Introduction, Sources and Methodological Approach
Throughout the twentieth century, prostitution occupied a structurally ambivalent position within European regimes of moral regulation. Persistently condemned as a social and moral danger yet widely tolerated as part of everyday social life, it remained a recurrent object of state intervention without ever being governed through a coherent or stable legal framework. Police surveillance, welfare supervision, medical inspection and administrative discretion coexisted with shifting legal regimes, making prostitution a particularly revealing site for analysing how states governed sexuality, gender and social deviance in practice. This tension raises a broader question: how did political rupture rework the everyday governance of prostitution in administrative terms – through identification practices, surveillance routines and welfare/judicial intervention – rather than through shifts in legal language alone?
This article examines prostitution in Spain during the Civil War and the early Franco dictatorship (1936–56) to reconsider the relationship between political change and the governance of sexual deviance. Rather than approaching regime change as a moment of sharp discontinuity in the regulation of prostitution, the article analyses how modalities of identification, surveillance and institutional management operated across the transition from Second Republican abolitionism to the Francoist regulatory framework that remained in force until the promulgation of the Decree of 3 March 1956 formally abolishing tolerated prostitution.
National Catholicism emerged during the Civil War as one of the principal ideological foundations of the Francoist state and became fully consolidated during the 1940s and 1950s through the close alliance between political authority and the Catholic Church. Its moral policies sought to regulate everyday behaviour through the defence of the patriarchal family, female domesticity, religious orthodoxy, sexual restraint outside marriage and the suppression of practices perceived as threats to the moral and spiritual regeneration of the nation.
The Spanish case shows that the establishment of an authoritarian moral order grounded in National Catholicism did not entail the dismantling of existing modes of governance, but rather their reconfiguration and intensification under conditions of war, post-war scarcity and political repression.Footnote 1 Continuity in administrative techniques did not preclude significant transformations in their intensity, ideological framing and punitive scope. By shifting the analytical focus from legal frameworks and ideological discourse to the ordinary mechanisms through which prostitution was governed, the article challenges overly rupturist interpretations and situates early Francoism within broader European dynamics of institutional continuity in the regulation of sexuality. It also uses the term ‘prostitution’, rather than ‘sex work’, deliberately and self-consciously: this is the category through which police, welfare and judicial institutions identified the women studied here, and it better captures a historical field structured by coercion, tutelage, intermittence, stigma and administrative classification, rather than by stable occupational self-definition.
The Francoist regime presented itself as a project of moral regeneration in which the reconstruction of political authority and social order was inseparable from the disciplining of gender roles. Female sexuality occupied a central symbolic position within this project. Respectable femininity was defined around domesticity, motherhood and sexual restraint, while deviations from these norms were constructed as threats to social stability and national renewal. Prostitution, in this context, was publicly denounced as a moral pathology and as a legacy of the liberal and Republican past. Yet the governance of prostitution during the Civil War and the early years of the dictatorship cannot be understood solely through ideological discourse or formal prohibition. Despite sustained condemnation, prostitution was neither eradicated nor uniformly suppressed. Instead, it was governed through a set of everyday practices combining police surveillance, administrative discretion, welfare intervention and selective repression. These practices produced a regime of managed deviance in which prostitution remained socially marginal yet institutionally legible and, in many cases, tacitly tolerated. The article therefore treats ideology and practice as mutually constitutive but not reducible to one another: the moral language of regeneration mattered, but so too did routinised administrative techniques inherited, adapted and normalised across political conjunctures.
It also contributes to a redefinition of prostitution as a historical category. Rather than presuming prostitution to constitute an enduring social identity or pre-given status, it conceptualises it as a trajectory produced through cumulative processes of institutional intervention. Reconstructed trajectories reveal that women were often identified, monitored and classified as prostitutes before they engaged durably in commercial sex, and that persistence within prostitution circuits was frequently less the result of individual choice or moral failure than of sustained surveillance, administrative memory and constrained access to alternative livelihoods. From this perspective, phenomena such as recidivism, permanence or repeated institutionalisation appear not as indicators of personal deviance, but as structural outcomes of regimes of governance oriented towards containment, legibility and the management of marginality. This trajectory-based approach also helps explain why apparent continuity in the record need not always be read as continuity of conduct: often it reflected the durability of the classificatory apparatus itself.
These arguments are grounded in an extensive multi-archival empirical corpus that allows for the longitudinal reconstruction of women's trajectories across institutions and over time. The research draws primarily on more than three hundred police files produced between the late 1930s and the mid-1950s, consulted mainly in the Archive of the Police Headquarters of Ourense (ACO) and complemented by police documentation embedded in judicial proceedings. These police files constitute the principal empirical entry point but do not correspond mechanically to individual trajectories. Rather, they provide fragmentary yet cumulative records of identification, surveillance and intervention that, when systematically cross-referenced with welfare and judicial sources, make it possible to reconstruct broader social trajectories extending beyond any single file or locality.
While earlier historiography on prostitution in Spain has tended to privilege hygienist sources, municipal regulations, legal norms or medical discourses – often generated by concerns over venereal disease, public health or urban order – this article uses such materials primarily as contextual reference points. Its analytical core lies instead in the systematic exploitation of everyday police documentation, a source base that remains underutilised despite its exceptional capacity to illuminate the practical governance of prostitution. Ourense occupies a central place in this article not because it constituted a closed or representative local case, but because it preserves an exceptional body of police files that allows individual trajectories to be reconstructed with unusual depth. Compiled from information supplied by police stations and other authorities across numerous Spanish provinces and Portugal, these records transform Ourense into an archival observatory from which wider processes of mobility, inter-provincial surveillance and administrative coordination become visible. Their significance therefore lies less in regional specificity than in demonstrating how local and regional police archives of comparable richness can be used to reconstruct similar documentary logics across Spain, opening new avenues for studying prostitution, social control and female mobility beyond the major urban centres that have traditionally dominated the historiography.
