I. INTRODUCTION
The very first article of the very first issue of the very first journal devoted to the history of economic thought had this title: “Research Priorities in the History of Economics.” The article, which appeared in History of Political Economy (HOPE) in 1969, was written by A. W. Coats, who was at the time, as Craufurd Goodwin tells me, at the height of his career.Footnote 3 When he wrote the article, Professor Coats, who was born in 1924 and died on 8 April 2007, was head of the Department of Economic and Social History (a department that no longer exists) at the University of Nottingham.
The main purpose of this essay is to discuss the degree to which articles in HOPE have responded to Professor Coats's priorities. But first, please allow me to digress for a brief space and point out that Professor Coats's article was, to some degree, unusual. Although many inaugural issues of subdisciplinary journals contain brief statements announcing the founding of the journal and its purpose, not all open with a formal statement of the questions most in need of answers. Three that did were the
• Journal of Land & Public Utility Economics, whose first issue appeared in 1925; the
• Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, which began publication in 1978; and
• The European Journal of the History of Economic Thought, first published in 1993.
The first article in Land & Public Utility Economics was titled “Research in Land and Public Utility Economics” and was written by the Wisconsin institutionalist Richard T. Ely, who, given the address of the editor listed on the masthead, I imagine was the editor of the journal. Ely begins by emphasizing the important role of research: “Economic research today is a social necessity”; it is “one of the chief expressions of modern life”; it is “the chief tool of economic progress” (Ely Reference Ely1925, p. 1). He divides his discussion into land problems and public utility problems; he closes with a statement on the development of research from an individual endeavor to a cooperative undertaking. In six short pages, Ely poses an array of questions that borders on breathtaking. He seems to admit as much when he comments, “It is impossible even to enumerate all the problems revealed by a consideration of land from an economic and social point of view. They lead into every nook and cranny of our economic society” (ibid., p. 4).
Ely's message is that there is a lot of work to be done—and exciting work at that. The message of the corresponding item in the Journal of Post Keynesian Economics is that we are living in denial—denial that economics, as practiced by the majority of the discipline, may simply be an exercise that is true only to its own internal logic, an exercise that has lost significant touch with reality. Titled “A Statement of Purposes” and written by the editors, it charges researchers to put to the test the accepted truths and theories of economics.
The Journal of Post Keynesian Economics will be committed to the principle that the cumulative development of economic theory is possible only when the theory is continuously subject to challenge ….
In the JPKE perspective, dominant ideas must be freely open to sifting, sorting, extension, debate—and abandonment when logic and fact require it. Underlying assumptions must always be scrutinized for pertinence to real world phenomena
(JPKE 1978, p. 3).“Progress in our society depends on constructive criticism,” the editors conclude. “Advance in economics requires disciplined controversy to jar orthodoxy from its lethargy, and to persuade with alternative arguments those who specialize in the logic—or illogic—of dominant views” (ibid., p. 7). The article reads like—the article indeed is—a manifesto.
Also reading like a manifesto is the “editorial” that leads off the first issue of the European Journal of the History of Economic Thought. “Historians of economic thought need to go on the offensive,” it begins. “Their subject has been marginalized or totally removed in many cases from the curriculum of their academic institutions” (EJHET 1993, p. 1). As a result, many economics programs “are producing graduates who feel that economics was discovered by a Paul Samuelson or a Milton Friedman” (ibid., p. 1). The editorial singles out the transition from collectivist to capitalist economics as an area for needed attention.
In his own contribution to the genre, Professor Coats provides more than a list of research priorities. He begins by contrasting the teaching of the history of economics—on the decline in 1969—with the volume of scholarship on the subject, which, ironically, was on the rise. He reproves historians for writing too many accounts of doctrinal history, too many “histories of economics for economists,” too many articles “identifying the sources and tracing the changing interpretations of individual concepts or theories” (Coats Reference Coats1969, p. 12). He points out that historians have avoided the really hard work of historical investigation: placing their subjects in historical and intellectual context, demonstrating a sufficient “commitment to the past” (ibid., p. 13), developing “a sufficiently broad or explicit intellectual framework” (ibid., p. 12). Such work would, Professor Coats admits, require much difficult labor; but it must be done if we are to have first-rate scholarship in the history of economics.
