Populism is a form of mass politics that claims to represent the common people. Due to its widespread and recurrent presence, it has increasingly been analysed by sociologists, political scientists, historians and economists as one of the most remarkable political phenomena of the region in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, in Latin America and elsewhere. Currently, populist movements and parties are in power in Bolivia, Ecuador, Nicaragua and Venezuela, as well as in Greece, Senegal and Zambia. Populist leaders are also challenging the rule of traditional party systems in other societies such as France, Spain and Australia. Likewise, different ‘Occupy’ movements in Western countries have carried out rebellions and insurrections in the name of the people, and similar movements have disarticulated established polities throughout the Middle East and North Africa.
This global revival of populism underpins this book, which, unlike earlier regional treatments, brings together 14 social scientists approaching populism in theoretical terms and analysing settings as varied as those of Latin American countries (primarily Bolivia, Ecuador and Venezuela); Thailand; Western Europe, the United States and Australia; and Senegal, Zambia and South Africa. The book attempts to maintain a cross-regional and global conversation between theoretical analysis and specific contemporary case studies of populism around the globe.
For decades, populism has exerted great analytical attraction among those following Latin America. Researchers elaborated analytical perspectives time and again in an attempt to account for both the pervasive appeal of populist leaders in the region and the radically varied physiognomy of successive waves of populism. These ranged from the early populist wave, represented by Hipólito Yrigoyen or Arturo Alessandri; to the so-called classic populist wave exemplified by Getúlio Vargas, Juan Domingo Perón or Lázaro Cárdenas; ‘neo-populism’ under leaders such as Carlos Menem or Abdalá Bucaram; and the ‘radical populism’ of Hugo Chávez. This volume builds on that previous scholarship on Latin America as a key site of emergence of populism, while approaching it as a global phenomenon challenging Liberal democracy.
A major reason for the strong appeal of populism as a research focus stems from its lack of fit within the analytical perspectives that have significant explanatory power in other domains of social science research: namely, institutional analysis, class analysis and the study of ideologies and doctrines. After five decades of research since the early studies of Gino Germani on Peronism, there is still no unifying theory. Instead, most researchers suggest an aggregate number of traits to identify populist movements, including (1) the bond between the leader and the masses, rooted not only in cognitive-rational elements but in emotions, buttressed by a certain style of addressing the masses, directed at the most popular sectors of the population; (2) a persisting call to plebiscitary-like decisions, which grants symbolic empowerment to popular sectors while retaining a powerful appropriation of voice by the leader; and (3) an emphasis on executive power overriding the division of powers, which often leads to ‘legislation by decree’. Consequently, a ‘politics of anti-politics’ has been identified. As emphasised in the OBO essay on modern populism (http://www.oxfordbibliographies.com), this tilts to the weakening or manipulation of some of the basic institutions of representative liberal democracy. It reflects and buttresses a general trend in which political parties remain secondary to mass movements; there is reliance on multi-class support and concomitantly the tendency to detachment from coherent, clear-cut ideologies (this does not mean lack of ideological rhetoric, as recent cases clearly indicate). Last but not least, populism often addresses the expectations of social forces marginalised or hit hard by the economic policies and downturns, and projects mythical promises of existential solutions even when, in practice, most of these movements do not carry out a revolutionary transformation of social structures.
As Carlos de la Torre indicates in his comprehensive introduction, this volume was designed to systematically analyse the challenges that populism poses to the mainstream premises of liberal democracy. These challenges vary from setting to setting, due to the variable elements of the concept of ‘the people’ as a discursive construct. In Latin America, Africa and Thailand, populists have sought to empower excluded segments of the population. Even if all these movements entailed an authoritarian peril due to the claim of such leaders that they express the ‘true will of the people’, Australian, European and North American populism's call to give power to the people has often entailed the exclusion of sectors of the population considered to have alien cultural values. In such cases, exclusion has converged within clearly demarcated boundaries of ethnicity, race or religion.
Moreover, the book identifies that whereas the fragility or breakdown of party systems has allowed populists to reach power in Latin America or Africa (as summed up by Kenneth Roberts's chapter), consolidated and strong institutions in Australia or the United States have relegated populist movements to the margins of their political systems (as analysed by Benjamin Moffit for Australia and by George Michael in the case of the Tea Party movement in the United States). Still, exclusion has not been absent from the more inclusive cases. For instance, Nancy Postero's chapter shows that even in Bolivia, Evo Morales’ pluri-national and multicultural restructuring of the state has excluded indigenous groups that opposed government policies.
The contributions also trace another source of ambiguity involved in the project of restoring or giving power to the people. Populists claim legitimacy by retaining and even deepening election and recall systems. Accordingly, populist leaders cannot cancel these mechanisms, but they might find it hard to accept an electoral defeat. Once in power, they tend to ‘skew’ the electoral game to their advantage and show a tendency to reject defeat, as clearly shown in Paulina Ochoa Espejo's analysis of the case of Andrés Manuel López Obrador in 2006 and 2012 in Mexico. Alluding to the late Hugo Chávez and Rafael Correa, De la Torre writes: ‘As incumbents, they had extraordinary advantages such as using the media, selectively silencing the privately owned media, selectively harassing the opposition, controlling electoral tribunal boards and all instances of appeal, and using public funds to influence the election’ (p. 13). This had led scholars such as Steven Levitzky and James Loxton to characterise populism as ‘competitive authoritarianism’. This ambiguity is clearly shown in the chapters by Margaret López Maya on Venezuela and Danielle Resnick on African populist leaders. Likewise, José Pedro Zúquete suggests that populisms have forwarded open-ended strategies vis-à-vis democracies, that is they may either regenerate democracy or undermine it.
Various chapters add analytical hindsight on these dynamics. Andrew Arato stresses the ideational basis of the authoritarian tendencies of populism rooted in the ‘mythical’ construction of ‘the people’. Paulina Ochoa Espejo reinforces the perils implied in radical attacks on institutions in the name of the people. Benjamin Arditti points out that popular insurgencies are ‘constituent moments’ during which issues that were seen as non-political become politicised. Robert Jansen's contribution presents the related idea of the Manichean discourse of the people against internal and external enemies, which serves as a form of political mobilisation. The book closes with a very rich conclusion by Cas Mudde that brings together all the analyses while singling out new lines of research to assess the conditions under which populisms may tilt their internal balance towards either a democratising or an authoritarian outcome. As he points out, populism has become a truly global phenomenon, of great importance ‘predominantly in democratic societies, but also increasingly in competitive authoritarian states’, while at the same time ‘few cross-regional studies of populism exist’ (p. 432). Defining it as a form of ‘moral politics’, Mudde describes populism as ‘fundamentally antipluralist, and therefore anti-liberal-democratic’, while also recognising it as a part of civil society. Among the avenues still to be explored in future studies, he identifies the connection between populism and gender, the relationship between populism and religion, the lack of strong international networks among populists, and finally, the relationships between populism in politics and outside of politics. Let me conclude by joining his remark that ‘the study of populism is more exciting and vibrant than ever’. The current book is a major contribution to such excitement and vibrancy.