Police files provide access to routine practices of surveillance, detention, expulsion, denunciation and moral assessment that are largely invisible in normative texts. They record how women entered institutional circuits for diverse reasons – vagrancy, public scandal, neighbourhood conflict, suspected venereal disease or presence in monitored spaces – and how, once identified, they tended to remain administratively legible over extended periods. Crucially, these records make it possible to follow women across years and localities, tracing sequences of intervention that transformed contingent practices of sexual exchange into sedimented administrative identities. In a substantial number of cases, the documentation allows the reconstruction of trajectories from early experiences of informal sexual exchange or precarious labour, through domestic service, bar work or residence in regulated or clandestine establishments, to later positions as pupils, independent sex workers or, more rarely, managers and property holders. Police records also document how women invested their earnings, negotiated housing, acted as informants for the authorities – both in criminal policing and political surveillance – and navigated shifting forms of institutional pressure over the life course. They also preserve the idioms through which authorities classified women – ‘mujer de mala vida’, ‘vida airada’, ‘de dudosa conducta’, ‘inmoral’ – making visible the everyday vocabulary through which marginality was administratively produced.
The longitudinal potential of these police sources is reinforced through systematic cross-referencing with welfare and judicial archives. In particular, the article draws on extensive documentation generated by the Women's Protection Board (Spanish: Patronato de Protección a la Mujer) and its provincial boards, consulted in the Provincial Historical Archives of Ávila (AHPA), Cáceres (AHPC), Ourense (AHPOU), Pontevedra (AHPP) and Toledo (AHPT). Additional documentation from the Civil Government fonds, preserved in the Historical Archive of Asturias (AHA), has also been consulted. Reorganised by decree in 1940–41 within the Ministry of Justice, the Board assumed formal responsibility for supervising female morality and intervening in the lives of women and minors classified as ‘at risk’ or ‘fallen’. Its surviving archival series – despite fragmentation and partial loss – include correspondence, case files, internal reports, statistical memoranda and minutes that document daily practices of tutelage, confinement, labour placement, religious instruction and medical supervision. Read alongside police records, these materials illuminate how protection and coercion functioned as intertwined modalities of moral regulation rather than as opposing logics, and how women circulated between institutions under the rhetoric of rehabilitation. They are especially important because they show that the regulation of prostitution cannot be reduced to the supervision of women already recognised as prostitutes: the same institutions also targeted servants, runaways, unmarried mothers, daughters of ‘bad families’ and girls deemed morally endangered.
Judicial sources constitute a third pillar of the empirical corpus. The study draws on procedural files and sentence books from the Provincial Court of Ourense, as well as on case materials from proceedings initiated under military jurisdiction during and after the Civil War, preserved in the Northwest Military Intermediate File (Archivo Intermedio Militar Noroeste, AIMN, Ferrol). These records make it possible to analyse how moral classifications shaped legal interpretation across jurisdictions. Judicial documentation reveals how prior police identification as a prostitute framed evidentiary assessment, facilitated punitive or corrective measures and, in some cases, displaced culpability in proceedings involving male defendants. Together, police, welfare and judicial sources expose a dense circuit of institutional circulation through which prostitution was governed as a form of managed deviance. They also make visible the asymmetry of that governance: men usually entered the record as clients, abusers, husbands, lovers, pimps, landlords, policemen or employers, whereas women entered it as objects of classification.
The integration of these archives has made it possible to reconstruct slightly over two hundred trajectories of women identified as prostitutes between the Civil War and the mid-1950s. These trajectories do not correspond one-to-one with individual police files but emerge from the cumulative cross-referencing of police, welfare and judicial documentation across time and space. As an analytical category, trajectories encompass processes of entry into prostitution or arrival in a given locality as a prostitute, subsequent stabilisation within local or regional circuits, and, in some cases, later displacement to other towns where institutional traces can also be followed. The analytical unit of the article is therefore not the individual life history conceived as a self-contained narrative, but recurrent social trajectories shaped by structural vulnerability, institutional labelling and constrained agency. Individual cases function as empirical anchors for identifying patterned sequences of entry, stabilisation, displacement and attempted exit, rather than as exemplary biographies.
For ethical and analytical reasons, all personal names are anonymised and cited only by initials. The archival record itself, however, is marked by frequent nominal instability – aliases, altered identities and inconsistent personal details – which is treated here not as an obstacle but as a structural feature of governance. It illuminates both women's situational strategies and the capacity of institutions to preserve administrative continuity despite personal flux.
Methodologically, the article combines social history with analytical perspectives drawn from the sociology of deviance and moral regulation. Concepts such as labelling, stigma and cumulative disadvantage are mobilised not as abstract theoretical overlays, but as tools for interpreting historically specific practices of governance. The trajectory-based approach adopted here makes it possible to analyse continuity and change without recourse to static categories or teleological narratives of ‘fall’ and ‘redemption’. Women's agency is understood as situational and relational, exercised within narrow margins defined by gendered labour markets, family structures, social stigma and authoritarian power. Decisions to enter, leave or return to prostitution are therefore interpreted in relation to institutional constraints rather than as expressions of personal disposition. At the same time, the article avoids treating women as passive objects of administration: mobility, the use of aliases, tactical relationships with bar owners, selective cooperation with the police and repeated attempts at occupational redefinition all point to forms of constrained but real manoeuvre within a heavily asymmetrical field of power.
The chronological closure in 1956 is not arbitrary. The Decree of 3 March 1956, which formally abolished the tolerated system of prostitution and ordered the closure of regulated establishments, marked a significant normative redefinition of the regime's position. It coincided with the first visible signs of economic stabilisation and the gradual attenuation of the most acute post-war scarcity, altering the structural conditions within which prostitution had been managed during the 1940s and early 1950s. Ending the analysis at this point therefore allows the article to capture the full cycle of wartime disruption, post-war consolidation and regulatory transformation before the onset of a new socio-economic phase. The decree did not end prostitution, nor did it dissolve the apparatuses of surveillance examined here, but it provides a defensible endpoint because it altered the legal language through which tolerated prostitution had previously been organised.
