I. INTRODUCTION: HISTORIAN OF AMERICAN ECONOMIC THOUGHT
The eminent scholar Bill Barber wrote on a range of topics from British Economic Thought and India 1600–1858 (1975) to The Economy of British Central Africa ([1961] 1984). He was a “principal assistant” on Gunnar Myrdal’s monumental study Asian Drama (1968) and contributed the volume on Myrdal to Palgrave Macmillan’s series Great Thinkers in Economics (2008). He wrote the widely used Penguin paperback History of Economic Thought (1967, translated into eight languages—including a pirated edition in Farsi); published in the inaugural issues of History of Political Economy, the Journal of Economic Perspectives, and the annual supplements to HOPE (Barber Reference Barber1969, Reference Barber1987, Reference Barber and Goodwin1991); and served for a year as acting president of his university, Wesleyan (see Smith Reference Smith2013).Footnote 1 He co-edited reprints of earlier American writings on political economy (Barber, Johnson, Medema, Rutherford, and Samuels 2002–2005) and surveyed scholarship on pre-1900 American economics (Barber 2003). In his Presidential Address to the History of Economics Society, he delivered a reasoned, thoughtful, and resoundingly affirmative answer to the question “Does Scholarship in the History of Economics Have a Useful Future?” (Barber Reference Barber1990).Footnote 2 But he is, I think, best known, and deservedly so, for three great contributions to the history of American economic thought: on the introduction of economics in American universities (Barber Reference Barber1988); on American economists and economic policy from 1921 to 1945, “the interplay of economic ideas and events during … years of extraordinary turbulence in the American economy,” From New Era to New Deal, 1985, and Designs within Disorder, 1996 (the quotation is from Barber Reference Barber1996, p. 1); and his edition of The Works of Irving Fisher (Fisher Reference Fisher and Barber1997; Barber 1997, Reference Barber and Rutherford1998a, 1999, Reference Barber, Dimand and Geanakoplos2005). This body of work establishes Bill Barber as the peer of and successor to Joseph Dorfman as an historian of pre-1945 American economics.Footnote 3 Barber (1998a, p. 19) suggested “another way to address the existence (or non-existence) of a distinctive national dimension in economic discourse in the United States.… Potentially, at least, it would seem to be fruitful to ask whether or not peculiarities of American circumstances leave a mark on the types of economic questions that are raised and the manner in which answers to them are sought.” His own work on the emergence and role of political economy and economics in American universities, on the interactions of American economists, policy-makers, and economic events from 1921 to 1945, and on the outstanding (but, before Bill Barber, rather neglected) pre-1940 American economic scientist demonstrated that the approach was indeed fruitful.
II. RE-EVALUATING IRVING FISHER
Bill Barber’s edition of Fisher’s Works strove “to make accessible the essential raw materials required for a thorough appreciation of Fisher’s impact on the development of modern economics” (Fisher Reference Fisher and Barber1997, introd. p. 1). The edition did much more than just reprint a dozen of Fisher’s books: it supplemented those texts with editorial introductions and postscripts that draw heavily on primary documents (many of previously unpublished). These primary documents include Fisher’s voluminous correspondence with professional colleagues and with public officials, his considerable testimony before Congressional committees, and his writings in popular as well as professional periodicals. “The scholar who studies this material will come away enriched with insights into Fisher’s remarkable creativity and into the intellectual dynamics of American economics in the first half of the 20th century,” explained Barber (1997, p. 446). These editorial introductions and postscripts were the heart of the edition, and were based on Bill’s intensive, meticulous archival research. Bill Barber’s edition of Fisher is as indispensable to anyone studying its subject as Eugene Rotwein’s edition of David Hume’s economic writings, the Piero Sraffa–Maurice Dobb edition of David Ricardo’s works and correspondence, or Donald Moggridge’s edition of The Collected Writings of John Maynard Keynes are to their subjects—the works generally accepted as the exemplars of how to edit an economist’s writings—one might say the “gold standard” of editions of economists except that Irving Fisher would have objected to the implied praise of the gold standard.
