What impact does religion have on state development? From Max Weber's argument that Protestant sects influenced capitalism in the West to Robert Putnam's argument that religious forces are a key component in civil society that contribute to a healthy democratic nation, social scientists have spent a great deal of energy attempting to determine the level(s) at which religion proves to be a significant force for state development. Religion, Class Coalitions, and Welfare States examines how specific Christian sects and the changing division of labor in postindustrial Europe helped consolidate the modern welfare state. Prior to this publication, research on the development of welfare states had failed to explore empirically the complex relationship between religious institutions and class coalitions.
Each chapter includes two important components: first, the way in which religion may promote or inhibit the development of social-protection policies and, second, the cultural framework provided by religion that influences economic, social, and political institutions in the West (p. 34). The book concentrates predominantly on Western European states—namely, the Netherlands, Belgium, France, Switzerland, Italy, and Sweden—with some attention given to the United States. The authors stress three important factors that led to the development of welfare states: the timing of the development of self-regulating markets in the tenth century, the long-standing religious differences since the Reformation in the eighteenth century, and the difference in the type of political restructuring that took place in each country as a result of its choice of electoral system (p. 119).
The book begins with a comprehensive theoretical overview of the significance of both class structures and religion in the establishment of welfare states. Here, Philip Manow and Kees van Kersbergen argue that the strategies behind the political countermovement (led primarily by the Social Democrats and those promoting religious social teachings) are salient to the understanding of the development of welfare states in Western Europe. Moreover, the editors suggest that three things are central for understanding the development of party coalitions in the welfare states: “the mode of financing, the benefit structure, and the provision of social services” (p. 28). The book proceeds with a series of case studies that contribute to the theoretical model posed by Manow and van Kersbergen.
The first contribution is by Thomas Ertman, who examines the relationship between religious parties and democratic consolidation, concluding that religion softened antagonisms between political and economic groups in most Western European nations. Next, Kimberly J. Morgan looks at work–family policies and how they were influenced by religious teachings, which encouraged parents (and particularly mothers) to have a more active role in their children's education and child care. Focusing on the Italian case, Julia Lynch evaluates the influential nature of Italian Christian democracy on social welfare programs. She posits that Italy is not a welfare state that is inspired by social Catholicism or established policies that encourage class unity. Instead, she argues, Italy is unlike other country case studies, for there is “little evidence that the Christian Democracy has determined the shape of the Italian welfare state through the mechanisms of parties that carry and enforce a particular set of socioreligious doctrines” (p. 114). Very directly analyzing the internal dynamics of the welfare state in the Netherlands, van Kersbergen contributes his own chapter, arguing that the Dutch welfare state emerged late due to the deeply entrenched religious cleavages and fragmentations. Continuing with another comparative-historical case study, Manow and Bruno Palier analyze the French structure. France is a unique case because, despite the church–state divide, there was no emergence of a counterreligious party from the late nineteenth to mid-twentieth centuries. Moreover, France maintains a political system based in presidentialism, a feature distinguishing it from its Western European counterparts that have embraced proportional representation.
Following this analysis, Herbert Obinger looks at the Swiss welfare state as a model for political and religious consolidation, which, as it turns out, were mutually reinforcing. Karen M. Anderson then uses another case study analysis to look at the Church of Sweden's absence from generating progressive social policy—and, in fact, its promotion of a conservative agenda—and how that materialized into an oppositional political force. Looking at the religious factor in US welfare state politics, Jill Quadagno and Deanna Rohlinger demonstrate how the country's tradition of church–state separation, the conservative nature of the Republican Party, and the troubled history of labor policies led many Americans to be cautious of government welfare programs, a development that makes the United States unique from the countries of Western Europe. Finally, taking a fresh look at religious social doctrines, Sigrun Kahl presents an alternative outlook concerning how religion may have promoted social welfare states, arguing that welfare states may have developed institutions that ran social programs motivated by religious principles.
This book is among the first to directly address the question of church involvement in the consolidation of political and economic systems, particularly as it relates to the welfare state. This delay in scholarly investigation may be due in part to the variety of ways in which religious and political cleavages have become manifested in Western nations. For example, van Kersbergen writes that “[r]eligious segmentation has characterized the history of the Netherlands since the Reformation…. The political impact of the fundamental religious cleavage on Dutch society, both expressed as a Liberal-Confessional antithesis and as a Calvinist-Catholic conflict, can hardly be overstated” (p. 121). Through the variety of case studies presented in this collection, the reader is introduced to the multitude of contributing variables that may prove to be the most influential in guiding a particular nation toward a social welfare state. A distinguishing feature of this work is its focus on Protestant social doctrines (as opposed to the pervasive Catholic social doctrine) and its effect on government welfare programs. Drawing on data from Lutheran and Calvinist, reformed, Protestant theologies, the authors contend that this religious differentiation has led to distinct class coalitions, especially among the middle and lower classes.
While the theoretical frameworks utilized in this anthology stem primarily from the political science research agenda, the book makes important contributions to other disciplines within the social sciences, including sociology, economics, and religious studies. The book not only helps scholars understand the complex nature in which religious doctrine affects social policy, but it also demonstrates how broader institutional forces (such as electoral systems, presidentialism, and labor unions) may dissuade or encourage social reform. Because the studies presented here are contextual, future examination of religion, class, and government welfare programs may also attempt a broader conceptual design for studying welfare states. Furthermore, it may be important to consider how deeply the cleavages among religion, electoral systems, and labor parties may penetrate policy reform at various levels. Finally, as suggested by the authors, future scholars may also wish to examine the direction of causality between government welfare programs and levels of religiosity within each national context.
In summary, Religion, Class Coalitions, and Welfare States provides not only a breadth of information that is new to the research agenda of many social scientists but also an important comparative-historical argument that addresses the ever-changing, ever-pervasive role of culture and its influence on political and class-based institutions.
