Persistent Imbalances
This review essay explores recent scholarship on the history of Jews in the post-Habsburg territories, before and after the Second World War.Footnote 1 The impressive wave of scholarship that has emerged in recent decades on European Jewish history shortly before, during and, increasingly, after the Holocaust, has only made historians more aware of how much they have left to do to reconstruct, at least in text, the lives of European Jews – a multilingual and culturally, economically and politically heterogeneous group – that the Holocaust so systematically and brutally destroyed.Footnote 2 Aiming to overcome reductionist attempts that either subsume the history of Jews under a national narrative or parcel it into separate national units without comparative or transnational agendas, a growing number of scholars aim to reconceptualise Jewish history as being crucial to European and global history.
There are still significant imbalances in research on Jewish history in different regions of Europe. Attempts to write Jewish history into broader European narratives has been hindered, until recently, by the scarcity of scholarship on East-Central Europe. Since 1989 the historiography of the Holocaust has increasingly focused on Central and Eastern Europe, including regionally focused research on Nazi German occupation policies in ‘the East’ and country specific monographs on other key regional participants, such as Romania, Slovakia, Hungary or Croatia.Footnote 3 However, this has not been accompanied by a similar growth of international interest in the major Jewish communities of Central and Eastern Europe. Yet, in early 1939 the largest Jewish communities of the continent resided in Poland and the Soviet Union, followed by Romania, Hungary and what still remained of Czechoslovakia after the Munich Agreement.
In contrast to the extensive scholarship on the history of Jews in Germany and Poland, the historiography dealing with the multifaceted post-Habsburg spaces appears to have lagged far behind. This absence is even more striking when one considers that substantially more Jews lived in this region than within the territory of the Third Reich itself, and that a significantly higher number and proportion of them were murdered by 1945. For this reason, three out of the four English language works to be reviewed below are of particular relevance. However, there is clearly more to link the scholarly agendas of their authors, Kateřina Čapková, Rebekah Klein-Pejšová and Anna Cichopek-Gajraj. Their books amount to comparable attempts to write Jewish history in the age of the Holocaust without viewing all key aspects as determined by the massive impact of persecution and genocide. As I shall aim to show below, they ask new research questions that promise to emancipate Jewish historiography on Central and Eastern Europe in its extended age of catastrophes from the priorities of Holocaust Studies.
From Neglect to Emancipation?
Writing the history of Jews in East Central Europe remained highly politicised in both East and West after the Second World War. The early post-war wave of murderous anti-Semitic violence and the vicious anti-Zionist campaign of 1968 justly made communist Poland infamous for its treatment of its few Jewish survivors, but such ignominies were far from exceptional across the region.Footnote 4 At the same time, however, Poland was the only Eastern Bloc state where a Jewish Historical Institute was established in 1947, and research on Jewish history remained institutionalised throughout the socialist period.Footnote 5 In other Eastern Bloc countries, however, key facets of the Holocaust, especially the depth of local political and social involvement in genocide, as well as the varied roles Jews had played in local societies, were neglected in historical research. Jewish history tended to appear only in publications focused on local history, which had a very restricted circulation, or in the dissident mode of ‘counter history.’Footnote 6 There was a notable increase in the intellectual and broader public engagement with Jewish topics during the last decades of communist rule.Footnote 7 Nonetheless, when Yehuda Don and Victor Karady released their edited volume A Social and Economic History of Central European Jewry in 1990 (which defined the geographical limits of Central Europe more in the spirit of their famed contemporary, Milan Kundera, than in the sense of a Germany-centered Mitteleuropa), many of the contributors had every reason to approach their topic as terra incognita.Footnote 8