“As a survivor of total immersion in those documents,” reported Barber (1999b, pp. 22, 28), “I can testify that working with Irving Fisher’s papers provides intriguing insights into his life and endeavors.… Study of Fisher’s papers, it should be emphasized, throws arresting light on his style of policy advocacy as well as on its substance.” Bill Barber’s immersion in Fisher’s mountainous archives provided not merely intriguing insights but a re-evaluation of an economist—long widely dismissed for being so disastrously wrong about the stock market in October 1929 and for his reform enthusiasms from dietary reform, the League of Nations, health insurance, and a new world map projection; through Prohibition, eugenics, and price level stabilization; to distributed lags, an “ideal index number,” indexed bonds, and the usefulness of mathematics in economics—as a key figure in the development of modern economics. “Even in Fisher’s own faculty at Yale,” Barber reported, “there were far more skeptics than sympathizers. His local reputation was largely that of a crank with a weakness for promoting unconventional causes.… It is now clear that his analytic powers have contributed much more to the shaping of economics as we know it today than most of his contemporaries in the 1930s and 1940s would have thought possible” (Barber Reference Barber, Loef and Monissen1999b, pp. 31, 32).
It must be stressed that Bill Barber’s work was crucial to the re-evaluation of Fisher, and that The Works of Irving Fisher was the product of Bill’s herculean labors. In the 1960s and 1970s, Irving Fisher’s admirers were few in quantity, although formidable in quality: Maurice Allais, Milton Friedman (but not his co-author Anna Schwartz), Ragnar Frisch, Hyman Minsky, Paul Samuelson, Herbert Scarf, James Tobin. Yale’s Department of Economics took the first significant step in the rehabilitation of Fisher’s scientific reputation to mark the centenary of his birth, with Ten Studies in the Tradition of Irving Fisher (Fellner et al. Reference Fellner1967), including nine papers by Yale authors (including Herbert Scarf’s first paper on his algorithm for computing general equilibrium, honoring Fisher’s 1891 hydrostatic mechanism simulating general equilibrium) plus Paul Samuelson on Fisher and the theory of capital, a paper in which Samuelson, with uncharacteristic modesty, acclaimed Fisher’s 1891 thesis as the greatest dissertation ever written in economics. In Fisher’s lifetime, Yale’s Department of Economics had ignored his seventy-fifth birthday in 1942, so Joseph Schumpeter organized a celebration at Harvard for the Yale economist.
Schumpeter conveyed his high regard for Fisher to his Harvard doctoral students Samuelson and Tobin. Samuelson, chiding earlier generations of Yale economists for their neglect of Fisher, concluded his keynote address at the 1967 symposium by endorsing Schumpeter’s prediction that Fisher’s “name will stand in history … as the name of the country’s greatest scientific economist” (Fellner et al. Reference Fellner1967, p. 39, quoted in turn as the conclusion of Barber Reference Barber, Dimand and Geanakoplos2005, p. 54), a prophecy that carefully distinguished Fisher the scientific economist from Fisher the economic and social reformer. James Tobin, on coming to teach at Yale in 1950, was startled by Yale’s disregard and disdain for its main (and perhaps only) claim to eminence in pre-1940 economics. Tobin, who was to write about Fisher for the New Palgrave encyclopedia in 1987 and for the American Economic Review’s 1985 special issue honoring the centenary of the American Economic Association, was a crucial supporter of Bill Barber’s edition of Fisher’s works. Beyond writing the editorial foreword and postscript for the second volume (the volume that included Fisher’s 1906 book, The Nature of Capital and Income), Tobin’s role as consulting editor of The Works of Irving Fisher contributed to Pickering & Chatto’s agreeing to publish such a large project, to the American Economic Association’s (AEA) providing funding, and to good relations with the Fisher family and the Manuscripts and Archives section of Yale University’s Sterling Memorial Library, as well as to the celebration of the completion and publication of the edition by a 1998 Cowles Foundation conference at Yale (see Barber Reference Barber, Dimand and Geanakoplos2005) and a six-paper AEA round table published in the Papers and Proceedings issue of the American Economic Review (see Barber Reference Barber1997a, accompanied by papers on Fisher by Tobin, Robert Hall, Robert Solow, Richard Thaler, and me). The American Economic Association, although accepting acknowledgment of its financial assistance (Fisher Reference Fisher and Barber1997, 1, p. xxi), preferred not to have its name attached to the edition (in contrast to the Royal Economic Society, which lent its name to the Ricardo and Keynes editions), due to well-founded uneasiness about Fisher’s involvement in eugenics and especially in campaigning for “selective immigration” before the restrictive Immigration Act of 1924 (see Fisher Reference Fisher and Barber1997, 13, pp. 160–207).
