Until relatively recently, William Petty (1623–1687) was perhaps best known to scholars of the history of political economy and demography, and to historians of Ireland. As a result, his status as the originator of ‘political arithmetic’ has tended to occlude many of his other interests in the eyes of intellectual historians and historians of science. In fact, Petty was a man of seemingly endless eclectic parts, as interested in shipbuilding and Irish land tenure as in natural philosophy or medicine. Rhodri Lewis aptly describes him in the Preface to this volume as ‘the most gifted of a generation of intellectual entrepreneurs’ (p. vii). Over the past two decades, stimulated largely by the British Library's purchase in 1993 of Petty's unpublished manuscripts and correspondence, there has been a growth of interest in the full range of Petty's diverse and full intellectual life. Ted McCormick's William Petty and the Ambitions of Political Arithmetic (2009) is representative of this wider, more complete perspective, although it remains the case that significant areas of Petty's career have attracted comparatively little attention. One of the areas on which Rhodri Lewis's valuable edition sheds light is Petty's religious beliefs and theological interests.
Petty's incomplete treatise Of the Scale of Creatures, which he composed in the 1670s, is a complex, difficult work. Cast in a familiar form, it attempts to perform multiple, perhaps contradictory, functions. The notion of a ‘scale of creatures’, scala naturae or ‘chain of being’, as Lewis emphasizes in his introduction, was a familiar device to early modern theologians and philosophers, and could be deployed in a variety of contexts. Petty used it as a way to develop an apologetic for his religious beliefs after challenges of heterodoxy levelled at him in the mid-1670s by Thomas Barlow, but also as a way of exploring questions that involved theology, anthropology and the relationship between humans and animals. In Petty's lifetime, Of the Scale of Creatures remained in manuscript and had only a small audience amongst his closest friends and collaborators. For intellectual and perhaps pragmatic reasons, this was never a public document. Indeed, as Lewis puts it, there is some evidence that Petty himself considered the Scale ‘an inauspicious failure’ (p. 82), hence its limited circulation. The fact that none of the extant manuscript versions of the Scale text presents a complete work adds to the interpretative challenges it poses.
Lewis's impeccable edition presents Petty's text with a thorough critical apparatus and textual notes. The shorter ‘Textual introduction’ is notable also for its excursus on editorial practice, which gives some firmly held and very helpful thoughts about the complexities of editing early modern texts. The edition is preceded by a long general introduction that sets Petty's project in its intellectual context, and dissects some of the apparent contradictions within it. Here Lewis highlights the voluntaristic nature of Petty's theological views as expressed in the Scale, which emphasizes the incomprehensibility of God to humans. As he puts it, Petty ‘did away with natural theology, preferring a pared-down and hard-headed fideism as the basis for religious belief’ (p. 38). This gives Petty's text a distinctively, and highly controversial, Hobbesian flavour, but also seems to pull in a very different direction from the emphasis implicit in the conception of a ‘scale of creatures' on the chain connecting God and the created world. On one reading, then, Petty's project contained contradictions and problems that he was unable or unwilling to resolve. Lewis's introduction handles this possibility sensitively, and with scrupulous attention to the textual and biographical evidence.
Overall this is a hugely valuable edition that brings a largely overlooked Petty text to a wider audience; it will also be of great interest to historians concerned with topics in late seventeenth-century theology and philosophy that extend beyond Petty himself.