By focusing on the Civil War and the first two decades of the Franco dictatorship up to 1956, this article situates the Spanish case within broader European debates on the governance of sexuality, deviance and moral order under authoritarian conditions. While shaped by the specificities of National Catholic moral discourse and post-war repression, the Spanish experience reveals logics of moral regulation – combining ideological condemnation with pragmatic tolerance and concentrating intervention on women's bodies and mobility – that resonate across diverse European regimes. Prostitution thus emerges not as a marginal anomaly, but as a key site for analysing how twentieth-century states produced and stabilised gendered marginality through everyday practices of governance. References to male prostitution and same-sex commercial encounters do appear in the archive, but only sporadically and through different classificatory languages – homosexuality, scandal, corruption and vice – rather than through a comparably dense administrative category. That imbalance is itself historically significant, and it explains why the article centres female trajectories while signalling the relative invisibility of male sexual commerce within the surviving documentation.
Prostitution and Moral Regulation: Historiographical Debates
The study of prostitution has long occupied a central place within European social history, particularly at the intersection of debates on morality, public order and state intervention. Early scholarship, shaped by concerns with regulationism and public health, focused primarily on nineteenth-century liberal regimes and the emergence of medicalised forms of control. In these accounts, prostitution was framed as a social problem to be managed through surveillance, registration and sanitary intervention, revealing the tensions between liberal notions of individual freedom and collective moral order.Footnote 2 This body of work situated prostitution within broader histories of sexual regulation, in which the governance of sexuality was understood as a constitutive dimension of modern political order rather than as a peripheral moral concern. Scholars highlighted the persistent European oscillation between regulatory, abolitionist and prohibitive frameworks, stressing that prostitution repeatedly resisted stable legal classification and was instead governed through shifting and often contradictory policy regimes.Footnote 3
From the late twentieth century onwards, historiography increasingly shifted attention towards the cultural and political dimensions of sexual regulation, emphasising the role of gender, discourse and power. Influenced by social and cultural history as well as by Foucauldian approaches to governmentality, scholars moved away from treating regulation as a purely technical response to a pre-existing social problem. Instead, prostitution was analysed as an object actively constituted through legal, medical and administrative practices that produced moral norms, social hierarchies and differentiated forms of citizenship.Footnote 4
Comparative research further demonstrated that prostitution was rarely governed through a single legal framework. Instead, it was regulated through a constellation of overlapping domains – public order, public health, labour regulation, welfare provision and migration control – whose combined effects shaped lived experience more decisively than formal legal status. From this perspective, medical and sanitary interventions did not merely respond to prostitution as a pre-existing social problem but actively contributed to the moralisation and stratification of sexual conduct, reinforcing stigma and legitimising practices of surveillance, exclusion and differentiated treatment.Footnote 5
Within this broader European scholarship, authoritarian regimes have attracted increasing attention, particularly in studies of Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany. This literature has highlighted the coexistence of ideological condemnation and pragmatic accommodation in the governance of prostitution. In practice, moral absolutism coexisted with selective tolerance, producing systems of managed deviance in which prostitution was simultaneously marginalised and functional, subjected to intense surveillance yet rarely eliminated.Footnote 6 A key contribution of this literature has been its attention to the gendered asymmetries of moral regulation. Across both authoritarian and democratic contexts, scholars have noted that women bore the brunt of surveillance, sanction and moral intervention, while male sexual demand remained largely invisible and unproblematised. Stigma operated not only as moral judgement but as a practical regulatory technology, legitimising differential treatment and sustaining long-term marginalisation.Footnote 7
The Spanish case has been incorporated into these debates only unevenly. Early studies of prostitution under Francoism tended to emphasise the regime's moral authoritarianism, highlighting the influence of National Catholicism and the rollback of liberal regulatory frameworks inherited from the Second Republic. These works often framed the dictatorship as a period of moral regression, marked by intensified repression and the reassertion of patriarchal norms. While they rightly underscored the centrality of Catholic discourse and gender ideology, they frequently relied on legal texts and official pronouncements, offering limited insight into how prostitution was governed in practice.Footnote 8
More recent scholarship has sought to complicate this picture by examining the everyday operation of control mechanisms at the local level. Drawing on police records, judicial files and municipal archives, historians have reconstructed women's experiences of surveillance, detention and medical inspection, revealing significant variation in enforcement practices as well as the persistence of prostitution despite its formal prohibition. These studies have also highlighted the role of poverty, migration and family breakdown in shaping women's vulnerability, moving beyond moralistic explanations of sexual deviance.Footnote 9 This line of research has further argued for situating prostitution within broader histories of labour, welfare and marginal employment, rather than treating it solely as a question of moral transgression. In post-war and occupation contexts, scholars have shown how sexual economies and their regulation became central to processes of urban reconstruction, social discipline and the reassertion of moral order.Footnote 10
Despite these advances, the historiography still shows a degree of fragmentation, both geographically and analytically. Local studies have generated rich empirical knowledge about the everyday operation of surveillance and control, but their findings have not always been fully integrated into broader conceptual and comparative debates. Conversely, more synthetic accounts of Francoist moral regulation have tended to privilege discourse and ideology, leaving the ordinary administrative routines through which deviance was produced, recorded and stabilised less explored. The challenge, therefore, lies in connecting locally grounded archival reconstructions to wider debates on labelling, moral regulation and authoritarian governance.
This article positions itself at the intersection of these historiographical strands. It builds on empirical research into everyday practices of control while embedding those findings within a broader analytical framework concerned with moral regulation, deviance and institutional continuity. By foregrounding the processes through which women were classified, monitored and rendered administratively legible over time, the article addresses a key limitation of existing work: the tendency to treat prostitution as a stable social category rather than as the outcome of cumulative governance. It also responds to a second limitation in the literature on Francoism: the tendency to oppose Republican and Francoist frameworks too sharply at the level of legal language, while paying less attention to continuities in ordinary administrative technique.