III. PATHS TO FISHER
Bill Barber came to work on Fisher through Breaking the Academic Mould: Economists and American Higher Learning in the Nineteenth Century (Barber Reference Barber1988), the American contribution to a project in which scholars from twelve countries studied the institutionalization of political economy in European, North American, and Japanese universities, with the national research teams interacting at a conference in San Miniato, Italy, in April 1986. In addition to editing the volume and writing the opening chapter, “Political Economy and the Academic Setting before 1900,” Bill also wrote the chapters on Brown University, Yale, Johns Hopkins, and the University of Chicago. Writing the chapter on political economy at Yale until 1899 meant that when James Tobin, having written on Fisher for the AEA centenary and the New Palgrave (for which he drew on Bill’s forthcoming chapter on nineteenth-century political economy at Yale), wished to encourage more study of Fisher, Bill Barber was uniquely qualified to edit Fisher’s works as an historian of economic thought well versed in the academic environment of Fisher’s studies and early career and conveniently located in Connecticut, close to the Fisher Papers.Footnote 4
As an offshoot of his chapter on Johns Hopkins, Bill examined the role of Simon Newcomb, the Nova Scotia-born astronomer who was professor of mathematics at Johns Hopkins, “as an unwitting catalyst in the formation of the American Economic Association” (Barber Reference Barber1987, p. 183) through Newcomb’s denunciation of the methodology of (untenured) Johns Hopkins political economist Richard T. Ely, who had declared “works which have advocated the application of mathematics to economics form no essential part of the development of economic literature” (Barber Reference Barber1987, p. 183). Defending his academic position, Ely promoted the creation of the AEA, which he hoped would combat the influence of “the Sumner, Newcomb crowd” (Barber Reference Barber1987, p. 179). Fisher dedicated his Purchasing Power of Money to Newcomb’s memory in 1911 (Fisher Reference Fisher and Barber1997, 4) because of Newcomb’s equation of exchange, and co-dedicated Stabilizing the Dollar to Newcomb’s memory in 1920 (Fisher Reference Fisher and Barber1997, 6) because of Newcomb’s proposal for stabilizing the price level. Newcomb provided another path to Fisher, in addition to the Yale chapter. But Bill’s familiarity with and interest in Fisher’s writings began earlier: the first reference in his contribution to another international comparative study, on economists in government (Barber Reference Barber and Coats1981, p. 176), was to Fisher’s 1918 AEA Presidential Address (reprinted in Fisher Reference Fisher and Barber1997, 13). Fisher figured prominently, even pervasively, in Bill’s studies of the involvement of American economists in policy discussion from 1921 onwards (twenty entries in the index of Barber Reference Barber1985 and nineteen in the index to Barber Reference Barber1996).
IV. CONCLUSION: SCHOLAR, EDITOR, HISTORIAN
Bill Barber undertook a monumental task in editing Fisher’s Works. Like the John Maynard Keynes and David Ricardo editions, the Fisher edition did not merely reprint Fisher’s major books and articles (even though books by Fisher were included in twelve of the fourteen volumes) but also introductions and postscripts that provided context and continuity and excerpted relevant material from Fisher’s correspondence, Congressional testimony, popular writings, and responses to reviews. He wrote the editorial introductions and postscripts for twelve of the fourteen volumes, the only exceptions being volume 2 (The Nature of Capital and Income), which James Tobin edited, and volume 7 (The Making of Index Numbers), which I edited. The construction of this indispensable resource for studying Fisher is thus mostly the single-handed achievement of Bill Barber, with the assistance of Kevin Foster.
In addition to valuable work on topics ranging from James Mill to Gunnar Myrdal, Bill Barber made fundamental contributions to three areas of the history of American economic thought: the emergence of political economy as an academic discipline in US universities; a gripping and insightful narrative of the complex interplay between economists and economic events in policy-making and policy discourse from 1921 to 1945; and a monumental, archivally based re-evaluation of Irving Fisher, retrieving the brilliant economic theorist and econometrician from the shadow of the sometimes quixotic reformer who was so memorably mistaken about the stock market in 1929. He was one of the truly great scholars of the history of economic thought.
