Faith in Faithlessness: An Anthology of Atheism, edited and introduced by Dimitrios Rousopoulos, gathers together some thirty-nine essays and excerpts on the general theme of atheism. While most essays were published in the Twentieth Century, the anthology ranges historically back to Spinoza. The book is divided into three sections, corresponding to time periods: the Early Classics (everything prior to the Twentieth Century); Early Twentieth Century Classics; and Later Twentieth and Twenty-First Century writings. The first and last sections comprise the bulk of the book with the early Twentieth Century Classics making up a comparatively thin slice in the middle.
The writings presented here are not exclusively philosophical, coming from scientists (Darwin, Dawkins, Einstein), literary figures (George Eliot, Gore Vidal, Salman Rushdie), journalists (H. L. Mencken, Hitchens), historians (W. E. H. Lecky, Carl Van Doren), poets (Shelley, Greydon Square), political activists (Charles Bradlaugh, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Bakunin, Emma Goldman) and even a lawyer (Clarence Darrow). The Four Horsemen of the Atheipocalypse are represented, though the selections from Hitchens and Dawkins come straight out of their famous New Atheist works. There is a wide variety of essays, and even some unusual choices, but all of the material has been published previously.
What seems lacking is any clear mandate in the selection of the essays. Not every piece clearly makes a significant point or contribution to atheism, and the inclusion of Spinoza seems questionable, since there is considerable disagreement as to what he might have believed. Some figures, like Thomas Paine, may well have been deists, which is technically “atheist” at least, in not being “theist.” Although there are some fine essays in this volume, there is little to distinguish it from the other anthologies now on the market. The organization by temporal period, rather than by theme, makes it more difficult for the reader to judge the contents, but this aspect is shared by many other anthologies as well. If the book is to be effective in accomplishing its stated aim – “to give rational tools to those who seek to counter the overwhelming influence and power [of religion]” (p. xi) – a more systematic presentation will surely be necessary.
According to the preface, the idea for the book was hatched at roughly the same time as the famous “New Atheist” books were published, and from more or less the same motives, that being concern over the apparent rise of religious fundamentalism. Unfortunately, it was published between two and three years following the four New Atheist texts and seems to be rather behind the curve. The Introduction and Epilogue by Rousopoulos are pretty bland fare. The Introduction begins on a note of shocked dismay that in the 21st Century monotheistic religion still must be discussed, though it is not made clear for what reason one might have expected it to go away. What follows is a now-familiar run-through of the horror and stupidity of fundamentalism and its current political significance. Readers of Sam Harris and Christopher Hitchens will not find much of surprise here. The Epilogue runs through a potted recital of the intellectual history of the Enlightenment period and the critical responses to it, such as Critical Theorists Adorno and Horkheimer. It closes with an “Open Letter to the Left” (appealing to them to “come out of the closet”) and a call for a Second Wave Enlightenment. Rousopoulos repeats the call for atheists to be frank and open about their beliefs, to generate or enter public political discussion with their perspective fully explicit. In other words, he repeats the essential point of Dawkins’s “Out Campaign,” without much novelty and without Dawkins’s eloquence. The New Enlightenment proposed would be based on the world view of humanism, for which Rousopoulos outlines a few basic points: ethics, building a better society with reason, concern for life and critical thinking. Consistent with the political activist message, the book includes a resource section, listing a number of atheist, secularist, humanist and skeptic organizations worldwide, including addresses, emails and websites. Unfortunately, the listing is simply recopied from the Richard Dawkins Foundation website, where the links are active and ready for use. On the whole, it is difficult to see what this book adds to the discussion of atheism, after the buzz of interest of the last several years, when much of this was hashed out repeatedly. On the other hand, a complete novice to non-belief wouldn’t find this to be a problem and would certainly benefit considerably from this introduction to the topic.
Finally, while I appreciate the noble origins of the title in a Pete Seeger song, it nevertheless is an unfortunate formulation. It seems to be admitting the old charge, recently reinvigorated, that non-belief itself is really a kind of faith. This will not confuse many atheist readers, but it may lend ammunition to the professional handlers of the faith community, the apologists and evangelists who crow with delight over the least indiscretion they can point out to their flock as proof of the illegitimacy of atheism.