In historiographical terms, the article situates the Spanish case within a wider European framework, engaging with comparative approaches to authoritarian governance and moral regulation rather than treating Francoism as an isolated or exceptional phenomenon. Prostitution constitutes a particularly revealing terrain for comparison, as it exposes how regimes with differing ideological foundations confronted similar tensions between moral absolutism and social necessity through everyday practices of governance.Footnote 11 By foregrounding the gendered moral economies underpinning these practices – most notably the disproportionate regulation of women's bodies and life courses – the article contributes to comparative debates on the everyday functioning of authoritarian power and the regulation of sexuality and social order in twentieth-century Europe.
Entry into Prostitution and the Consolidation of Marginality
Entry into prostitution during the Civil War and the first two decades of the Franco dictatorship rarely constituted a sudden or definitive rupture in women's lives. Rather, it unfolded as a gradual, cumulative trajectory shaped by structural vulnerability, constrained labour opportunities and early experiences of social and institutional exposure that often preceded – and in some cases actively produced – sustained engagement in commercial sex. Across the reconstructed trajectories, domestic service emerged as one of the most common initial occupations among women later identified as prostitutes. For young women migrating from rural areas to urban centres in contexts of war, post-war scarcity and labour dislocation, employment as maids, cooks or general domestic workers represented one of the few accessible forms of paid labour. It required neither formal qualifications nor established urban networks and frequently provided accommodation alongside minimal wages.Footnote 12
Yet the structural accessibility of domestic service coexisted with pronounced forms of social, moral and sexual vulnerability. Employment within private households placed young women in positions of acute dependence on employers and exposed them to arbitrary dismissal, informal discipline and intense surveillance of conduct. As historiography on domestic service in Spain has emphasised, female servants occupied a morally ambivalent position within bourgeois and middle-class households: simultaneously indispensable and suspect, vulnerable to sexual harassment by male household members while also constructed as potential threats to domestic respectability and marital order. Accusations of impropriety, rumours of sexual availability, conflicts with employers’ wives or pregnancy – whether resulting from consensual relationships, coercion or abuse – frequently triggered immediate dismissal, often without compensation, references or access to alternative employment. Domestic service thus functioned as a structurally precarious transitional zone, producing both economic insecurity and early institutional attention, rather than as a neutral prelude to prostitution.
Loss of domestic employment frequently constituted a decisive moment of destabilisation within women's trajectories. Dismissal entailed not only the abrupt loss of income and shelter, but also reputational damage that further narrowed already limited labour options within segmented and highly moralised urban labour markets. Police documentation indicates that dismissals linked to pregnancy, allegations of immorality or conflict within the employing household frequently marked the point at which women first entered police visibility. This pattern is evident in several reconstructed cases, including those of M.O.F.G. and M.V.G., where expulsion from domestic service preceded both the first recorded instances of transactional sexual exchange and the onset of sustained institutional surveillance. In the case of M.O.F.G., the surviving record does not begin with an established prostitute identity but with a sequence marked by sexual violence, rural vulnerability and subsequent residence in tolerated houses before police documentation came to stabilise her as a prostitute. The same file also records her later attempt to establish herself as a bar manager, illustrating efforts to move beyond the administrative identity assigned to her.Footnote 13 The trajectory of M.V.G. similarly shows dismissal from domestic service, mobility and police registration, a sequence that progressively transformed an initially precarious situation into a durable administrative category.Footnote 14 In the absence of effective welfare provision and under conditions of intensified post-war surveillance, women expelled from domestic service often faced acute subsistence crises. Transition into sexual exchange therefore often reflected cumulative exclusion rather than deliberate occupational choice.
Beyond domestic service, other forms of precarious female employment constituted significant zones of vulnerability within the urban labour markets of the Civil War and the first two decades of Francoism. For young women with limited education, weak family support and unstable migratory trajectories, access to stable industrial or clerical employment remained largely closed. Instead, they were disproportionately concentrated in low-wage, informal or semi-formal occupations such as sewing, laundry work, street vending and, most notably, employment in taverns, inns, cafés and small bars. These activities offered irregular income, minimal contractual protection and varying degrees of exposure to public scrutiny, situating women at the intersection of economic necessity and moral suspicion.Footnote 15
Occupations such as sewing, laundry work and street vending generally entailed more intermittent contact with employers and clients than live-in domestic service, limiting sustained subjection to household authority and continuous moral oversight. Although these activities did not usually expose women to the same intensity of reputational risk associated with residential service, they provided only fragile and irregular subsistence, often dependent on payment in kind or unstable demand. In a small number of documented cases, however, sexual contact arising within these contexts – whether through coercion, dependency or opportunistic exchange – preceded occasional recourse to transactional sex under conditions of acute need. While such trajectories were numerically limited, they illustrate how even relatively less exposed forms of precarious labour could, at moments of crisis, intersect with processes of institutional classification and heightened administrative visibility.Footnote 16
Employment in spaces of male sociability – particularly bars, cafés and inns – proved especially ambivalent within the urban labour markets of the Civil War and the dictatorship's formative decades. While such venues offered immediate access to cash income and, in some cases, accommodation or food, they also blurred the boundaries between legitimate labour and morally suspect activity. Women employed as waitresses, barmaids or informal assistants were routinely exposed to sexualised interactions, pressure to drink with clients and expectations of availability that exceeded formal job descriptions. Even in the absence of overt sexual commerce, their visibility in male-dominated public spaces rendered them vulnerable to reputational damage and intensified police and welfare scrutiny, thereby reinforcing institutional associations between female spatial mobility and moral suspicion. This was one of the principal routes through which bar work and prostitution became administratively entangled, even when the former initially preceded the latter.Footnote 17
Police and judicial documentation confirm that employment in such venues frequently sufficed to trigger surveillance, denunciation and preventive sanctions for moral disorder, regardless of evidence of prostitution. The trajectory of M.C.F.P., for example, illustrates how police intervention was initially linked not to proven commercial sex but to her presence in morally suspect spaces and to reports describing her conduct and company as improper, well before any stable prostitute identity had been administratively established. Presence alone often led to identification as a woman ‘of doubtful conduct’, initiating cycles of police control that narrowed future employment opportunities. Repeated identity checks, short-term detentions or administrative expulsions reinforced women's administrative legibility and contributed to the gradual consolidation of marginal status.Footnote 18
Under these conditions, transitions from precarious employment to transactional sexual exchange often emerged as pragmatic responses to cumulative exclusion rather than as abrupt moral ‘falls’. Loss of employment following police intervention, employer complaints or neighbourhood denunciations could precipitate acute income crises similar to those observed after dismissal from domestic service. For some women, occasional sexual exchange became a supplementary strategy within existing workplaces; for others, it followed expulsion from such employment altogether. In both cases, prostitution functioned less as a discrete occupational choice than as an extension of already marginal survival practices, increasingly shaped by institutional labelling and narrowing alternatives.Footnote 19
Taken together, these forms of precarious employment extended the continuum of vulnerability already visible in domestic service. Although occupationally distinct, they reproduced similar combinations of economic insecurity, moral exposure and institutional scrutiny. Cases from Toledo, Cáceres, Ourense, Madrid and Monforte-Lugo show that women could be classified as being of ‘doubtful conduct’, as ‘leading an immoral life’ or as ‘frequenting suspicious environments’ after neighbour denunciations, labour conflicts or absenteeism from domestic service, before any verified evidence of commercial sex. Early encounters with police and welfare institutions thus arose less as responses to established prostitution than as effects of visibility, reputational vulnerability and community surveillance in morally charged environments. Read together, these files indicate that moral regulation operated through the interaction of informal social control and formal policing rather than through proof of sexual commerce alone.
