Nearly two decades have passed since the fall of the Berlin Wall, and over that period questions about political liberalization, societal transformation, and transitional justice have captured the attention and imagination of scholars and regional experts worldwide. As part of the trend, there is now a vast body of scholarship and journalism about prospects for political liberalization in the Middle East.
For obvious reasons, far less has been written about transitional justice in the region. In fact, although most Middle Eastern countries have a history of serious human rights problems and several societies have experienced some form of political opening, only three countries can be considered to have had any experience that might qualify them for case study of transitional justice. The Iraq experience has not been a fully indigenous process, and in Algeria the 2006 Charter for Peace and Reconciliation has stymied efforts to account for the state's role in perpetrating abuses during a decade of civil war. Morocco's experience with transitional justice, by comparison, has been relatively robust. Questions about how to confront the past have dominated Moroccan politics for more than a decade, and (so far) the process for reviewing and redressing complaints has been expanded three times. According to the 2005 report of the Equity and Reconciliation Commission, more than 10,000 victims or their heirs have received compensation for wrongful treatment by the state.
Because the possibility of naming and prosecuting perpetrators has thus far been excluded, the Moroccan experience is not comparable in scope to processes undertaken in other regions. Nevertheless, it offers today's best vantage from which to consider the ways in which transitional justice might be pursued in the Middle East. Other works have examined and analyzed Morocco's decades of political repression, al-sanawāt al-sawdaء, but Performance of Human Rights is unique as a study of the representation of repression in Morocco. It is also the first book-length volume to treat the social dynamics that have given rise to Morocco's transitional justice process.
Slyomovics sets the stage by reviewing several decades of repressive politics as well as the institutions that provided legal and physical context for them. Drawing on prison writings, sketches and cartoons, interviews, and testimonials to supplement extensive reporting by international and domestic human rights groups, she considers the unique forms of torture, privation, and other abuse suffered by various groups of prisoners—leftists, trade unionists, students, Saharans, women, Islamists, and those associated with failed attempts at a military coup. This volume, however, is not simply a compendium of wrongs partially righted. It is an effort to document the process of recovery and the determined efforts of Morocco's emergent civil society to redress specific wrongs through publicity, protest, and performance. It is effectively an ethnographic study of the opening of public space in Morocco, examined from the vantage of those who have worked diligently to pry apart the heavy doors.
Slyomovics' analysis is very rich in detail and heavily contextualized, but it does not reach beyond the immediate Moroccan experience to connect with enduring themes of pageantry and performance in the history and anthropology of Moroccan politics or the development of transitional justice in other world regions. However, the author does paint a sensitive and sympathetic portrait of those who have suffered, and are recovering, and she provides a systematic and nuanced review of the Moroccan experience of political repression. An important next step will be to analyze the politics of justice, including resistance to change and the delicate maneuvers by those vested in power to address wrongs by the state without denouncing the royal regime, or implicating the late monarch. Ultimately, the durability of Morocco's political opening depends not only on those who augur for reform but also on the readiness of the monarchy to tolerate dissent and transform relations of power.
Political repression is a hidden phenomenon, difficult and often dangerous to study in any systematic way. Those targeted for repression are not simply punished, but silenced, and removed from society by exile, imprisonment, assassination, or “disappearance.” Repression engenders silence and instills fear. There is no doubt a cathartic aspect to the delivery of public testimonials, but there is also social significance. In reclaiming their voices, those who were deliberately removed from society seize opportunity to reinsert themselves and their experience into the collective memory. In similar fashion, scholarship that documents and analyzes the experience of repression establishes the possibility of its examination and incorporation into analyses of political practice. That is the work Slyomovics has undertaken in this important volume. It will be of great value to scholars attempting to locate the experience of repressive practice in the broader context of Moroccan politics as it will to those seeking a more general understanding of the experience of transitional justice across national and cultural boundaries.