Tellingly, Professor Coats uses a particular word no fewer than four times in outlining his research agenda: systematic. He even puts it in italics in one place: “In the past few historians have systematically investigated the ideas of even the greatest economists, let alone the supporting players and popularizers, partly because such studies are too time-consuming and too demanding intellectually” (ibid., p. 14). Research into the history of economics, he seems to suggest, has been conducted with little coordination among scholars, little disciplinary purpose, little overall structure.
It is worth pondering for a moment the exercise of constructing a list of research priorities. As Craufurd Goodwin pointed out to me, the priorities listed by Professor Coats in the 1969 article are the priorities that he himself had as a researcher. Do they happen to coincide with what the discipline really needed? Who can say? Is it possible for anyone active in the subfield to construct a list that would not reflect his or her own agenda? Perhaps it would be constructive to invite a distinguished economist who keeps an eye on the subfield but who does not conduct research in it—a Robert Solow or a Kenneth Arrow or a William Baumol. Perhaps someone who is outside the subdiscipline would be free of their own prejudices.
Now to Professor Coats's research priorities. As I see it, there are four that can be distinguished in the article; they may be listed as follows:
(1) the development of applied economics—the tools, data, and techniques of economists—with the goal of tracing the economist's knowledge (rather than his theory);
(2) the relationship between economic theory and policy, and in particular the role of economists in government;
(3) the propagation and dissemination of economic ideas to areas outside the discipline; and
(4) the “sociology” of economics, which covers a broad range of topics such as the emergence of economics as a discipline, and the social background and training of economists, and the qualifications for entrance into the profession.
My task here, as I have defined it, is to assess the extent to which the articles published in HOPE have responded to the priorities articulated by Professor Coats. My conclusion? If one looks at the numbers, then, to a reasonable degree, yes, especially when one considers not only the regular issues of HOPE but the supplemental issues as well. If one looks instead at the momentum of the body of research as a whole found in the pages of HOPE, then the answer is not very much.
Given the place it occupied—the first article in the first issue of the first journal devoted to the history of economic thought—I expected that Professor Coats's article had loomed large in the minds of the historians who first attempted to write for HOPE. Especially in the early years, even if I did not find articles that explicitly responded to the research priorities he had articulated, I expected at the very least to find abundant references to his article and convoluted apologies from authors who, while acknowledging the great importance of the research areas Professor Coats had so considerately and usefully identified, nevertheless with some embarrassment and reluctance had to go ahead with their description of the economic ideas of Henry Brook Parnell or Albert Frederick Mummery.
Instead, much to my surprise, far from looming large in the minds of historians, Professor Coats's article loomed hardly at all. As far as I have been able to tell, the first reference to Professor Coats's article appeared in the second issue of Volume 3, in a footnote to an article by Vincent Tarascio on recent developments in the history of economic thought in the United States. The footnote, which appeared near the end of the article, simply read: “For a further discussion of the state of research in the history of economics see A. W. Coats, ‘Research Priorities in the History of Economics’” (Tarascio Reference Tarascio1971, p. 429), etc. The next reference did not come until eight years later, in an article on disciplinary and subdisciplinary growth, by Joseph Remenyi (Reference Remenyi1979, p. 30), and there again the research priorities were not taken up substantially. Professor Coats's article, and especially his research agenda, were not materially addressed at all in a HOPE article until the Fall 1983 issue, in an article by Neil De Marchi and John Lodewijks, which will be discussed momentarily. Indeed, the De Marchi and Lodewijks article is the only HOPE article that comments in any appreciable way on the research priorities set forth by Professor Coats. The last time a reference to Professor Coats's article appeared in a regular issue of HOPE was in the Spring Reference Schabas1992 issue. There, in an article on the consumption function by J. J. Thomas, it at least figured in the first sentence. But the substance of the reference dealt not with the research priorities but with economists’ being “still guilty of that ‘provincialism in time’ of which Lord Robbins complained so eloquently years ago” (Thomas Reference Thomas1992, p. 153).