The unwillingness of scholars to tackle Habsburg and post-Habsburg Jewish history was, however, far from restricted to one side of the Iron Curtain. If there was one book that encapsulated the key role of Vienna in modernist culture for Western audiences during the late phase of the Cold War, it was Carl E. Schorske's Fin-de-siècle Vienna, published in 1979.Footnote 9 Remarkably, it was in 1989, when a dramatic scholarly reorientation was about to begin in the study of all the other post-Habsburg spaces, that Steven Beller released his Vienna and the Jews, 1867–1938. In this book, Beller set out to demonstrate how ‘the Jewish background’ of the cultural élite of the city – in fact of the liberal bourgeoisie as a whole – was a factor of ‘utmost importance’ unjustly neglected in Schorske's otherwise majestic explorations.Footnote 10
Jewish history writing in and about Central and Eastern Europe during the post-communist decades was shaped by paradoxes and controversies. This scholarship emerged in a politically charged context after 1989 as a visible revival of Jewish religious and ethnic self-identification and the increased salience of Holocaust remembrance emerged alongside increasingly public expressions of anti-Jewish resentment. New treatments of Jewish history could thus acquire symbolic importance and several authors went as far as to conceive of the role of Jews as crucial to the making of modernity.Footnote 11 However, Jewish history frequently remains excluded from the historiographical mainstream in Central and Eastern European countries. Whereas Jewish history could be construed as a major challenge to the ethnic nationalist canons of interpretation, local adaptations of Jewish Studies were, ironically, often also based on rather strict ethnic distinctions; the integration of Jewish history into the national and European mainstream may in fact have been helped and hindered in nearly equal measure by the recent institutionalisation of Jewish Studies as a separate field across the region. The status the field has acquired over the past decades has evidently facilitated the accumulation and transnational exchange of new results, but its successes may also have contributed to a rather narrow focus on processes within the Jewish world and the construction of Jewish identities.Footnote 12
After 1989 Jewish historiography in Central and Eastern Europe at first remained in the shadow of new preoccupations with the history and memory of the Holocaust.Footnote 13 Remembering the murdered Jews and studying the process that led to the genocide against them took precedence over exploring their socially integrated, while specifically Jewish, lives before and also after the Holocaust. While the former issues were already promoted as broad national concerns, the latter were still often understood as a matter of interest only to members of the now often tiny Jewish communities. It took a younger generation of scholars from Central and Eastern Europe, many of whom (and this ought to be mentioned here since it constitutes a novelty) are not themselves Jewish, for Jewish history writing to become intellectually more wide-ranging and potent. As a result of this transformation, Jewish history is increasingly studied not only because of its distinguishing features and for what differentiated the experiences of Jews from those of non-Jews, but also in order to reveal how heterogeneous Jews were and what they shared with others on the different scales of national and European history. The ambition to make Jewish history in twentieth-century Central and Eastern Europe relevant beyond the ‘lessons of the Holocaust’Footnote 14 has in the meantime yielded new approaches to Jewish experiences in the twentieth century. This new scholarship seeks to find alternatives to concepts drawn directly from the contemporary vocabulary of the Holocaust, such as witnessing, survival and trauma.Footnote 15
Rather than focusing on Jews as passive victims in the Nazi-dominated parts of Europe, this new wave of scholarship has instead foregrounded Jewish subjectivities and agency. The move towards deconstructing the homogenous image of Jewish victimhood was motivated by the opening up of archives and new empirical materials, as well as new conceptual approaches with parallels to an influential stream in post-colonial historiography.Footnote 16 Such emphases are obviously not meant to ignore Jews’ ever narrowing scope of action and predominant experience of victimhood, but they do imply a conscious rejection of retrospective teleologies of genocide and can also help symbolically restore the human dignity of the victimised. But the growing number of monographs and edited volumes on the early post-war moment in European Jewish history do not simply challenge the notion that Nazi extermination policies had been fully implemented and that European Jewish history would have therefore come to its devastating end by 1945. These studies also aim to challenge the dominant narrative about traumatised – forcibly silenced and largely passive – survivors. Discourses of Holocaust trauma as we know them today were not institutionalised until several decades after the end of the war, and survivor self-identification at first also remained rare. We now have sophisticated analyses of Jews’ multifaceted, even if often ultimately rather unsuccessful, attempts to rebuild their lives and communities in Europe. Another key outcome of research into the early post-war moment has been the rediscovery of the long neglected efforts of Jews to document the genocide in its immediate aftermath (for this see, above all, Laura Jockusch's Collect and Record), which amounts to an exposure of the supposed initial silence surrounding the Holocaust as a myth.Footnote 17