Once entered into police or welfare records, women were drawn into a cumulative process of institutional designation that helped stabilise marginal status over time. Initial detentions for scandal, vagrancy or suspected venereal disease could trigger medical inspection, temporary confinement and heightened surveillance, producing an enduring bureaucratic trace that constrained later social and occupational mobility. Presented as preventive or corrective measures, these interventions often deepened rather than alleviated vulnerability by continually reinscribing the link between moral status and social position.Footnote 20
Alongside trajectories shaped by early institutional encounters, other women entered prostitution amid acute economic and social pressure, without prior contact with formal systems of regulation or welfare. Rural–urban migration was central to these trajectories. Young women arriving in provincial capitals often did so with limited resources, fragile kinship networks and few viable employment options beyond domestic service or informal labour. When these options collapsed – through dismissal, illness or reputational conflict – sexual exchange could become a contingent survival strategy rather than a deliberate occupational transition.
Motherhood outside marriage constituted a particularly disruptive rupture within these trajectories. In a social context marked by intense moral conservatism, neighbourhood surveillance and the authority of Catholic norms, childbirth outside marriage frequently entailed not only symbolic dishonour but material exclusion: expulsion from the parental home, withdrawal of familial support and effective exclusion from forms of female employment considered morally respectable. Under such conditions, prostitution functioned less as a moral break than as a forced adaptation to compounded vulnerability, as stigma itself narrowed the range of legitimate economic practices. Case files repeatedly show that pregnancy outside marriage was not simply a moral stigma added to poverty; it actively restructured women's access to housing, employment and kin support.
In many cases, entry into prostitution was mediated by the direct intervention of male relatives or intimate partners, revealing the gendered asymmetry of economic and moral control. Police files document, for example, the trajectory of a young rural migrant who entered sexual commerce following the collapse of informal employment, an unmarried mother who turned to prostitution after childbirth outside marriage and subsequent exclusion from familial support, and women introduced into prostitution by intimate partners or male guardians who controlled both housing and income. Fathers, uncles acting as guardians and male partners could thus embed sexual exchange within household economies and pre-existing relations of dependency, blurring the boundary between coercion and adaptation. Rather than representing autonomous choice, these trajectories show how prostitution could be imposed, facilitated or normalised within contexts of male dominance, economic scarcity and limited institutional protection.Footnote 21
The convergence of early vulnerability, constrained labour opportunities and institutional labelling produced conditions in which prostitution became one of the few viable means of subsistence. Such trajectories were rarely linear. Some women alternated between informal sexual exchange and other forms of precarious labour, while others attempted reintegration through marriage, relocation or welfare intervention. Cases such as M.C.F.P. and M.R.R.C. show movement between bar work, other precarious labour, occasional sexual exchange and attempts at reintegration. This movement between survival strategies reflected both structural scarcity and the discretionary application of institutional toleration, while also reinforcing the durability of earlier classifications and stigma and complicating any stable distinction between ‘prostitute’ and ‘non-prostitute’.Footnote 22
Geographical mobility often constituted a response to institutional pressure rather than a strategy of opportunity. Women displaced by expulsions, intensified surveillance or localised moral scrutiny frequently relocated across provincial boundaries, but the cases of M.L.V.M. and M.L.R.M. show that repeated relocations and the use of aliases rarely disrupted institutional continuity. For example, after moving successively through Lugo, Vigo, Madrid and Portugal under different aliases, M.L.V.M. was repeatedly re-identified through the circulation of earlier police reports. Administrative correspondence routinely linked new detentions to previous classifications, demonstrating how institutional memory travelled more effectively than the women themselves. Similar patterns are visible in the trajectory of M.L.R.M., whose previous records likewise accompanied her across jurisdictions.Footnote 23
Post-war governance under the Francoist regime formalised these mechanisms within a moral framework grounded in National Catholic ideals, even as pragmatic tolerance persisted until the abolitionist decree of 1956 redefined the formal legal status of prostitution without dismantling the underlying practices of surveillance and tutelary intervention analysed here. Abolitionist discourse coexisted with tacit permission for prostitution where it was considered controllable, spatially segregated and administratively legible. Police, judicial and welfare interventions formed interlocking circuits of control, with institutions such as the Women's Protection Board increasingly tasked with moral rehabilitation through confinement, supervised labour, religious instruction and medical supervision. This tutelary oversight extended even to women who had not engaged in prostitution: the cases of M.M., a domestic servant expelled after sexual abuse, and A.P.M., who sought institutional protection from her stepfather, show how the Board regulated labour and moral trajectories under the guise of protection. Visible across several provincial archives, this pattern suggests that the Board did not simply ‘rescue’ prostitutes; it widened the field of moral governance by converting vulnerability itself into a reason for intervention.Footnote 24
Taken together, these trajectories demonstrate how early institutional encounters, precarious labour opportunities and repeated forms of social displacement consolidated women's marginalisation. Within this framework, prostitution emerged less as an autonomous choice than as the cumulative product of administrative categorisation, moral regulation and constrained survival strategies.
