In Exporting Jim Crow (a finalist for the Association for the Study of the Worldwide African Diaspora's 2021 Outstanding First Book Prize), Chinua Thelwell narrates an expansive, global history of blackface minstrelsy, ‘the first homegrown popular culture export of the United States’ (p. 2), by tracing the traffics of ‘blackface minstrelsy in South Africa and the global arena’ (p. 3). In this book, Thelwell makes a significant, original contribution to the study of blackface minstrelsy, assembling a voluminous archive of primary documentation both of the nineteenth-century traffic of the minstrel show through colonial South Africa and of its enduring legacies in apartheid-era and post-apartheid South Africa. Perhaps the most significant contribution of the book is Thelwell's schema outlining the ‘five waves of blackface minstrel globalization’ through which he traces material changes in the dissemination of blackface, from early solo performance through the minstrel show and onto its mediatization in film and television (p. 7). Also noteworthy is Thelwell's refutation of the scholarly ‘argument that early blackface minstrelsy carried a large amount of “progressive” potential’ through his demonstration of the ways in which blackface minstrelsy functioned as an efficacious performance of race-making throughout its global itineraries (p. 56). Thelwell maps how blackface minstrelsy promulgated ‘colonizing logics’ of racial discourses and served as ‘the visual bedrock of a transcultural imaginary in which notions of citizenship, race, gender, and social status were thoroughly entwined’ (p. 5).
As indicated in its title, the book combines two projects: a history of blackface minstrelsy (1) in South Africa and (2) beyond. The ‘beyond’ takes the shape of a global history of minstrelsy that draws together numerous secondary sources, which Thelwell synthesizes into a coherent overview and a well-curated bibliography that will be useful to anyone interested in the subject. Yet the heart of Thelwell's study lies in South Africa and in the primary-source material he assembles on the histories of touring white performers of blackface minstrelsy, the singular case of black impresario Orpheus McAdoo and his troupe of black spiritual singers and minstrel performers, and the influence of minstrelsy on the annual Cape Town Kaapse Klopse Carnival. The latter two chapters are particularly insightful, as they offer both abundant primary evidence on these overlooked performance histories and nuanced analyses of their racial politics. Thelwell carefully situates both McAdoo and the Kaapse Klopse within South Africa's distinctive tripartite racial classification system, tracing how the racial categories of white, black and coloured complicate blackface minstrelsy's presumptive racial binary of black and white. Thelwell thus models a methodological approach to grappling with the complex legacies of blackface minstrelsy globally – by giving equal weight to its expansive promulgation of racial discourses as well as to local engagements with minstrelsy and its performance repertoires.
Despite the book's merits, this reader wonders how an understanding of performance cultures as multidirectional and interanimating might have complicated Thelwell's central metaphor of blackface minstrel performance as a ‘popular culture export of the United States’ (p. 2). For instance, Thelwell's foundational assertion that ‘cultural influence between the Old and New Worlds was unidirectional’ prior to the ‘export’ of blackface minstrelsy strains credulity (p. 2), particularly in the wake of Joseph Roach's theorization of the ‘circum-Atlantic’ in Cities of the Dead (1996) and Elizabeth Maddock Dillon's elaboration of the concept in New World Drama (2014). Indeed, Thelwell's theoretical and historiographical contributions would have been enriched by a more thorough engagement with theatre and performance studies and by more robust descriptions and elaborate theorizations of historical performances to supplement the book's positivist accounts of archival documentation. Nevertheless, Thelwell's study stages a critical intervention in blackface minstrel scholarship, demonstrating the inherent globality of the form and its history. Moreover, Thelwell's extensive documentation of nineteenth- and twentieth-century histories of minstrelsy in South Africa makes his monograph indispensable to scholars interested in blackface minstrelsy and those interested in South African performance. It also has much to offer to those interested in global approaches to cultural studies and in race and performance generally. Most importantly, Thelwell models an ethical mode of antiracist scholarship, which is best summarized in his statement: ‘Because antiblack racism is a global phenomenon, antiracist thinking must also be global’ (p. 212). Exporting Jim Crow provides a compelling contribution to this urgent intellectual project.
