayi during her final illness, their attempts to understand her lasting presence, and their continuing institutional travails. In these we learn that the process of Ma's leaving her body at her Kankhal ashram, near Dehra Doon, was a prolonged process, beginning with a marked deterioration of her health at the end of 1981 and culminating on August 27, 1982. With Ma meeting disciples increasingly less often, she was said to have let herself die slowly so that they could gradually get used to not seeing her. After her passing, some disciples still did, in dreams and visions—but not all. Most, though, continued at least to have a sense of Ma as an abiding presence that transformed them—sometimes in spite of poorly functioning ashrams where Bengali Brahmin disciples with orthodox ways held outsized influence.
In analyzing devotees’ voices, Aymard distinguishes between those of early disciples, who knew Ma when she was alive, and new ones, who came after her passing; Indian disciples and Western ones; and people oriented toward personal, impersonal, or non-dual aspects of the divine. She is able to point out understandable patterns in the characteristic responses of the different groups and occasional surprising similarities across the board.
Aymard's fine-grained and sympathetic study of the personal and institutional responses of Anandamayi's disciples to the passing of their guru is presented as an example of the post-mortem cult in Hinduism, with “cult” used in the French sense of a worship tradition. This conceptualization adds some laudable breadth to the study, but also some extra baggage. Thus, the first two chapters, while also containing some voices of devotees, are much more dispassionate than the last three and seem detached from them. The first chapter, describing Ma's ashrams, their administration, and the cycles of public worship that take place in them is mostly straightforward description. The second is a long treatise on the cult of relics in Hinduism. While much in the first chapter certainly needs a place in the book, the second chapter—worthwhile in its own right—might have found a more generally appreciative audience in a specialist journal. Throughout the book, Ma is contextualized through references to other modern saints, particularly Sri Aurobindo and Sri Ramakrishna, and her cult through a rather eclectic analytic frame. Thus, the last chapter on the cult's “sustainability” is grounded in Weberian ideas of charisma and routinization, with references to Bourdieu on Weber, Habermas, and some current scholars on Indian saints, but the earlier chapters are framed largely through old-school history of religion: Eliade on hierophany, yoga, and the sacred; van Gennep on ritual process; Rudolf Otto, William James, and Raimundo Panikkar on experience. Although these authors are now largely out of academic fashion, they may still speak to many readers interested in Anandamayi Ma.
In her conclusion, Aymard suggests that the rich data she offers might “provide a platform for further research, especially with respect to the religious experience of the faithful …” (p. 247). That data, to which she offers some insightful analysis, is the book's great strength, and it is a valuable one—which McLain offers us only in a relatively few interviews with current enthusiasts. Thus, where McLain skillfully presents broad-stroked religious understandings and the ways in which people bring together ideally nonsectarian faith and social action in a religiously inscribed world, Aymard shows us deep, sometimes painful, religious emotion and the complex religious reflections of people attached to a guru who is no longer there for them in the flesh. Distance, we see, can bring clarity, but glimpses into the complicated personal “religious experience of the faithful” are most easily had close up.