Stabilisation, Recidivism and the Production of Managed Deviance
Once women had been identified as prostitutes by police, judicial authorities or welfare institutions, subsequent encounters did not simply document conduct but reproduced a classificatory status. In successive police and welfare files, earlier descriptions such as ‘known prostitute’ or ‘mujer de mala vida’ were routinely copied into later reports, including in cases involving attempted withdrawal from commercial sex or periods spent in domestic service. Stabilisation operated through bureaucratic reiteration: earlier designations were transcribed into later police reports, welfare files and court records, transforming an initial attribution into a durable administrative category. Prostitution thus became less a behaviour requiring renewed verification than an administrative status requiring continual confirmation. Prior records functioned as authoritative descriptors that structured evidentiary reasoning and narrowed the range of plausible institutional responses.
This classificatory logic shaped the historical meaning of recidivism. In several long trajectories, women moved intermittently between brothels, bars, arrests, short imprisonments and attempted exits from prostitution, yet remained legible to the authorities through copied descriptors rather than through newly demonstrated acts. Reappearance in police or welfare documentation did not necessarily indicate renewed engagement in prostitution; rather, it reflected the increased probability of intervention once a woman had entered official registers. Repeated detentions, inspections or referrals often followed from prior identification rather than demonstrable new conduct. Recidivism, in this sense, frequently functioned less as evidence of continuous behaviour than as the cumulative effect of repeated documentation, producing the appearance of continuity even where the archival record itself documented discontinuity.Footnote 25
Judicial proceedings reinforced this stabilising mechanism. Court files from the 1940s and 1950s show that women charged with vagrancy, public scandal or minor disorder were routinely introduced as ‘known prostitutes’ or ‘mujer de mala vida’, even when the immediate offence bore no direct relation to sexual commerce. H.A.A., for example, appeared repeatedly in police and judicial records for offences ranging from sheltering bandoleros to corruption of minors, while A.M.Y.H.’s prior identification continued to shape later interventions and restrictions on mobility. Such labels operated as evidentiary shorthand, shaping judicial interpretation and facilitating corrective or custodial measures. Prior police classifications thus migrated into legal adjudication, informing sentencing logic even when prostitution itself was not the immediate issue before the court. In cases involving minors, this prior labelling could displace scrutiny from male defendants onto women already marked as morally suspect, effectively redistributing culpability within the courtroom. The result was not simply harsher treatment, but a narrowing of judicial interpretation: once a woman was already known, alternative explanations became increasingly difficult for courts to sustain.Footnote 26
Welfare intervention, particularly through the Women's Protection Board, further consolidated deviant status. Women referred to the Board were subjected to confinement, supervised labour, religious instruction and medical oversight, formally justified as moral regeneration. Cases such as the repeated confinement of M.F.V. at the Special Women's Reformatory of Santander or the tutelary placement of the F.P. sisters show how these interventions generated extensive documentary records that reproduced the very categories they sought to correct. Documentation from the Provincial Board for the Protection of Women in Pontevedra indicates the persistence of these practices beyond the formal abolition of regulated prostitution in 1956. Files concerning young women placed under tutelary supervision repeatedly identified domestic service, pregnancy outside marriage, mobility without effective family control and sociability with men as signs of ‘moral danger’, even in the absence of proven prostitution. In practice, prior classification often carried greater weight than demonstrable conduct.Footnote 27
Taken together, these practices formed an interlocking apparatus. Police identification frequently triggered referral to welfare institutions or judicial authorities; welfare non-compliance, institutional escape or disciplinary infractions returned women to police scrutiny; judicial proceedings explicitly cited prior administrative classifications. As reconstructed trajectories reveal, women moved repeatedly between police supervision, welfare confinement and judicial intervention, with earlier classifications circulating across files and institutions. Through this circulation, prostitution emerged less as a discrete occupational decision than as the cumulative effect of reiterative documentation across institutional domains. Stabilisation was therefore less the reflection of stable conduct than the outcome of administrative reproduction within a system that privileged memory over verification.Footnote 28
This pattern resonates with scholarship on twentieth-century European abolitionist systems of sexual regulation, which has shown that formally abolitionist frameworks did not eliminate administrative management but reorganised it through surveillance, welfare intervention and documentary accumulation. In post-war France, the closure of licensed brothels did not dissolve the nexus between prostitution and police registration but reconfigured it around new forms of monitoring and moral categorisation. In Spain between 1936 and 1956, the consolidation of Francoist authority intensified rather than disrupted this classificatory logic: abolitionist rhetoric coexisted with practices that stabilised prostitution as a manageable, documentable and administratively legible condition.Footnote 29
Police and welfare authorities demonstrated a marked capacity to reconstitute identity across space through physical description, prior file references and inter-provincial communication. Archival evidence from Ourense documents this mechanism directly: the files of M.L.V.M. and M.L.R.M. show how successive relocations between Lugo, Vigo, León, Pontevedra, A Coruña, Santiago, Madrid, Barcelona and Portugal generated new institutional encounters without dissolving prior classifications. On the contrary, police files incorporated aliases and earlier interventions into consolidated dossiers, so that each displacement added documentary density rather than fragmenting administrative knowledge. Spatial circulation therefore became one of the mechanisms through which deviant status was reproduced: each encounter expanded the documentary trace, rendering subsequent identification more efficient and more difficult to contest.Footnote 30
Urban concentration further structured this dynamic. Cities marked by ports, military installations, transport hubs or seasonal labour demand – including Madrid, Barcelona and Vigo – absorbed women displaced from smaller localities. These movements inserted prostitution into broader circuits shaped by wartime disruption, post-war scarcity and uneven urbanisation. Yet urban relocation did not signify institutional anonymity. Larger centres facilitated coordinated supervision through specialised police units, welfare boards and medical inspection regimes. Spatial concentration enhanced both surveillance capacity and selective toleration, enabling authorities to confine prostitution to administratively legible zones while maintaining rhetorical commitment to moral regeneration. Files concerning expulsions, detentions and welfare referrals regularly circulated between provincial authorities together with summarised moral assessments and references to prior interventions, allowing women to be re-identified across jurisdictions.Footnote 31
Rather than interrupting marginal trajectories, mobility frequently relocated them within new circuits of administrative oversight. Displacement across municipal or provincial lines altered the geography of intervention but not its underlying logic. Police registration, welfare referral and medical inspection operated through inter-provincial circuits that extended beyond local boundaries, ensuring that prior designations informed subsequent encounters. Deviance was not anchored to a single locality but circulated within an administrative field structured by documentation, communication and institutional coordination. The evidence from Ourense is especially revealing because it documents dense inter-provincial and cross-border circuits of surveillance and displacement, making visible the scale at which administrative continuity operated.