Choosing between Competing National Narratives in Interwar Bohemia
This gradual and by necessity only partial shift away from the focus on Jews as helpless victims and traumatised survivors constitutes the background and context of the four books under review here, which all explore the broadly conceived age of the Holocaust (c. 1918 to c. 1967) from new angles. They are Rebekah Klein-Pejšová’s dense and intriguing Mapping Jewish Loyalties in Interwar Slovakia; Kateřina Čapková’s Czechs, Germans, Jews?, a multifaceted and original overview of Jewish national ideologies and organisations in Bohemia during the same period; Anna Cichopek-Gajraj's Beyond Violence on Jewish survivors in Poland and Slovakia during what Dan Stone has recently described as the process of the liberation in his The Liberation of the Camps Footnote 18 and the edited volume Postwar Jewish Displacement and Rebirth by Manfred Gerstenfeld and Françoise S. Ouzan, which connects its admittedly somewhat more conventional focus on trauma and rehabilitation to its key interest in post-war Jewish migration.
Engaging with scholarship on the construction of nationalities in the Czech lands, Kateřina Čapková’s Czechs, Germans, Jews? argues that ‘communities with the potential to become a nation can overlap’ (5). Here her line of enquiry is similar to works such as Jeremy King's Budweisers into Czehs and Germans and, more recently, Ines Koeltzsch's Geteilte Kulturen. Footnote 19 Čapková agrees that it was not unusual for Jews in interwar Bohemia to be nationally indifferent, to cite Tara Zahra's much discussed analysis of this phenomenon.Footnote 20 However, her interest is precisely in that influential minority of Jews who were active in various national movements. What is more, Čapková’s well-researched book asserts that identity – which she understands as subjective, plural, negotiable and flexible – has played a key role in the modern history of the Jews of Central Europe.
In concurrence with Leora Batnitzky's How Judaism Became a Religion, the starting point of Čapková’s book is that definitions of Jewishness have sharply diverged in modern times.Footnote 21 Focusing on debates about Jewishness in interwar Bohemia in particular, the monograph analyses the three leading national narratives about the Jews being Germans, Jews or Czechs as articulated by Jewish lawyers, writers, doctors, journalists, university students and professors, and embedded in organisational structures of various strengths. Czechs, Germans, Jews? thus consciously extends the pioneering research in Hillel Kieval's The Making of Czech Jewry to paint a detailed picture of the three competing interpretations of Czech Jewish identity that evolved in the interwar period.Footnote 22
The structure of this cogently argued book follows each of the three streams of Jewish identity mentioned above. The first two chapters, however, are more of an introductory nature, sketching the historical background to the social, cultural and religious development of the Bohemian Jews. They discuss, in somewhat conventional fashion, the legislative setting and census results. Chapter three covers all those Jews of Bohemia who preferred to use the German language and tries to explain why there was no better organised and more successful German-Jewish movement in the interwar period. As Čapková convincingly shows, even before the emergence of Nazi Germany, all Jewish narratives in Bohemia were shaped by Jewish loyalty to the newly established Czechoslovak state and this directly hindered the spread of pro-German Jewish political activism. As elsewhere in the post-Habsburg space, Jewish affinities with German language and culture did not translate into support for the vision of a German-dominated Central Europe – and the origins of this bifurcation had little to do with the strength of German anti-Semitism. Čapková also documents the curious lack of success of the Czech-Jewish movement. At the moment when most Jews had integrated deeply into Czech-speaking society and had adopted the Czech national narrative, the Czech-Jewish movement was caught in decline. This was partly due to the difficulties of motivation and mobilisation once many of the movement's chief goals had been achieved. But the main reason was that – its key goals conveniently overlapping with those of the Jewish national movement – the Czechoslovak state, instead of supporting the Czech-Jewish movement, preferred an alternative strategy to solidify its dominance.
