‘Establishment’ is not in the title of David Fergusson's revised Bampton Lectures, but it haunts the discussion. The placing of Britain's two established churches within civil society is intended as an alternative model to the current one that reflects what Professor Fergusson believes to be an outmoded position as national churches that claim to represent the religious character of Scotland and England respectively. There is much useful material and insightful discussion here, biblical and historical, and a sound underlying theology. Political life is part of the divinely intended natural state for humankind. Political authority is ordained by God. Christians are not aliens in political society, but hold a true citizenship there, albeit one that is subordinate to their allegiance to the Kingdom of God. Christians should get involved in political society and actively seek the common good. This is a thoroughly worthwhile book, rich in its engagement with the Christian heritage and modern political reflection. But I have to say that it leaves me dissatisfied.
Running through the book I find an ambivalence with regard to the national witness of the established churches within the prevailing culture (it is assumed that there is one). We live, we are told, after the end of Christendom and in the twilight of establishment. In that context, it is alleged, the churches should evolve a more congregational, voluntarist and ethically counter-cultural identity. Political liberalism is presented as an attractive, even seductive vision, but one that cannot stand the strains of argument and conflict in a plural world. The nature of distinctive Christian nurture and formation is explored. Toleration is defended, not on the basis of natural rights, but as an aspect of the common good. Indeed, the theme of the common good runs through the book and is very welcome from a Protestant theologian, having been largely the preserve of the Roman Catholic Church hitherto. Institutions within civil society relate to each other by civilised converse, by negotiation and compromise, but there is little sense of the fierce competition of the market place or of the conflict of ideologies. (Where is the resurgence of militant Islam to be located in relation to civil society: within or without?)
Professor Fergusson seems to believe that the state is now neutral in its practical policies, and that is why establishment is an anachronism (p. 5). He assumes that he would be comfortable with a secular state because he thinks that basically that is what we have already. It is true that the political programmes of both national and local government are often not conducive to Christian mores; they are in fact often riddled with political correctness, sometimes of the crassest kind. But that does not mean that the state, in the sense of the constitutional principles and structures of the United Kingdom, is neutral. (It is asserted, without considering the likely consequences, that the Act of Settlement 1701 should be abolished.) The idea of state neutrality is a chimera. Is religious neutrality possible without moral neutrality? The two are bound up together; a state that is morally neutral is an impossibility and, if it existed, it could not promote the common good. Every state needs a creed of sorts that underpins its central values. While Fergusson recognises that civilised values such as tolerance are possible because they are embedded in historic institutions, he does not conclude that this requires a more conservative attitude to our institutions, particularly those of church and state.
In the conclusion, the boot is on the other foot: the churches are advised not to be counter-cultural, but to go with the flow. ‘Clinging to establishment is futile; it represents a failure to recognise current cultural trends, especially among the younger generations’. This concession implies much more serious capitulation: if cultural trends are to set the agenda, we will end up by abandoning not merely establishment, but also the church as an ordered community, and even Christian faith itself. Where is counter-culturalism and Christian distinctiveness now?
Again, I am not convinced by the tacit opposition of civil society and establishment: they are not mutually exclusive. A number of major institutions within civil society are established in an analogical sense: for example, health-care and education providers are authorised by the state and carry corresponding obligations. That does not prevent there being private-enterprise hospitals, schools and colleges; we do not say that it is unfair to them that other institutions are more closely related to the state and more integral to the life of the nation. The mixed economy is beneficial: the state needs a stake in these areas for the sake of the common good, but alternative provision can fill certain gaps and keep the mainline institutions on their toes. So it is with the established, national churches on the one hand, and the Free Churches and ‘other faith’ communities on the other. The Church of England and the Church of Scotland are major players within civil society, but their unique roles in the nations are also recognised by the state.
The figures given for Church of England ‘membership’ on p. 142 are misleading as they seem to refer to the Church Electoral Roll, which for English Anglicans is certainly not the same as membership. The sharp comments about the crown's involvement in the appointment of bishops would be lost on most English Anglicans: to them it embodies a process of consultation that reaches beyond the active Christian constituency and is therefore benign and even salutary.
This book takes an essential place in the spate of recent studies in this area. But I find it an uncertain and wavering book, again and again defaulting to a liberal stance and then admitting that it won't do. Although Fergusson admits that ‘establishment’ is not a univocal term, and is neither the same on both sides of the Border nor the same today as it was in the past, he nevertheless argues steadily against ‘establishment’, in the sense of state recognition of any particular church or creed, but then backs off from ‘disestablishment’. He advocates neither establishment nor disestablishment and is equivocal about ‘the demise of the national church’ (p. 143). Taken as a whole, this book renounces some classic claims for the place of the churches in national life, identifying them with an ill-defined ‘Christendom’, rather than urging the churches to validate their distinctive, received place through effective and persuasive mission.