This dynamic accords with broader scholarship on twentieth-century European systems of sexual regulation, which has emphasised the persistence of surveillance infrastructures under formally abolitionist regimes. The dismantling of regulated brothel systems in several European contexts did not dissolve mechanisms of identification and monitoring but reconfigured them through welfare, policing and medical oversight. In Spain between the Civil War and the abolitionist decree of 1956, mobility reveals the durability of these infrastructures: even when women moved, the classificatory apparatus remained mobile with them.Footnote 32
The continuity of administrative practices becomes particularly visible in trajectories spanning the Republican and Francoist periods. D.R.P., for example, first entered police records in July 1935 after being found by two police officers engaged in sexual intercourse with J.G.G. near the Jardín del Posío. Although both insisted that no payment had been involved and that they had maintained a romantic relationship for several months, she was nevertheless classified as a prostitute. When her file resumed in March 1940, police documentation described her as clandestinely practising prostitution from a rented room, without revisiting the circumstances that had originally led to her classification. What persisted across regime change was less the evidentiary basis for identifying her as a prostitute than the administrative continuity of that classification, even as Francoist authorities increasingly reframed such cases through the language of moral disorder and social discipline.Footnote 33
This interpretation is consistent with recent scholarship on prostitution and social regulation in the late Restoration and the Second Republic, which has shown that police registration, medical inspection and administrative surveillance already constituted central instruments for rendering prostitution administratively visible and governable before 1936. Rather than creating these mechanisms de novo, the Franco regime incorporated them into an ideological framework shaped by National Catholicism, intensifying their scope and institutional reach while reorienting them towards the project of moral regeneration.Footnote 34
The Civil War and the immediate post-war period intensified existing mechanisms of classification and control without fundamentally transforming their underlying logic. Wartime disruption, material scarcity and the militarisation of urban space did not generate a new regulatory framework for prostitution; rather, they accelerated institutional practices already oriented towards visibility, containment and moral policing. For some women, increased reliance on precarious subsistence strategies, including transactional sexual relationships, coincided with heightened surveillance capacities, producing deeper institutional entanglement rather than structural reorientation.
Early wartime detentions exemplify this dynamic. The cases of B.V.G., D.V.L. and M.V.G. show how conflict conditions rapidly increased institutional visibility through police intervention and welfare referral, embedding women within classificatory systems that long predated the war itself. Their files linked wartime mobility and exposure in militarised urban spaces to broader suspicions of moral danger, even where direct evidence of prostitution remained limited or absent. The war thus functioned as an accelerant of surveillance, intensifying scrutiny while leaving intact the administrative grammar through which prostitution was identified and managed. The most significant shift after 1936 therefore lay less in the creation of entirely new mechanisms than in the intensification and ideological reframing of existing forms of control.Footnote 35
In the post-1939 context, economic collapse and social reordering further entrenched these dynamics. Sanctions, rationing regimes and the exclusion of defeated families from relief disproportionately affected widows, women with dependants and households fragmented by imprisonment or execution. These pressures expanded informal survival economies in which sexual exchange intersected with domestic labour, lodging and affective relationships. Police and welfare documentation repeatedly framed such arrangements through the language of disorder, immorality or clandestinity rather than material necessity. Institutional responses consistently treated these practices as moral deviance rather than adaptive strategies under conditions of scarcity. Administrative attention prioritised regulation of visibility and space, reinforcing classificatory stability while obscuring the material roots of vulnerability.
This pragmatic moralism is particularly evident in the regulation of clandestine and informal prostitution. Rather than targeting sexual behaviour directly, authorities focused on the material and spatial conditions that rendered such practices legible. The case of P.A.V., fined for renting rooms used for prostitution, and that of E.E.N., who repurposed a former brothel to rent rooms to couples following abolition, reveal how economic penalties and discretionary toleration structured control. Sanctions operated as instruments for managing space and profit rather than eradicating sexual exchange, embedding informal prostitution within household survival strategies while maintaining administrative oversight.Footnote 36
Under both wartime and post-war conditions, institutional practice thus converged on management rather than elimination. Surveillance, periodic sanction and documentary accumulation proved more adaptable than repression in contexts of scarcity and social instability. The Civil War did not disrupt the classificatory order governing prostitution; it intensified its reach. By deepening administrative memory and expanding the range of women rendered inspectable, conflict and reconstruction reinforced prostitution's status as a stable, governable category within the Francoist moral economy.
The consolidation of Francoist rule did not inaugurate a wholly new regime of sexual regulation so much as routinise and stabilise existing practices through ideological and administrative rearticulation. What distinguished the post-war period was not simply increased repression, but the normalisation of administrative management: prostitution became legible as a problem to be regulated across welfare, police and judicial spheres rather than eradicated.
