The study of magic in the ancient world is one of those disciplines where no-one entirely agrees with anyone else on the meaning of the concept being discussed. Much has been written about what may, or (as it turns out) may not be ancient magic, and how it related to religion, medicine, healing and ritual, without bringing us much closer to a final answer. It is into this interesting, but sometimes problematic, research area that Radcliffe Edmonds has tried to dig out a new path with Drawing Down the Moon. In a nutshell, the volume is a new contribution that seeks to outline what magic in the Greco-Roman world was and convey a sense of its scope, practices and character.
Synthetic publications on this theme do appear every few years. The most recent is a contribution by Lindsay C. Watson (Magic in Ancient Greece and Rome, 2019; see Parker, BMCW 2020.03.28 for a review). They are inheritors of works like Fritz Graf's 1997 Magic in the Ancient World, as well as source-based works by Georg Luck (Arcana Mundi, 1985) and Daniel Ogden (Magic, Witchcraft and Ghosts, 2002) and chronologically narrower overviews like that of Faraone and Obbink (Magika Hiera, 1991). Drawing Down the Moon fits firmly within this tradition — taking a thematic approach to different aspects of ancient magical practices and drawing heavily on classical texts and surviving textual sources to inform and extrapolate. That is not necessarily a criticism, as E. has here produced the most synthetic of these works in a little over 400 pages. It begins with a now almost obligatory attempt to define the subject. For E., magic is ritual that is non-normative in emic terms. This approach avoids characterising magic negatively (e.g. as ‘not religion’). Instead it allows E. to adopt a set of criteria (efficacy, aims, social location of the performer, the style of the performance) which can be used to test whether an instance of ritual action can be placed within ‘the discourse of magic’ (32).
The subsequent chapters cover cursing rituals, love charms and erotic curses, healing and protective magic, prayers, divination, astrology, alchemy and philosophy. This is all big picture in its scope. The reason that synthetic volumes on magic in the Greco-Roman world exist is because there were considerable continuities, as in other cultural domains. This does, however, pose a problem, in that the sweeping scope entails a fundamentally essentialist approach to the ancient world. Undoubtedly there was not a uniform experience of ancient magic between the central Mediterranean in the fifth century b.c. and the north-western provinces at the end of the Roman Imperial period (nor does E. say as much), but one might get the sense that these specific topics were at all times ubiquitous in the ancient (Western) world — something which is patently untrue. A tradition of writing down spells was clearly present in pre-Roman Egypt, and phallic imagery became increasingly popular in the Mediterranean basin through the Classical period and beyond, but there is no evidence for either in Britain until the Roman invasion of the first century a.d. The focus of the book is very much on the longue durée, leaving little room for nuance in terms of materials or practices that may be not have been ubiquitous. E. is clearly aiming for bigger game with this text, so its utility for scholars of the provinces may be limited.
The chapters are constructed through a question-led approach: ‘What is the evidence for erotic magic?’ ‘Why practice erotic magic?’ ‘How does erotic magic work?’, etc. There are very useful short conclusions at the end of each chapter drawing the narrative back to the author's fundamental conception of magic (that which might be ‘non-normative’) and what we might learn from this. This approach is a sharp pedagogical tool that helps the reader to digest the huge breadth of the subject at hand. Within the chapters, the focus returns time and again to what may have constituted normative or non-normative ritual action. By analysing the topics through both emic and etic lenses in turn, E. aims to show that magic was a variable process, act or phenomenon. He does this in a rather functionalist way. One might pertinently counter E.'s own questions of ‘how do amulets and other protective and healing magics work?’ with questions like ‘why does it matter if we know how they work?’. These questions are not really considered in Drawing Down the Moon because the author's focus is on investigating ancient ritual practices to test whether they can be characterised as magical. This is the scaffolding that holds the book together.
The distinction between emic and etic categories is a central and important feature of E.'s approach. In their introduction to Magical Practice in the Latin West (2010), Gordon and Marco Simón expressly rejected discussion of ‘the emic/etic “problem”’, favouring a ‘rough and ready operational definition’ of magic, and other scholars have avoided it too. Yet Bremmer already noted its importance in his introduction to The Materiality of Magic (2015): ‘Although it is true that historians have applied the opposition emic/etic much less often than anthropologists, there can be no doubt that the better ones have seen its usefulness’. The distinction is central to Drawing Down the Moon. The emic approach may perhaps have lent itself to a fuller study of the materiality of ancient magic, though that is not the intention of E.'s volume. More use could have been made of objects in the question-led approach, since objects can provoke questions that texts might not. The volume is not overtly visual; there are colour plates of a very high quality, but the visual focus is on elements of written spells and Greek-inscribed magical gemstones.
That said, this is a fresh, modern take on the subject of ancient magic. It is no easy task to try and find sense and reason across ritual practices covering nearly a millennium, but this volume is a bold effort at doing so. It is certainly one I will be returning to in the future.
The name R. S. O. Tomlin will be well known to the readers of this journal. In her introduction to Litterae Magicae, Celia Sánchez Natalias remarks rightly that the lack of a Festschrift in his honour has been an oversight. Tomlin has made a significant contribution to epigraphy and especially to the study of ancient magical practices, through the translation and publication of the curse tablets from Bath (UK) and subsequent work on other curse tablets and phylacteries from Roman Britain. Sara Chiarini sums it up eloquently in the introduction to her contribution: ‘Tomlin's contribution to the debate on literacy and writing in the Roman world can be quantified not only in his tireless work of deciphering and supplying the scientific community with hundreds of new Latin documents from the Roman provinces, but also in specific studies devoted to the practices and tools relating the writing down of defixiones in Roman Britain’ (131).
The body of this volume is a mixed palette of contributions, as befits its nature, organised into three substantive parts. The first is an interview with the honouree, given to I. Czeti and D. Seres in Budapest in 2017 after he received the István Hahn Prize, followed by a bibliography of his extensive publications. The second is a group of six papers discussing translations and re-translations of some epigraphic materials. Three are written in English, two in German and one in Italian. The third section is a group of essays on magical texts. This is followed by a list of abbreviations (essential reading in a book about magical texts) and bibliography. The contributors to this volume are a veritable Who's Who of Roman magical studies and S. has done well to draw them all together under this single aegis.
The volume presents a valuable series of communiqués, primarily on subjects related to the Roman cursing tradition and Romano-Egyptian spells. Undoubtedly, its greatest value will be for scholars in this research area. Personally, I found the interview with Professor Tomlin of great interest. Tomlin was influenced directly by the likes of Roger Syme and Eric Birley. There is raw honesty in this interview, such as the description of his creation of a pseudo-Christianised curse to aid a teacher friend (who subsequently deposited the curse off the coast of Swansea) or the account of the misogynistic teaching practices of Eduard Fraenkel at Oxford. Ultimately this is a Festschrift and the influence and contribution of Tomlin can certainly be seen in each paper. If anyone is in doubt about his expansive contribution to the fields of epigraphy and philology, the subsequent bibliography has over 128 entries covering the period 1972–2018.
These two recent publications on the topic of ancient magic are quite different texts, both in terms of subject and organisation. Litterae Magicae is an edited volume aimed at specialists and celebrating one of its great contributors. Drawing Down the Moon is something of a magnum opus designed to introduce the kaleidoscope of ancient magic, though it is also aimed at an academic or student audience rather than being for popular consumption. They could both readily have a place on the bookshelf of scholars of ancient magic and religion.