In her analysis of the Jewish national movement, Čapková first sketches, in a somewhat derivative manner, the special character of cultural Zionism in Bohemia,Footnote 23 which yielded a moderate political programme. She subsequently reveals, in a much more original fashion, notable similarities between the narratives and identities of members of the Jewish national and the Czech-Jewish movements. Both movements struggled to gain a privileged position in the Jewish community and in relations with leading Czechoslovak politicians. Asking why the Jewish movement was more successful in acquiring leading positions in most places (though not in the predominantly Czech-speaking interior parts of the country, except Prague), Čapková argues that, rather counterintuitively, the political strategies of the Zionists conveniently converged with those of the Czech politicians, who encouraged Jews to identify as members of the Jewish nationality rather than as Germans or Hungarians. Moreover, she shows that the dominance of the Zionists was partly due to the relative weakness of institutionalised anti-Semitism during the 1920s and 1930s in Czechoslovakia, rather than a reaction against attacks on Jewish rights.
Czechs, Germans, Jews? also explores why individual Jews chose one narrative and organisation over another. Here the author finds that such choices were due more to the social ties Jews had with other Jews as well as non-Jews than their levels of societal integration or any distinct linguistic matter or political preference. Thus an individual's choice of membership in a particular organisation did not necessarily define their identity. Recognising that further evidence would be required to develop a more precise explanatory model, the author suggests that relations within families and among friends, early school years, university life, workplace experiences and even seemingly chance events could all prove decisive in the choice of national affiliations among Bohemian Jews. It is worth noting that, having a clear focus on the minority of active members in these competing national organisations, the book does not aim to discuss the Jewish population of Bohemia at large. However, the author does note that the unequal distribution of members in these organisations, i.e. the clear majority of the Zionists, does not directly reflect the national identities of Bohemian Jews, nor does the specifically skewed results of Czechoslovak censuses offer a reliable guide to Jewish subjectivities.
Czechs, Germans, Jews? places the case of Bohemia on the European map in an intriguing manner when it explains that, as ‘neither Yiddish culture nor an important class of Jewish workers existed in Bohemia, and the absence of eastern European immigrants only confirmed the secular nature of the Jews of Bohemia’, they might be considered ‘more “western” than the Jews of Western Europe’ (245). Moreover, the book shows that Bohemia was a highly specific place in the history of Zionism too since ‘in no other European society into which most Jews had integrated did adherents of Jewish nationalism win greater social and political status and respect’ (247). It is indeed one of the chief merits of this even-handed monograph that it convincingly accounts for this counter-intuitive Jewish national success in the only functioning democracy of Central and Eastern Europe shortly before the catastrophe.
The Paradoxical Consequences of Reorienting Loyalties in Interwar Slovakia
Mapping Jewish Loyalties in Interwar Slovakia by Rebekah Klein-Pejšová is based, in contrast to Czechs, Germans, Jews?, on the premise that in modern Jewish history the question of loyalty took precedence over that of identity. According to Klein-Pejšová, the efforts of Jewish citizens to prove their individual and group loyalty to the state by living up to explicit demands of citizenship, and the recurrent and often malevolent questioning of their commitment, are the red threads that connect epochs in this tumultuous history. More specifically, Mapping Jewish Loyalties in Interwar Slovakia traces the ‘geopolitical reorientation’ of Jews from the Kingdom of Hungary to the new state of Czechoslovakia. It focuses on three dominant elements of this overarching transformation: the creation of new and deeper bonds of solidarity through refugee aid, welfare work and self-help programmes; the rise of Jewish nationality and national politics, a tendency espoused by the majority of Jews in Slovakia and, third, the transformation of Jewish territoriality, by which the author means the reorganisation of the communal infrastructure and the reshaping of Jewish public spaces to anchor the community locally and within the boundaries of the new state. In addition to analysing the ways in which Jews aimed to express their loyalty, the book also devotes attention to how Czechoslovak state actors (such as government officials, demographers or police investigators) as well as members of the surrounding society approached, traced and assessed these Jewish efforts to demonstrate loyalty.