To pursue my task, I intended to browse every issue of HOPE published between 1969 and 2006, the last year for which there is a complete volume of issues. But I didn't do quite that. First, and fortunately for me, some of the work had already been done. In two articles in the Fall 1983 issue of the journal, Neil De Marchi and John Lodewijks, as well as Professor Coats himself, took stock of the first ten years of HOPE. (More will be said on both articles below.) I then intended to pick up where they left off and browse through all the volumes from 11 to 38. But pressured for time, I decided to limit my examination to the most recent fifteen volumes. It may be that an examination of the neglected volumes, numbers 11 through 23, would reveal quite different results; but given what was reported about the first ten volumes, and what I have seen in the last fifteen, I doubt it. The comments that follow, then, are based on a perusal of Volumes 24 through 38, covering the years 1992 to 2006.
II. HOPE, TEN YEARS OUT
As just mentioned, some of the work I had set out to do had already been done by none other than Professor Coats himself. In the Fall 1983 issue of HOPE, Professor Coats revisited the research priorities he had identified in the first issue of the journal. His conclusion was mixed. “There has been no marked shift toward studies of the development of ‘applied’ economics or the evolution of the economist's techniques, tools, and data. Nor has there been any clear relative expansion of contributions on the relationships between economic thought and policy or the sociology of economics” (Coats Reference Coats1983, p. 316). Even so, he acknowledged that scholars had conducted “much valuable research on some of [those] matters” and that the “potentialities for future work are now much clearer and more promising than in the late sixties” (ibid., p. 316). He particularly stressed again the need for research on thought and policy. Practicing what he preached, he had guided the production of an entire issue of HOPE devoted to that topic: the Fall 1981 issue, Economists in Government. But as he implied in his 1983 retrospective, historians should not now conclude that their work on the subject was done; the relationship between theory and policy has many components, and research is needed not just on the present-day position of economists in relation to policymakers, but on past positions as well.
In the 1983 article Professor Coats mentioned again the need for research on the application of economic ideas. “In an age such as ours, when the majority of professional economists are engaged in non-academic employment, it is appropriate to devote more attention to the uses to which economic ideas are put—to the propagation of economic ideas; the rise, dissemination, and influence of popular economic ideas (including fallacies), and their relationship to the prevailing ‘scientific’ conceptions at any time” (Coats Reference Coats1983, p. 317). And he urged scholars to concentrate less on the “great men” of economics—“who,” he said, “continue to feature so prominently in submissions to HOPE”—and more on the “supporting players and popularisers,” who may have had little to contribute to theory but who often had quite a “practical impact” (ibid., p. 317).
Also in the Fall 1983 issue was an article by Neil De Marchi and John Lodewijks that examined HOPE and the journal literature in the history of economic thought. Reading very much as a companion piece to Professor Coats's article, the article, among other things, took stock of the subdiscipline's response to the research priorities the man from Nottingham had laid out. The stock was small indeed. “Submissions reflect little attention to the development of data or the tools of the economist (methods, specific techniques); or to the interaction of economic theory and policy; or to the sociology of the discipline” (De Marchi and Lodewijks Reference De Marchi and Lodewijks1983, p. 325). Instead, the papers that had been submitted to HOPE were mainly of two kinds: those that told the history of the discipline through the ideas of Great Men; and those that sought to uncover the earliest articulations of currently accepted theory.
