Standard accounts in English which place the Huns at the centre of their investigation are now quite old (Thompson 1948, limited up-dating by Heather, 1996) or incomplete (Maenchen-Helfen 1973), though they naturally also feature significantly in the more numerous modern studies of the Goths. Kelly aims to rectify this lapse in a study divided into four parts: background and context; the Hunnic rise to power in the fifth century; the embassy of Priscus to Attila's court; Attila's final campaigns and posthumous collapse. The twenty-four chapters, often with titles such as ‘Shock and Awe’, ‘Mission Impossible’ or ‘Hearts and Minds’, whose contemporary cleverness may not stand the test of time, are topped and tailed with a brief account of Attila's funeral and a more extended survey of his varied afterlife. The contemporary historian Priscus, who observed Attila at diplomatic work and festive repose, is inevitably at the heart of this enterprise. It is difficult, however enthusiastic the approach (230), to go far beyond Priscus’ fragmentary information, and impossible to present any sustained analysis of Attila's motivation, without resorting to conjecture and imagination. At various points K. admits that this is his procedure (e.g. 78, 85, 203, 248), but readers will need to beware repeating notions such as that Aspar was appointed as ambassador to Attila in a.d. 441: this is presented in the text without qualification (93–5), but admitted to be groundless speculation in the notes (254). In other respects K.'s most significant contribution to the standard accounts, apart from much sensible up-dating in the light of recent specialist studies, is to spice the narrative with evocative adjectives, colloquial asides (another transient aspect), and reminders of the realities of ancient life, for example the horrors concealed by brief statements of a city's sack. The location of all references to sources and scholarly discussions within a single endnote for each chapter also suggests that the volume is aimed at a general market.
I noted a couple of missed opportunities. Asemus, a small north Balkan city which managed to deflect Attila's demands for the return of Roman fugitives and Hunnic prisoners, is not mentioned; the incident supports K.'s suggestions that Attila was not quite so all-conquering as his image presents, since his destruction of Roman sites was not comprehensive and determined opposition could lead him to back down. Second, in considering the impact of Hunnic destruction on popular thought, it would have been worth pursuing the apocalyptic image of the hordes of Gog and Magog who poured, in Hunnic guise, through Alexander's Iron Gate in the Caucasus in the Syriac Christian stories about Alexander. This is a counterpart to the image of Attila in the West as the scourge of God whose threat supported the development of various stories about saints who protected their cities: Nicasius at Metz, Geneviève at Paris, Lupus at Troyes. K. approves of Priscus’ positive assessment of Attila the man as an effective and inspiring leader, in contrast to the treacherous incompetence of the Constantinople court. This may be justified, since Attila's persona unified his federation, but Priscus is not the only ancient historian to present criticism of a contemporary regime through a rosy view of an external rival; Hunnic fugitives related to Attila who were impaled immediately after being surrendered by the Romans might have disagreed. The fact that Attila stamped his authority very extensively across central Europe in less than a decade is an impressive achievement, but it is questionable whether he deserves praise as a great empire builder (228). Even more than Alexander the Great, Attila was a man of action, whose control was built upon the sheer terror of his personality and so was uninheritable; Alexander's empire largely survived simply because he had conquered territories which already possessed a durable administration, whereas Attila dominated tribes with no such tradition of central organization so that any heir would have to start from scratch, a challenge which was beyond Attila's fractious sons.
K. has digested academic scholarship into a sound and readable popular account, which might also spark reflection on some big contemporary questions that are tucked away on the final page (230).