After the First World War the newly defined territory of Slovakia became part of a unitary state dominated by Czechs. A key part of post-Habsburg Czechoslovakia, post-Hungarian Slovakia remained fiercely contested during a period when citizenship and state belonging already tended to be viewed through a national lens but the nation state system remained fragile. Interwar Slovakia thus constitutes an excellent choice for an in-depth study of Jewish geopolitical reorientation after the disintegration of the Eastern empires. Moreover, Jews in interwar Slovakia have been neglected in international historical scholarship, although the Hungarian historian Éva Kovács has addressed the question of Jewish loyalty in the major local town of Košice.Footnote 24 In subsequent years a Slovak secessionist movement gained independence on a somewhat reduced territory and an increasingly Nazi-dominated continent, and became the first country allied to Nazi Germany to organise the mass deportation of its Jewish population to Auschwitz-Birkenau. However, these developments unfortunately largely fall outside the scope of Rebekah Klein-Pejšová’s brief book.
According to Mapping Jewish Loyalties in Interwar Slovakia, Slovakia provides an intriguing case study because before the First World War its 135,000 Jewish citizens experienced, largely in accordance with other Orthodox Jews in the Kingdom of Hungary, ‘high levels of Magyarization at varying rates of accommodation’ (9). In 1918 they were dislocated from their established patterns of behaviour and expectation and came to face inverted state and social relations: the previously suppressed Slovaks suddenly acquired majority status whereas representatives of the Hungarian majority became members of a disadvantaged minority. Thus, at the starting point of her study Klein-Pejšová explicitly departs from previous treatments of Slovak Jewry as a separate ethnic group as articulated, perhaps most notably, by Yeshayahu A. Jelínek.Footnote 25 Instead, Mapping Jewish Loyalties in Interwar Slovakia argues that the emergence of (a geographically rather than strictly nationally defined) Slovak Jewry was ‘tied to conditions created by the movement from empire to nation-state’ and the result of an ‘arduous process of shifting political loyalties’ under civic and linguistic conditions that were not conducive to Jewish integration into the culturally defined Slovak nation (17).Footnote 26
The first chapter of the book examines social relations in Slovakia during and especially in the immediate aftermath of the First World War against the backdrop of Slovakia's convoluted and violent incorporation into Czechoslovakia. This constitutes a logical place to begin; whereas the chances of Slovak nation building were scarce before 1914, the war years of mobilisation and social transformation were of key importance in the country's piecemeal emergence. Chapter two explores, in a comparable manner to Čapková’s book, the post-war evolution of nationality policy in Czechoslovakia and the place of Jewish nationality within it. Chapter three in turn focuses on the territorial insecurity of the Czechoslovak state and how its agents paid special attention to feared accomplices of Hungarian irredentism. The charge of irredentism was also used as a pretext to pressure Jews to cut their ties to Hungary and Hungarian Jews, a telling illustration of how seemingly more democratic forms of nationalism came to resemble undemocratic ones. The state increasingly viewed minority loyalty as a problem of national security rather than domestic sociocultural conflict. The subsequent and last chapter of the book begins in 1930, by which time the administration recognised that Jews had relocated their political loyalties as citizens of Czechoslovakia. However, the author subsequently shows how, as tensions continued to rise during the 1930s, their status as a separate nationality set them apart from the Czechs and other nationalities. What is worse, they were left utterly helpless when interwar Czechoslovakia was eventually destroyed and replaced by the Slovak state.
