This book can be reviewed within two contexts: as the purely scholarly work originally intended, or as historical background to the catastrophe that occurred in New Orleans shortly after the author completed his manuscript. Read, as it was written, before Katrina, it would have been a readable, thoroughly researched and detailed history of the rise of the tourist industry since the end of World War II. Read in the wake of the disaster, it rises to a different level by documenting the sad decline over these decades that made the city vulnerable to a fearsome combination of natural disaster, neglect, apathy, and human error. Katrina was a considerably more complex event than suggested by media coverage. To comprehend the complicated racial, class, governmental, economic, and engineering forces that lay behind what seemed to many as a sudden natural disaster demands historical perspective on how this city reached such a vulnerable condition. Mark Souther's New Orleans on Parade contributes to that understanding.
Consider this study first as a scholarly work. Though focused on the postwar tourist industry, it is not purely an urban economic history. To explain how the city largely displaced its prewar economy by focusing increasingly on tourism, the author explores the often arcane, even bizarre, cultural, social, and political machinations that dominated the postwar debates regarding the city's economic future. Souther thus devotes considerable space to conflicts centering on the French Quarter, Mardi Gras, and Dixieland jazz, all elements of the distinctiveness that made the city an attractive and potentially profitable tourist center. New Orleans was like no other American city, historically and culturally.
But in common with other Southern cities at war's end, it faced a critical choice between joining an emerging New South that was seeking tighter integration into the national economy, or holding onto its past. In New Orleans that past was a unique and storied one. For many locals, tourism seemed to offer the best of both worlds. This book explores the resultant conflicts among contending interest groups vying to control the city's economic destiny. Many of the “old family” elite opposed rapid modernization. Yet not all of the wealthy power structure resisted change. Philanthropist Edgar B. Stern and his wife Edith, daughter of Sears magnate Julius Rosenwald, for example, used their considerable influence to support and lead efforts to improve the local economy. But conflict was common. Financial newcomers came into contention not only with the “old money” but with preservationists. Other groups apparently feared that business expansion, including building new hotels or acquiring a major league football team, could upset the Jim Crow laws and traditions. Early postwar mayor de Lesseps “Chep” Morrison, generally a force for change, envisioned the city as the logical center for trade and commerce between the United States and Latin America. Under his administration local leaders took substantive steps toward this goal by establishing, as an example, the International Trade Mart. This vision for international business relations never fully materialized, and prospects for its success dimmed as the decades passed.
Souther reveals how the battle for the new economy ultimately centered on the old French Quarter. There the diverse elements of race, social class, ethnicity, tradition, business, and politics clashed most clearly. The Quarter is known not only for its architecture and its history but for its reputation as a place for pleasure seeking and indulgence. It was the perfect foundation upon which to build an expanding tourist trade. This area's importance motivates the author's extensive discussion of such cultural icons as jazz and Mardi Gras. The now-notorious Superdome played a significant role in the struggle to create a convention and tourist economy. Some readers interested specifically in the tourist industry and related economic issues might find the degree of detail on seemingly noneconomic influences excessive. His discussion of the secretive social underpinnings of Mardi Gras or the fortunes of jazz and its prominent musicians might initially seem distractive from the economic theme, but the author makes a convincing case for its importance in understanding these conflicts and the ultimate economic transformation of this urban area. New Orleans is a place perplexing to many, perhaps most, Americans. This volume helps explain this puzzling town.
There is another perspective from which to approach this book. For those still puzzled and curious about the Katrina aftermath, the details in Souther's narrative become quite relevant. At least some of the local response before and immediately after the disaster must be related to the area's poor economic condition. But how could a city that had been so prosperous and economically vital during most of its history slide into such poverty and general economic decline since World War II? A single sentence in the book helps answer this question. Commenting on newly elected mayor Moon Landrieu's belief, stated in 1970, that the city should capitalize further on its tourist image, the author says, “Economists' warnings that the city could not realize its potential while remaining dependent on tourism, shipbuilding and the port went unheeded” (p. 159). They remained unheeded for the rest of the century.
The compromise that led New Orleans down the tourism path, and away from the models of Houston or Atlanta, produced long-term consequences for the standard of living by creating a “one-crop economy” with a low occupational ladder. Businesses left for other southern cities, the port slipped in relative national importance, and the historic districts risked becoming, as one chapter is entitled, a “Creole Disneyland.” Tourism could not fill the void. Nor was it the basis for creating high-paying jobs. Poverty grew. In retrospect, not creating a more diverse local economy hurt many people. Reading this book helps reveal how critical choices from the past rendered the city susceptible to any severe shock. Tourism was not the single cause of the Katrina aftermath, but it is emblematic of bad choices made. On 29 August 2005, history caught up with current events. New Orleans on Parade provides many clues to the mysteries still surrounding Katrina and today's Crescent City.
