This thought-provoking volume, edited by Doris Sommer, is the result of a multi-year project that was funded by the Ford Foundation and asked scholars based across the United States and Latin America to engage with the concept of cultural agency and to think through its meanings and implications in their work. The collection contains a critical introduction by Sommer, 14 essays and two Afterwords. The essays are divided into three sections: ‘Media’, ‘Maneuvers’ and ‘Cautions’. The contributors come from a range of disciplines in the humanities and social sciences, though the majority are based in anthropology or media studies.
The epigraph that opens the Introduction suggests that ‘culture is the area in which humanist values are created and established’ (p. 1). Sommer then sets out to create a framework to understand the concept of cultural agency, who cultural agents are, and where they are located. The book identifies cultural agency ‘as a range of social contributions through creative practices’ (p. 1). The approach advocated follows the Gramscian tradition of not waiting for perfect conditions or transformations and instead finding what Sommer terms the ‘wiggle room’ that opens up spaces for subjects to empower themselves and bring about change. Sommer also introduces a key theme in the collection, which is the relationship between research and activism and how these can work together instead of in opposition or conflict. She calls scholars out of passivity and pessimism and towards a reflective practice that engages in a reciprocal relationship between researchers and activists.
The first section, ‘Media’, examines different vehicles for cultural agency. It includes discussions by Jesús Martín Barbero on how to intervene through research practice, Néstor García Canclini on the possible impact of cultural policies on the socio-economic development of Mexico City, and Diana Taylor on how public performance in Argentina turns trauma into a vehicle for cultural agency. The second section, ‘Maneuvers’, is concerned with interventions and provides examples of how scholars and activists find wiggle room. This section contains the largest number of essays, which treat a diverse range of examples of how culture enables agency. These include topics relating to gender, religious tradition, bicultural education, radio and theatre. The final section, ‘Cautions’, warns of how cultural agency can go wrong. Charles R. Hale and Rosamel Millamán discuss the struggles over representations of Mapuche culture by the Mapuche and the state, while Santiago Villaveces-Izquierdo relates the story of Colombia's ‘violentologists’ and their interventions and exile. The collection concludes with two Afterwords by Mary Louise Pratt and Claudio Lomnitz which, instead of bringing closure, move the project forward by inviting readers to think through how culture is a space for agency.
One of the greatest strengths of this collection is that it is grounded in concrete examples that move it from the theoretical into the practical. The addition of the ‘Cautions’ section in particular offers balance to what otherwise could be an idealistic vision of how cultural practices can create spaces for subjects to empower themselves. The approach of this collection means that readers are offered many different perspectives on cultural agency and are able to see its complications and ambivalences, as well as its successes. As Mary Louise Pratt suggests in her Afterword, it is a foundational gesture that opens a dialogue for those researchers and practitioners interested in engaging with these questions.
As a group the essays define and illustrate cultural agency through its practice but, with few exceptions, they do not engage directly with it in theoretical terms. This is left to the Introduction and the Afterwords. On first reading this seemed to be a weakness, but on reflection it is perhaps one of the strengths of the collection, as it reflects a work in progress or captures a time of change in the ways that scholars are treating questions about how political and social change is brought about and what their own positioning in that process might be.
Those interested in reflecting critically on their relationship to research and to political and social transformation will find this a very useful book. Some humanists, those in literature or history, for instance, may find the emphasis on anthropology and communication studies less helpful, as it reflects quite different disciplinary practices. But if this book is a foundational gesture, it also asks us to enter into the dialogue. As one of the outcomes of a project, this collection seems to act out the call for change. The project as a whole and the book as a part of it move us forward to new scholarly practice and approaches. As such, the book represents an important contribution and essential reading for those interested in taking up the challenge of being reflective cultural agents.
