John T. Matthews's William Faulkner: Seeing through the South is the rare book that will prove vital and engaging both for readers new to Faulkner's writing and for scholars long devoted to it. To strike such a balance is no small task, for the fiction is difficult and the exegeses plentiful. Nonetheless, Matthews manages to guide readers through Absalom, Absalom! (1936), for example, with clarity and conciseness yet without sacrificing the nuances that researchers value in this most complicated novel. Throughout, his discussion incorporates insights from the full history of Faulkner criticism: supporters of feminism, psychoanalysis, deconstruction, new historicism, and Marxism will not be disappointed; nor will those of the new modernist studies, the new southern studies, the new hemispheric American studies, or, for that matter, the old and new formalisms. (Though never constrained by new-critical dictates, Matthews has long been recognized for the sophistication of his aesthetic analyses; here, in keeping with this volume's appearance in Blackwell's Introductions to Literature series, he also consistently and even gleefully foregrounds the pleasures offered by Faulkner's prose.) But while the breadth and flexibility of Matthews's interpretive methods are impressive, the most invigorating aspect of this study is its singular argument, which persuasively posits “a Faulkner for our times” (viii).
To be clear, Matthews deftly situates Faulkner's prose in its historical context, but he strenuously resists the familiar idea that the Mississippi of the early twentieth century was effectively isolated from the larger world and bears no continuity with that of today. Noting that even recent critics have accused Faulkner of being “obsessed by the past,” Matthews argues the greater importance of the author's fascination with – and admitted ambivalence toward – ongoing “sexual, racial, and economic revolutions.” In this study, Faulkner's often tortuous representation of time itself is neither parochial nor backward-looking; instead, it reflects a local confrontation with the upheavals of global modernity.
Matthews's title condenses (at least) two meanings. On the one hand, as Faulkner devotes himself to the modernist project of challenging “old-fashioned mores,” he ultimately “sees through” the ideological fiction that the traditional South was innocent of capitalist exploitation (25). Thus, drawing on the psychoanalytic theorist Slavoj Žižek, Matthews elucidates how Faulkner stages the confrontation between would-be white elites and the social structure that they have perceived but disavowed; that is, the fact that their economic privilege derives from colonial and continuing racial oppression. Further, Faulkner situates this abuse within the South's encompassing embrace of dehumanizing mercantile values. Along these lines, in Matthews's reading of The Sound and the Fury (1929), he describes the once-aristocratic Compsons' decline, so often interpreted as a specifically local phenomenon, through the framework of (increasingly global) commodity fetishism. More strikingly, observing what would seem to be the quintessential stereotype of bucolic backwardness – Ike Snopes's erotic adventures with a cow in The Hamlet (1940) – Matthews finds a doomed “dream of exemption from a monetary economy” (137).
On the other hand, Faulkner “sees” the spread of global capitalism “through” its depredations in his own locale, from the expropriation of Native American land through the abuses of slavery and Jim Crow, including also the domination of women under patriarchy and the desperation of the laboring class. Matthews's depiction of a writer centrally concerned with economic justice may surprise readers who associate Faulkner with his notoriously gradualist response to black southerners' demands for civil rights, nor does it mesh readily with the caricatured figure of a dandified southerner, with a well-documented fondness for Greek revival architecture (however quirkily modified in his own Rowan Oak), horse-riding, and bourbon. But Matthews, who insists that “the books themselves actually were the essence of Faulkner's life,” supports this aspect of his argument, in particular through vigorous readings of the often neglected late fiction (viii). Accordingly, he explains how The Town (1957) encapsulates “the formula for the eventual US global empire in information and entertainment industries,” The Mansion (1959) depicts Mink Snopes as a member of the “global South's agricultural proletariat … await[ing] recognition and recompense,” and A Fable (1954) observes the consolidation of a global ruling class (252, 259).
Throughout this volume, Matthews depicts a writer who devoted his authorial efforts to unveiling and disrupting hegemonic narratives – stumbling occasionally, of course, but also yielding “magnificent insight” (271). Accordingly, one cannot help but suspect that the impressive energy and clarity of Matthews's prose are fueled by determination that Faulkner's demystifications not be subsumed into yet another enabling fiction – this time of the quirky regional writer, capturing an anomalous culture at the moment of its decline. Combating such possibilities through a vivid and theoretically sophisticated illumination of Faulkner's vision, Matthews has produced both a stirring work of criticism and a bracing model of critical vocation.