III. HOPE: THE LAST FIFTEEN YEARS
As mentioned earlier, HOPE articles over the most recent fifteen volumes have, if one looks at the numbers, taken up Professor Coats's research program to a reasonable degree. Between 1992 and 2006, it is safe to say that approximately 360 articles (probably a bit more) were published in the regular issues of HOPE (about 6 articles an issue, 4 issues a year, 15 volumes). Of those, I identified almost 50—or roughly 1 in 7—that responded to one of Professor Coats's priorities. I have listed them in an appendix to this essay. (That ratio, by the way, is roughly the same as that found by De Marchi and Lodewijks in their 1983 survey.) Some of the articles quite clearly addressed a priority: “Shaping Opinion on Development Policy: Economists at the Colonial Office during World War II,” by Barbara Ingham (Fall Reference Ingham1992), for example, or “Statistical Economics, 1900–1950,” by Jeff Biddle (Winter Reference Biddle1999), or “The Form and Function of Price Indexes: A Historical Accounting,” by H. Spencer Banzhaf (Winter Reference Banzhaf2004). Others, I had to think about. I found it particularly difficult to decide if an article was about applied economics—tools, data, techniques—and hence dealt with one of the research priorities; or if it was instead about theory and thus should not make the list. Is the IS-LM model—the subject of William Darity Jr. and Warren Young's Spring 1995 article and of the 2004 supplemental issue—a tool, or is it theory? Same for the U-shaped average cost curve, which is written about in Jan Horst Keppler and Jérôme Lallement's Winter 2006 article. When in doubt, I left them off the list.
It is in the annual HOPE supplements where Professor Coats's research program fares well. To date, seventeen supplemental issues have been published, and many are devoted to topics that can be counted among his priorities:
• The Post-1945 Internationalization of Economics (1996), edited by Professor Coats himself;
• New Economics and Its History (1997), edited by John B. Davis;
• From Interwar Pluralism to Postwar Neoclassicism (1998), edited by Mary S. Morgan and Malcolm Rutherford;
• Toward a History of Applied Economics (2000), edited by Roger E. Backhouse and Jeff Biddle;
• The Age of Economic Measurement (2001), edited by Judy L. Klein and Mary S. Morgan;
• The Future of the History of Economics (2002), edited by E. Roy Weintraub; and
• The Role of Government in the History of Economic Thought (2005), edited by Steven G. Medema and Peter Boettke.
The contrast between the articles in the regular issues and the supplemental issues is quite easy to explain. Whereas the editors of HOPE have taken an eclectic approach to the articles that appear in the former, they have used the supplemental issues, which arise out of annual conferences, to direct research toward the kinds of subjects Professor Coats identified as priorities. But doing so is not always easy. As Craufurd Goodwin explained to me, it is one thing to issue a call for a particular kind of paper on a particular subject; it is another to actually get what you ask for. Most scholars, it seems, are intent on doing precisely what they already want to do, regardless of any invitation to do otherwise. For a case in point, see the Winter 2004 issue of HOPE. The editors solicited articles on the history of economics for an audience not of other historians but of economists in the other subdisciplines. “The results, overall, were disappointing. We discovered that most historians of economics are not able or unwilling to address, or to envisage, this new and unfamiliar audience,” (HOPE 2004, p. 587) the editors wrote.
IV. SO WHAT HAVE HOPE ARTICLES ACCOMPLISHED?
If we examine the momentum of HOPE research as a whole, a different picture emerges. Professor Coats's assessment in his 1983 survey of the first ten years of HOPE is still accurate: In the last fifteen volumes of HOPE, there is no indication that historians have been increasingly turning their attention to the development of applied economics, the relationship of theory to policy, or the sociology of economics. There have been articles here and there that have taken up his research program; but there is no reason to believe that more and more articles will. Is that tolerable? How seriously should the journal take Professor Coats's priorities? Has the journal nevertheless produced a useful body of scholarship? Has it followed a de facto research program that is every bit as necessary as Professor Coats believed his to be?
Those questions are difficult to answer—if they are possible to answer at all. But at the very least, we can observe what actually has appeared in HOPE and draw some conclusions. Let me begin by offering the general impression I have of HOPE articles, an impression formed over eight years as the managing editor of the journal.