Welfare intervention played a central role in this process. Through the Women's Protection Board, a broad range of women were drawn into tutelary regimes that regulated labour, mobility and moral conduct under the language of protection and rehabilitation. Crucially, such oversight extended well beyond verified prostitution. As the trajectories examined in the previous section suggest, welfare authority operated preventively by converting vulnerability itself into grounds for supervision. In doing so, it generated dense administrative records that stabilised moral classification even in the absence of sexual commerce, reinforcing the continuum between assistance, surveillance and control.Footnote 37
Judicial practice mirrored this ambivalence. Post-war court records reveal a preference for measures aimed at regulation rather than long-term incapacitation. Sentences frequently prioritised short-term confinement, forced relocation or corrective supervision, while moralised language persisted in judicial rhetoric. Prostitution was thus treated less as a criminal offence requiring decisive punishment than as a recurring social problem to be contained through flexible sanctions. Legal authority relied heavily on prior administrative classifications, allowing courts to manage women already marked as morally suspect without committing to their permanent exclusion from social space.Footnote 38
Taken together, welfare and judicial practice in the post-war period consolidated prostitution as a managed form of deviance. Abolitionist language coexisted with routine intervention; protection operated alongside coercion; and women already identified in police or welfare records remained tightly constrained by documentary memory and repeated supervision across institutional settings. Rather than resolving prostitution as a moral problem, Francoist governance stabilised it as an administratively intelligible condition, sustained through overlapping circuits of care, discipline and selective tolerance. The concept of managed deviance therefore captures these dynamics more precisely than either simple repression or tacit liberalisation.
Through sustained interaction with police forces, welfare authorities and courts, women became embedded in an administrative environment in which prostitution was reproduced as a durable social position. Stabilisation did not arise from individual persistence, recalcitrance or inherent moral deficiency, but from the cumulative effects of institutional circulation, documentary repetition and classificatory memory. Once established, administrative identities constrained subsequent encounters, shaped the range of permissible responses and limited the possibility of definitive exit. In this sense, prostitution functioned less as a discrete activity than as a trajectory produced and sustained through governance.
These findings complicate linear narratives of repression or reform by foregrounding the productive effects of institutional intervention. Administrative practices, combined with restricted labour opportunities and constrained mobility, generated conditions in which prostitution proved structurally resistant to eradication or meaningful resolution. Instead, it was stabilised as a manageable condition, continuously reproduced through surveillance, welfare supervision and selective judicial intervention across the Civil War and the first two decades of Francoist rule, culminating in the abolitionist reform of 1956.
In broader perspective, this analysis invites a re-situating of prostitution within the social history of labour, welfare and state formation in twentieth-century Spain. The trajectories reconstructed here show that prostitution operated as a structurally embedded form of marginal labour, shaped by gendered labour markets, moral regulation and administrative governance. Rather than constituting an exceptional or residual phenomenon, it emerged as a predictable outcome of regimes that combined limited economic integration for women with expansive systems of classification and control. From this perspective, the governance of prostitution appears not as a failed project of moral eradication, but as a durable mode of managing female marginality under authoritarian conditions.
Conclusion
This article argues that prostitution in Spain between the Civil War and the abolitionist decree of 1956 should be understood not as a fixed social condition or individual moral failing, but as a historically produced trajectory shaped through cumulative practices of governance. Drawing on more than two hundred reconstructed trajectories across police, judicial and welfare archives, it shows that sustained engagement in prostitution was frequently preceded – and in some cases structured – by early institutional encounters linked to precarious labour, domestic service, mobility, moral suspicion and acute social vulnerability.
Entry into prostitution rarely constituted an abrupt rupture. Rather, it emerged at the intersection of restricted labour markets, gendered stigma and institutional processes of identification that progressively narrowed women's life chances. Once activated, administrative attention tended to persist across time and space. Reiterative documentation, inter-institutional circulation and the preservation of administrative memory transformed contingent practices into durable classificatory identities, so that apparent recidivism often reflected the self-reinforcing logic of surveillance regimes organised around containment and restricted mobility rather than demonstrable behavioural continuity.
The combined use of police, judicial and documentation from the Women's Protection Board enables a longitudinal reconstruction of these dynamics. Police records reveal forms of administrative memory capable of sustaining deviant identities despite geographical displacement, alias usage and fragmented life courses. Read alongside welfare and judicial sources, they expose the cumulative circulation of women across multiple arenas of governance. Even strategies intended to evade control – such as mobility or the adoption of alternative identities – frequently prompted the refinement of identification techniques, reinforcing institutional traceability rather than disrupting it.
The consolidation of the Francoist dictatorship did not inaugurate a radically new regime of sexual governance; rather, it intensified and routinised pre-existing mechanisms of moral and social regulation within the ideological framework of National Catholicism. Abolitionist discourse coexisted with pragmatic toleration, and welfare intervention operated alongside coercive policing. Far from eliminating prostitution, Francoist governance rendered it administratively legible and institutionally containable, embedding it within the regime's broader moral economy.
In comparative perspective, the Spanish case speaks to wider European dynamics in which prostitution was governed through dispersed institutions rather than through a single stable legal category. Across the reconstructed trajectories, condemnation and accommodation were gendered practices enacted through police surveillance, welfare tutelage and judicial interpretation, producing durable classifications that travelled with women across space, while male sexual demand remained largely outside equivalent regimes of scrutiny and moral intervention. Political rupture mattered most in the intensity and ideological framing of control – especially under wartime conditions and post-war moral reordering – while administrative logics of identification and documentary persistence remained operative across the period studied.
By conceptualising prostitution as a trajectory rather than a static condition, this article reconceptualises authoritarian moral governance as a productive apparatus that generated the marginality it purported to contain. It shifts the analytical focus from policy as declared intention to bureaucratic practice as the primary site at which deviance was constituted and reproduced as a structurally durable condition. In doing so, it underscores the value of everyday police records – read in conjunction with welfare and judicial archives – as a privileged source base for understanding how regimes governed sexuality in practice as well as in principle.
Acknowledgements
The author gratefully acknowledges the Universidade de Vigo and the Consorcio Interuniversitario do Sistema Universitario de Galicia (CISUG) for funding the open-access publication of this article.