Mapping Jewish Loyalties in Interwar Slovakia aptly emphasises that whereas the dominant mode of state building during the period fused questions of language, nationality and territory and viewed minority loyalty as a matter of state security, in newly established Czechoslovakia belonging to the state nationality was not an exclusive marker of loyalty. The Czechoslovak state in fact invented the category of Jewish nationality precisely to endow it with loyalist connotations. To many Jews in interwar Slovakia it appeared that choosing Jewish nationality would offer the best compass to chart the treacherous road ahead after the imperial collapse. Supporters and opponents of Czechoslovak state building viewed this choice in very different ways. For the former, Jewish nationality was a means of measuring loyalty to the dominant political community, whereas those members of the Hungarian and German minorities belonging to the latter category tended to perceive it as an attack on their language-based minority rights. What further complicates the picture is that in spite of the numbers of registered Czechoslovaks being on the rise among the Jews, the Slovak Jewish assimilationist movement remained a rather negligible force. Slovak nationalists – among whom, as Miloslav Szabó has shown, anti-Semitism was a widespread current from early onFootnote 27 – were thus also critical of Jews’ reorientation.
The invention and spread of Jewish nationality was thus an ambivalent process with momentous consequences. It resulted in state support for Jewish national minority rights, but also helped to redefine the concept of ‘nationality’ from a linguistic-cultural category to a subjective ethno-racial one. Based on census results, efforts to create distance from Magyarisation in the newly defined territory of Slovakia may have proved highly successful; as a result, Jewish nationality would henceforth be decoupled from language. One consequence of this was the renewed dominance of the German language in Slovak Jewish public life – a profound irony which Klein-Pejšová’s book, being marginally interested in matters of cultural identity and the workings of multiculturalism, notes only in passing. It was tragic rather than merely ironic that the decoupling of Jewish nationality from linguistic markers also facilitated the exclusion of Jews by all major nationalist forces active in the territory once the Czechoslovak state crumbled. In other words, the emphasis on loyalty brought some extra benefits to Jews under the consolidated Czechoslovak regime but also contributed to their subsequent special vulnerability. It proved a double-edged sword indeed, which Klein-Pejšová should have done much more to reflect on, if only she had not closed her book at the beginning of an even more controversial period.
The Power of Yearning for Normality in Abnormal Times
Anna Cichopek-Gajraj's Beyond Violence, the third monograph under review, compares the experiences of Jewish survivors of the Holocaust upon their attempted return to the homes they had so brutally lost in Poland and Slovakia. Cichopek-Gajraj maintains that the existing historiography, which is certainly much more voluminous regarding Polish than Slovak Jews, is heavily skewed towards Jews’ continued experience of violence and subsequent emigration. Moreover, she argues, previous historical narratives tend to contain an element of determinism, suggesting that Jewish attempts to rebuild their lives had been an impossible undertaking from the beginning and emigration the inevitable outcome.
Beyond Violence insists that such utter failures of homecoming do not amount to the entire story of post-war Jewish experience in Eastern Europe (233). Without ignoring the experience of violence, Cichopek-Gajraj explains that the early post-war interactions between Jews and non-Jews cannot be reduced to anti-Semitism. The book shows that the early post-war moment was not only characterised by grand projects of ‘ethnic homogenization’ and retribution, everyday violence and fear (aspects that Keith Lowe and, more specifically for the case of Poland, Marcin Zaremba have recently analysed in depth),Footnote 28 but also by reconstruction efforts and the hopes of a transition to a better world. In a rather characteristic balancing act, Cichopek-Gajraj emphasises that the Kielce pogroms of 1946 resulted in the emigration of 120 000 Polish Jews, but another 100,000 stayed whose agency and experiences also deserve attention.
Beyond Violence is interested in efforts to return to ‘normality’ in deeply ‘abnormal’ times and the specifically Jewish story of reconstruction from the ashes of the war (27). It focuses on the interactions between Jewish survivors, the state and the majority population at sites where public and private lives intersected – the reader is invited to enter public offices, courts, city halls and the headquarters of various organisations, both Jewish and non-Jewish, to explore the multiplicity of Jewish experiences in the immediate aftermath of the Holocaust and the diverse types of encounters with non-Jews. More specifically, the opening chapter is devoted to the first days of freedom, the journey and the return to ‘no home’. It is followed by two chapters on property restitution and its role in shaping post-war relations. The book also offers, despite its more categorical title, a comparative narrative of anti-Jewish violence in its broader cultural context. The subsequent chapter analyses the struggle to obtain citizenship, especially in Slovakia, whereas the two closing chapters approach various attempts to build families, take up work again and find ways to belong to communities.