When I think of a HOPE article, I think first and foremost of an article that explains the ideas of a single economist—or sometimes of two economists (rarely of three or more); I think of an article that tells readers what Adam Smith had to say about value, or William Stanley Jevons had to say about the “pain” or “disutility” of labor, or John Maynard Keynes had to say about the role of central banks. A pure example of this kind of article is “The Monetary Thought of Allyn Abbott Young,” by Perry Mehrling (Winter 1996). The purpose may be to offer a different explanation (or interpretation) than that found in other papers; see, for instance, “Carl Menger's Theory of Price Formation Reconsidered,” by A. M. Endres (Summer 1995), or “Philosophical Psychology and Economic Psychology in David Hume and Adam Smith,” by Gordon F. Davis (Summer 2003). Or it may be to compare the ideas or theories of one economist with those of another, often to make some kind of connection between the two, sometimes to suggest that Economist A could have influenced Economist B or that the ideas of (famous) Economist C were first articulated by (lesser known) Economist D; see “Classical Political Economy between Two Fires: Jean-Baptiste Say and Frank H. Knight on the Enterprise Economy,” by Philippe Fontaine (Spring 1999), or “The Origins of the Theory of Optimum Currency Areas,” by Filippo Cesarano (Winter 2006). Or it may be to remind or reintroduce readers (or to inform them for the very first time) about the ideas of Economist E—as in “The ‘Secret Concatenation’ in the Mid-nineteenth Century: The Case of George Poulett Scrope, a Still Neglected Political Economist,” by David Stack (Fall 2000), or “Isaac de Pinto (1717–1878): An Enlightened Economist and Financier,” by José Luís Cardoso and António de Vasconcelos Nogueira (Summer 2005). As someone who often finds economic treatises difficult to understand, I regard readable accounts of the ideas of economists as most welcome indeed.
The vast majority of those articles deal with a single figure—and that figure seems to often be Adam Smith or Keynes. Since 1992, there have been no fewer than 69 articles about, or in substantial part about, Adam Smith or John Maynard Keynes, a number representing almost 20 percent of all HOPE articles published over that period. Indeed, it seems that every HOPE article deals with Smith or Keynes—or Ricardo or Malthus or Hayek. That's an exaggeration of course, but only to a degree. The Great Man approach to history is still alive and well. When I add Ricardo, Malthus, and Hayek to Smith and Keynes, the number increases to almost 100, or well more than a quarter of all articles. Instead of Ricardo, Malthus, Hayek, one could have added Marshall, Mill, and—Jevons? Pareto? Hume? Sraffa? The result would have been the same. The point is that more than a quarter of HOPE articles have been about one of five economists.
Next in frequency are articles that trace the evolution of a theory or idea. These articles usually begin with some early statement of a theory—or at least something that resembles or approximates the theory as it exists today—and demonstrate how the theory was modified in its treatment by successive economists. Recent examples are “Frequentist Probability and Choice under Uncertainty,” by Alberto Baccini (Winter 2001); “Informative Prices, Rational Investors: The Emergence of the Random Walk Hypothesis and the Nineteenth-Century ‘Science of Financial Investments’,” by Alex Preda (Summer 2004); and “Monetary Equilibrium,” by Claes-Henric Siven (Winter 2006).
My impression is that those two kinds of articles—articles that explain the ideas of a particular economist or that outline the origins and modifications of a theory—represent the largest class of HOPE articles. Taking a tally would be tedious work; but I would estimate that as much as 40 percent of HOPE articles are one of those two kinds. Among the less common subjects one finds in HOPE articles, let me list a few of my favorites. I like articles that explore a school or group of figures. I enjoyed Erik Buyst and colleagues’ article on the development of economics in the Low Countries (Spring 2005), Hansjörg Klausinger's on emigration and the decline of the Austrian school (Winter 2006), and Greg Moore's on the Cambridge Millites and Leslie Stephen (Winter 2006), as well as Malcolm Rutherford's on institutional economics at Columbia University (Spring 2004) and Loïc Charles and Christine Théré’s articles on the Physiocrats. I would like to see more articles on recent developments in economics; excellent models are Esther-Mirjam Sent's articles on John Muth (Summer 2002) and behavioral economics (Winter 2004) and Philippe Fontaine's exploration of philanthropy and altruism in economics (Spring 2007). A very few articles have dealt with events: Mauro Boianovsky and Hans-Michael Trautwein's article on Haberler and business cycle theory (Spring 2006), for instance, which documents the origins and composition of Prosperity and Depression.
