With a preface by Soraiya Faroqhi and a postscript by Gottefried Hagan, this work crowns the research of Robert Dankoff on Evliya Çelebi's Seyahatname, particularly as it represents the Ottoman worldview. I am even more pleased to introduce this book because I was one of those who heard Dankoff speak of its beginnings in 1999, at the conference of the National Institute of Oriental Languages and Civilizations in Paris. It is true that this is not a complete critical edition of the Seyahatname (The Book of Travels). The complete edition of the book by the Turkish scholar Yapi ve Kredi Yayinlari is forthcoming, thanks in part to Dankoff, who contributes to volume nine. However, many of the secrets of the manuscript have already become available to us through several of Dankoff's previous publications, notably An Evliya Çelebi Glossary: Unusual Dialectal and Foreign Words in the Seyahat-name (1991); Sources of Oriental Languages and Literatures, ed. Finasi Tekin and Gönül Alpay Tekin; Evliya Çelebi inBitlis (1990); and A Guide to the Seyâhât-Nâme of Evliyâ Çelebî, in Materialien zu Evliyâ Çelebî II, with Klaus Kreiser (1992); and Evliyâ Çelebî in Albania and Adjacent Regions (Kosovo, Montenegro, Ohrid), with Robert Elsie (2000).
Evliya Çelebi was the first Ottoman author to give an almost complete description of the Ottoman Empire and its hinterlands (excluding North Africa). Dankoff is the first scholar to attempt a cohesive analysis of the Seyahatname. The book is composed of six chapters (as well as a glossary, bibliography, and index), with each focusing on a particular characteristic of Çelebi and his work.
“Man of Istanbul” compares Books I and X of Çelebi's work to illuminate the way in which the author envisioned Istanbul and Cairo as the dual capitals of the empire. In this chapter, Dankoff systematically lays out the ten books of the Seyahatname and notes the themes relevant to Çelebi's discussion of these capital cities in each one. The author highlights the importance of Istanbul for Çelebi, as the place where he was born and spent his first thirty years, and the base to which he returns after each of his voyages. As a result, the information that he gives us about the capital is extremely rich and largely authentic. Robert Mantran could have based his study, Istanbul in the Second Half of the 17th Century, on the facts of the Seyâhatnâme. The family and childhood of the author (what little we know) had his intellectual formation at the feet of masters and in the imperial palace. In particular, the different subjects and numerous works that he studied were the object of remarkable developments with passages borrowed from the traveler.
The second chapter, “Man of the World,” concentrates on Evliya Çelebi's world view, which remained fundamentally that of a Sunni Muslim, Ottoman Turk, and Istanbulite, and it was through these categories that he judged the world. He is so sure of the superiority of the Sublime Porte that he often treats other peoples and states with contempt. On the model of works by Acâib ül-Garâib, he describes with amusement, and often for the purposes of storytelling, the manners and customs of the people that he meets. For the purpose of humor, ethnic stereotypes are used in abundance, provided that reasons need to be given. Even the “Turks”—despite being described as “protected,” in contrast to “foreigners,” particularly during battles—do not escape his dark humor. (Contrary to what is said on page 64, Dankoff wrote to tell me that the phrase etrak-i bi-idrak [Turks without intelligence] did exist in the Seyahatname [IX, 137b18]). Thus, Çelebi's tolerance did have its limits (pp. 63–76).
The third chapter, “Servitor of the Sultan,” which is dedicated to Çelebi, is a vast fresco describing good governance and socioeconomic protocols between the different professional communities in Istanbul and Cairo, particularly during processions and ceremonies. He evokes brilliantly in this chapter scenes of Ottoman justice—while, at the same time, a certain number of injustices are being perpetrated on the population; certain mysteries that surrounded the Ottoman dynasty and other prominent public figures; and the power of the empire in contrast to certain large projects that were not realized, such as the canal connecting the Sakarya River and Lake Sapanca to the Gulf of Izmit or the Suez Canal.
However, Evliya was first a “çelebi” and Sufi. Dankoff suggests that he was a Gülcheni dervish (the fourth chapter “Gentleman and Dervish”). He was also raised on the music of Ömer Gülsheni de Tokat (p. 122). Because his essential mission is to travel and recount what he sees, he often finds himself on missions on behalf of sultans and pashas, sometimes as imam, muezzin, confidant (nedim), but also as the attendant of guards, emissary, special courier, scribe, or accountant.
Naturally, the principal “profession” of Çelebi is to be a traveler and, above all, a “storyteller” with a humoristic and anecdotal style. Thus, the fifth chapter, “Raconteur,” attempts to measure the veracity of the facts contained in The Book of Travels. The pages dedicated to his fetishistic details number around sixty, and reveal the taste for entertainment possessed by Çelebi. The extraordinary stories that he invents or that he reports when he describes cities and regions are part of this tendency to exaggerate. This does not prevent him from giving certain reliable statistics, as some researchers have noted.
Thus, Çelebi uses all the means at his disposal to “persuade” and “amuse” his audience. In the sixth and final chapter, “Reporter and Entertainer,” Dankoff examines Çelebi's entourage and the audience with which he shares some of his observations throughout the winters in the capital, as well as the provinces. His listeners are sultans, notably his pasha benefactors, such as Melek Ahmed and his wife Kaya Sultane, the khan of Crimea, and a multitude of shaykhs and courtesans.
Dankoff has accomplished an enterprise of exceptional dimensions after many years of experience with and work on the Seyâhâtnâme. I look forward to many more works of this magnitude and importance.