Adopting a comparative approach, Anna Cichopek-Gajraj explores the various dynamics and outcomes in these two rather different milieus. As well as highlighting the relevance of local and regional factors within both countries, the study examines a host of factors that make her comparative approach fruitful. Whereas Cichopek-Gajraj can point to the greater role played by early post-war violence in Poland, she finds higher emigration rates in the case of Slovakia which, of course, complicates any simplistic correlation between the two phenomena. Her research also reveals that, in contrast to the manifold Polish Jewish break with patterns of the past, the economic and religious patterns displayed by Slovak Jews in the early post-war years were conspicuously similar to those of the much larger pre-war community; a majority of the latter community of survivors nonetheless decided to emigrate within a few years.
Beyond Violence also analyses Jews’ attempts to rely on the local state, which led, particularly in the case of Slovakia, to extended and intriguing cases of what the author calls ‘negotiations of justice’, including restitution claims. Even though the wartime Slovak state was heavily involved in the Holocaust, early post-war Czechoslovakia did not extend any special forms of recognition to Jewish survivors from Slovakia's reincorporated territory; with the government conspicuously uninvolved, their status often remained unregulated. The book amply illustrates how, as a result, surviving Jews were compelled to pursue an elaborate and often tense dialogue with state authorities – mere loyalty was far from enough.
These are all persuasive analyses. However, several of the central claims of the book – for example, that Jews employed various stratagems of normalisation with varying degrees of success, or that the return to normality may have been brief and interrupted, but nonetheless remained an option – are perhaps a little predictable. Similarly, the author's concluding argument that her approach has revealed how ‘Jewish individual and communal life was still possible in both Poland and Slovakia, even if for a short period of time’ suggests a rather rudimentary use of the comparative method (233). The fact that several countries in Central and Eastern Europe had larger communities of Holocaust survivors than Poland or Slovakia throws further light on the limitations of Cichopek-Gajraj's comparative agenda. Next to Great Britain and France the largest Jewish communities west of the Soviet Union resided in Romania and Hungary, where the majority of Jews did not leave, even as they were exposed to further deadly violence before and during the imposition of communist regimes in their countries. The disproportionate influence of the violence and emigration narrative, which Cichopek-Gajraj's book does well to challenge in the cases of Poland and Slovakia, ultimately appears to be a primarily Polish rather than a broader Central and Eastern European concern.
On Destroyed and Recreated Homes
The edited volume Postwar Jewish Displacement and Rebirth, 1945–1967 studies some of the major patterns of Jewish migration and the various hardships connected to the rebuilding of European Jewish communities in previously lost or entirely newly established places of home. The product of Israeli-French cooperation with authors from several other countries, the volume draws on presentations held at Tel Aviv University in the spring of 2011 to dissect sociological as well as more conceptual issues related to major early post-war waves of Jewish migration, prominently including those of refugees. The volume juxtaposes major contexts of these early post-war streams of migration: the challenges of reintegration and assimilation after discrimination and deportations as in the case of France, the social exclusion and severe threats Jews had to face in North Africa and the Eastern European experiences where, according to the editors, acts of violence and the imposition of dictatorship played key roles. In the latter sense, the editors essentially reiterate what Anna Cichopek-Gajraj aims to nuance.
Postwar Jewish Displacement and Rebirth, 1945–1967 is divided into four major sections devoted to the plight of those uprooted after 1945 and the social and legal responses to their condition; post-war Jewish migration and the place and role of Czechoslovakia in it; the revival of Jewish communal life in various localities and emigration to Israel from Europe and the Middle East. Whereas the aforementioned juxtaposition promises new insights, individual contributions are simply too heterogeneous for the volume to add up to much more than the sum of its parts. Articles on divergent topics are included here, such as Jewish refugees in the border regions of Poland and Czechoslovakia, the role of Jewish chaplains employed by the United States in liberated Europe, the fraught revival of the Dutch Jewish community in the post-war period, the Israeli Law of Return, the integration or lack thereof of immigrants, particularly Jews from Arab countries in Israel via radio broadcasts, etc. As editors Manfred Gerstenfeld and Françoise S. Ouzan themselves tellingly remark, the ‘complexity of the issues related to post-war Jewish migration is further demonstrated by the diversity of the articles of this volume’ (5).