One final note. Given the preponderance of articles on Smith and Keynes, I expected to find an Anglo-American bias in HOPE. Perhaps one could argue that there is. But nearly ninety articles, or around a quarter, have been on Continental figures, and over a third have been by historians from other than the United States or Britain.
V. YES—BUT IS IT HISTORY?
One can state and explain the ideas of Adam Smith on the division of labor or of Alfred Marshall on demand; likewise, one can take readers through the successive iterations of business-cycle theory or of the concept of involuntary employment. Doing so may—or may not—count as economics. But does it count as history? I don't think this is an irrelevant or tiresome question. Our subdiscipline is the history of economic thought; our journals all have the word history in their titles; they are not called, say, the Review of Economic Ideas or the Journal of Economic Theory. What constitutes history? In his 1969 article, Professor Coats suggests that history means placing their subjects in historical and intellectual context, demonstrating a sufficient “commitment to the past,” (Coats Reference Coats1969, p. 13) developing “a sufficiently broad or explicit intellectual framework” (ibid., p. 12). Furthermore, at the close of his article he hints that history involves archival work.
In that spirit, I would like to see our historians use a much wider array of primary sources, especially contemporary documents. Where are journals, letters, and diaries? Minutes of meetings? Autobiography? Newspapers, pamphlets, and magazines? Photographs, illustrations, and paintings? Speeches and interviews? Oral histories and personal correspondence with authors? Some scholars come immediately to mind who have set examples here: Mauro Boianovsky, Loïc Charles, Ross Emmett, Malcolm Rutherford, Esther-Mirjam Sent, and Christine Théré. I hope many more follow their lead.
But maybe Professor Coats is being unfair. In something as brief and focused as a journal article, it may be unreasonable to do what he charges. In twenty-five pages, can one successfully pay sufficient attention to the historical context? In addition, practically all contributors to HOPE were trained as economists; they are economists, on economics faculties. When one really thinks about it, there is something bothersome about the idea that an economist could be expected to simply sit down and write an historical analysis. Certainly, historical inquiry involves methods and techniques and a habit of mind that require years of training to develop, to say nothing of mastering. It certainly doesn't work the other way around: no one would expect an historian to produce, with no training or instruction, an acceptable economic analysis.
VI. RESEARCH PRIORITIES FOR THE EARLY TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY
I was recently in a room with five historians of economic thought. I asked them the following question: What are the research priorities for the field in the coming decade? I asked five historians, and I got—five different answers? Well, no. In fact, I got no answer! It was significant to me that when confronted with the question, not a single historian had an immediate answer to give. Instead, I got questions in return. Who can decide what the priorities are? How valid is the process of establishing priorities? To what degree did Professor Coats's article reflect the beliefs of the editors of HOPE?
I may not have gotten answers from the historians, and I, a managing editor and hardly a trained or practicing historian, am in no position to determine priorities. But I can offer a few reflections about what areas seem to be neglected for the moment. In contrast to the situation a generation or so ago, we receive very few papers on preclassical economics, and practically none at all on economic thought in the ancient and medieval periods; and Karl Marx has, from all indications, fallen off the face of the earth. With the publication in 2000 of the Biographical Dictionary of Women Economists, as well as Kirsten Madden's fine 2002 essay on female contributions to economic thought, I have expected to see papers on women economists; but virtually none have arrived at my office.
VII. CLOSING REMARKS
Constructing the history of an idea is an elusive process. The origins of an idea can never be conclusively dated or located. An idea does not keep records or leave a paper trail; it has never written a single word or signed a single document or attended a single meeting; it cannot talk back to its interpreters, propagators, and disseminators; it cannot sit for an interview; it cannot be felt or smelled or tasted or heard. Whatever histories we manage to construct about it, they must remain approximate at best.
