This study by Patricia Fara marks a major contribution to our literature on the history of women and gender in science, particularly timely in light of recent First World War centennials. Fara laments that many today have forgotten the vital roles that female scientists, doctors and engineers played in supporting Britain's wartime research, industrial production and military mobilization. Her book highlights women's work in aircraft design, statistical analysis, cryptography, weather forecasting, bacteriology, food science, military medicine, weapons chemistry and more, all under stressful wartime conditions and at lower pay than men:
These scientific pioneers have suffered from a double neglect in the nation's memory. First, they are largely ignored in studies of women during wartime: feminist historians have understandably preferred to focus on wartime manual workers, who were far more numerous and left behind more readily accessible evidence. At the same time, professional women are scarcely mentioned in books about science and medicine during the War, which deal almost exclusively with men. (pp. 10–11)
Fara opens by reviewing pre-war economic, education and gender inequities, especially regarding access to college. She reminds readers of the evolutionary, psychological and physiological theories asserting female inferiority, as well as eugenicists’ warnings that educating women endangered social well-being. Female students were mocked and isolated in Oxford and Cambridge's gender-separated classes and colleges, but enjoyed more freedom to share intellectual space with men at the newer red-brick universities. Fara argues that by persisting in their pursuit of science, these women set the stage for wartime changes. ‘The women who developed explosives in laboratories or performed emergency surgery on the battlefield or intercepted wireless signals could only do so because their predecessors had already been hammering away at conventional barriers’ (p. 27).
Fara's story reinforces familiar themes in the history of science and gender, where she details how women in early 1900s Britain were excluded from many professional societies and channeled into low-level positions. Fara also traces the way that open-minded family members, supportive male mentors and institutions such as the British Federation of University Women and Newnham College helped women gain access to education and professionalization. What adds extra richness to Fara's work is its strength in political history as well as social and intellectual history. Carefully tracing the feminist dimensions of science and gender history, she describes how engineer Caroline Haslett, mathematician Ray Costelloe Strachey and other key women linked their passions for science and suffrage, perceiving both as desired advances in modernity. Critics also connected the two, condemning both suffragists and female scientists for defying traditional feminine modesty and submissiveness.
A Lab of One's Own alternates the broad analysis of gender and science history with case studies of specific women's experiences, such as the work of physician Mona Geddes and botanist Helen Gwynne-Vaughan in establishing the Women's Auxiliary Army Corps. Fara nicely links her story to the broader context of Britain's wartime employment of women and its class complications, noting gendered pay gaps; union opposition; and the toxic hazards of munitions manufacture, welding and industrial chemistry. She highlights the work of Ida Smedley, Martha Whiteley and other female chemists on explosives, pharmaceuticals, insecticides and poison gases (including self-testing). Not coincidentally, Smedley and Whiteley advocated for the London Chemical Society to accept female members and were among the first women admitted in 1920.
Fara's book also highlights the many ways in which women doctors proved essential to medical care, both during and after the war. She features Helena Gleichen, who performed field X-rays of wounded soldiers; Helen Chambers, who developed better antiseptics; and suffragists Louisa Garret Anderson and Flora Murray, who established military hospitals despite bureaucratic obstacles. She notes how women overcame practical challenges, servicing their own battlefield equipment and setting up portable lights for operating stations. In compelling chapters, Fara details the lives of surgeons Elsie Inglis, Isabel Emslie Hutton and other women who established hospitals in Serbia, Salonika and other wartime hot spots, tending soldiers and civilians under dangerous conditions. She describes how locals still revere these British women, but pointedly uses their cases to underline the historical obstacles of gender. By 1921, Hutton
was now an expert surgeon who had coped with complicated chronic cases as well as urgent battle injuries, but she faced up to reality: as a woman, there was no chance of practising surgery in Britain. Moreover, although she … had run entire hospitals on her own, as a married woman she was obliged to … become her husband's financial dependent. (p. 255)
British officials eventually accepted female physicians’ service, though often only on temporary hire, at lower pay and status than male doctors. Yet Fara indicates that war set the stage for female doctors to organize, demanding long-term goals of equal pay for equal work. She similarly argues that despite postwar setbacks, female scientists had established clear success. Women ‘had proved themselves capable of carrying out work traditionally reserved for men, and – try as reactionaries might – that unprecedented sense of achievement and power and possibility could not be obliterated’ (p. 12). Fara expresses concern about the modern persistence of gender imbalances in science and engineering, concluding, ‘Blatant mockery and explicit segregation may now have disappeared, but concealed prejudice can be both harder to fight and more keenly felt … Before the First World War, suffragists could see what they were fighting against but modern discrimination is elusive, insidious, and stubbornly hard to eradicate’ (p. 283).
A Lab of One's Own represents superlative research and reads beautifully, making it an excellent resource for researchers and students alike. The book focuses exclusively on Britain, leaving readers to determine how much of this story is unique or reveals parallels in other countries. Fara's work shows just how challenging it is to uncover women's work that was eclipsed or left silent, raising tantalizing questions about how many stories yet remain to be dug out of dusty First World War accounts.