Some of the discourses employed may at times sound like rehearsals of a somewhat outmoded Leidensgeschichte; however, the contributions recurrently contrast lived experiences and eventual outcomes. Without adopting a heroic tone to discuss the rebirth referred to in the volume's title, several articles show how, despite the numerous psychological, social and material hardships, many Jewish migrants from the Middle East and Europe have managed to rebuild their lives. Others focus on Europe to explain how numerous Jewish communities re-established themselves, with several of them, unexpectedly, soon beginning to flourish. This is puzzling indeed, though the discourses surrounding it have by now been heavily standardised. The innovative potential of the volume rather lies in its broadening of the scope beyond Europe to address the mass exodus of Jews from Arab and Muslim countries, a tragedy which has all too often been minimised by way of reference to the Nazi genocide.
The overall suggestion of the volume that analysing the similarities and differences between the migration of Holocaust survivors and that of Jews from Muslim countries may substantially complement our current understanding of Jewish migratory patterns is persuasive. However, what analytical gains such juxtaposition might bring are not sufficiently specified in the volume; the connections to be explored and the exact comparisons to be pursued remain rather vague. The reader is ultimately left with the impression that due to the variety of political and social contexts and the divergent local strategies of exclusion, migration out of Eastern Europe and North Africa would lend themselves only to more fine-tuned, and at the same time more systematic, comparisons.
Conclusion
Innovative studies on Jewish history in the age of genocide increasingly look beyond the thematic priorities and conceptual apparatus of Holocaust Studies. Kateřina Čapková’s pluralistic depiction of interwar Bohemian Jews with her focus on activism and the element of choice, Rebekah Klein-Pejšová’s ambivalent analyses of the paradoxes of reorientation and loyalty and Anna Cichopek-Gajraj's exploration of the rebuilding of Jewish lives and communities close to the geographical centre of the Holocaust, however partial and temporary it may have been, all illustrate this remarkable transformation. As the scholarly interest in the relatively underexplored Jewish communities of Central and Eastern Europe grows, unusually complex or downright paradoxical processes begin to beg for attention: Zionist political successes in an interwar democracy; ‘the trap of consolidation’ and the ambivalence of Jewish minority rights or (perhaps less strikingly, but no less importantly) the more ‘normal’ aspects of ‘abnormal’ times.
Future researchers of Jewish history in Central and Eastern Europe in the age of catastrophes may wish to go more consciously transnational. They should begin to address the elephant in the room, i.e. the role Nazi Germany played for local Jews before the respective German occupations. They may also be interested in posing the intriguing, though not uncontroversial, question of continuities and discontinuities across the ultimate rupture of genocide. The abrupt and violent end to millions of human lives has understandably overwhelmed researchers too and long exercised a taboo on serious inquiries in this direction. However, leading Holocaust historians have recently started to discuss and debate questions of continuities.Footnote 29 Especially with regard to countries with more substantial communities of Jewish survivors, a closer focus on the reestablishment or change of political, social, economic, cultural and intellectual patterns after 1945 promises to yield fascinating results – in other words, this would mean the thematic and geographical extension of Anna Cichopek-Gajraj's explorations. More specifically, key questions in the cultural history of politics, such as how Jewish survivors responded to the genocide, how they renegotiated their utopian commitments and how the relationship between their sense of catastrophe and utopianism evolved in subsequent decades might prove particularly fruitful.Footnote 30 More generally, as attention gradually shifts from the canonised stories of Jews as helpless victims and traumatised survivors and from the mainstream narratives of Jews in Germany and Poland to the ‘semi-periphery’ of the Czech lands, Slovakia, Hungary or Romania, Jewish history in the age of genocide is bound to appear in an unfamiliar light and merit renewed attention.
