In Hinterland Dreams, Eric Morser uses La Crosse, one of my favorite Midwestern cities, as a subject for his examination of the political economy of the late nineteenth and early twentieth century and its impact on the growth of a frontier river town. Hinterland Dreams is a well written, thoroughly researched, and insightful story of the growth of a Midwestern town. Morser provides an abundance of useful maps and photos, which add interest, especially if one is familiar with the city.
Morser paints a picture of the political impact on economic development. His story is that when there is an opportunity for profit, the government will step in to take control. As he argues, this is a good thing for all of the public goods benefits that the government provides, such as defining and enforcing property rights and improving waterways for shipping, and building railroads and bridges. He goes on to argue that the existence of these public goods is the backbone upon which the further exploration, and indeed profitable exploitation, of the resources in the area is built.
He tells his story in chronological fashion, with each chapter focused on a different facet of the economy. The familiar string throughout the book is the indispensability of the government in the growth of La Crosse in particular, and frontier towns in general. While the importance of public goods is not to be denied, Morser oversells his argument a bit.
In the opening chapter, he focuses on the fate of the indigenous population at the hands of the expanding American frontier. He weaves tales of adventurous explorers in the Mississippi Valley and how government-funded exploration led to the publication of stories about the frontier, stoking interest in exploiting its riches among pioneers with wanderlust.
The next three chapters deal with public goods as they apply to a particular industry: fur trade, lumber, and the railroad. He uses these growing industries to sell the notion that the creation and enforcement of property rights by the government was critical in the settlement and growth of frontier towns. While the importance of well-defined property rights is readily recognized by economists, they will not, in and of themselves, result in economic growth. This is the weakest part of Morser's book—his overemphasis on the role of government.
For example, we learn that “in the end, state incorporation made it possible for [Cadwallader] Washburn to raise the money necessary to expand his lumber operations and, in turn, helped him to become a prosperous mill owner” (p. 57). It is true that the existence of stable property rights was useful, but it would have been equally as useful to anybody else. He hints at this idea when he notes that “[Gideon] Hixon‘s story of government policy, pineland, and economic prosperity was certainly not the norm for most La Crosse lumbermen. It does suggest, however, that some residents were able to take advantage of public land policy to prosper in the lumber industry” (p. 61). But he doesn't tell us why Hixon succeeded where others failed. We never get a clue as to what it was about these entrepreneurs that elevated them above everyone else who could avail themselves of these same government policies. It would have been nice to hear a little bit about what it was that separated the Nathan Myricks, Cadwallader Washburns, and Gideon Hixons, who achieved fantastic wealth in La Crosse, from the legions of those who tried but failed.
Chapter 5 turns the focus on local government and its role in the provision of water, lights, and local transportation, which moved La Crosse from an outpost to a “civilized” city. While interesting to a local, this chapter is likely to be a bit dry for most readers. There is a good general discussion of municipal versus private provision of public goods, but no data to illustrate the points or suggest the value of the possible outcomes. We learn that La Crosse settled on a municipal water supply and private streetcar system, but not the impact of either. As a result, we don't really learn much about when private markets will dominate the public provision of goods, or what makes an efficient investment.
Chapter 6, which covers labor markets and labor rights, is the best in the book. It is the least specific to La Crosse, and has good general information about the labor movement during the late nineteenth century and the difficulties of advancing labor's cause in the existing political climate. Given the current political turmoil over labor rights in Wisconsin, this is a timely chapter with broad appeal.
Chapter 7 is equally as appealing. Morser gives a nice summary of changes in laws regarding women's property rights and the suffrage movement in the last half of the nineteenth century. He then goes on to use local examples to illustrate the impact of these changes on Midwestern frontier cities such as La Crosse.
Morser is clearly a talented writer and careful researcher, and the construction of the book shows off these skills. Each chapter begins with an anecdote about an entrepreneur in La Crosse, which the author then uses as a springboard to discuss the impact of government on the political and economic environment in La Crosse in particular, and the Midwestern frontier in general. It is a well written study of a small Midwestern town and highlights the importance of government in the growth of our frontier. Even if it is not a balanced view of economic growth, it is one worth reading.
