Michael C. Alexander's Roman Amoralism Reconsidered, which is available to download for free online, is a masterpiece of historical argumentation carefully elaborated around a single point. This study emerges from the author's previous contribution to scholarly debate (Athenaeum 97 (2009), 31–57) about the intriguing ancient pamphlet often known as ‘A Short Guide to Electioneering’, the Commentariolum Petitionis, which purports to be written by Quintus Cicero in c. 64 b.c.e. as advice for his more famous brother Marcus, on running for consul. The treatise is notable for its apparently cynical attitude towards politics, which it portrays as a distinct arena where the normal rules of moral behaviour are suspended and ‘anything goes’. While some scholars treat it as authentic, and as providing evidence of late republican attitudes to electioneering, others, including A., contend that it was most likely written towards the end of the first century c.e.; A. reads it as satirical.
In this book, A. provides further context for his ‘ironic’ reading of the Comm. Pet. by building a case that the Romans were not usually ‘amoralist’ in their approach to politics (ch. 2). He demonstrates, further, why an influential strand of Roman historiography written during the twentieth century — the ‘era of disillusionment’ mentioned in the book's title — misread the Comm. Pet. due to a variety of factors (including prosopography, debunking and Cold War paranoia) which are valuably explicated in chs 3 and 4. As a preliminary illustration of what amoralism might look like within a democratic system, we are offered eye-watering instances from modern Louisiana and Illinois, where people take a perverse pride in local traditions of dirty tricks, including candidates openly changing their names to mislead voters about their ethnicity (9). There is no evidence, A. argues in ch. 2, of such attitudes in ancient Rome, so a straight reading of the Comm. Pet. would place it at odds with all our other evidence from the period.
Debates over the date, author and purpose of the Comm. Pet. will not be resolved, and indeed readers may not agree with A.’s more general arguments. But this is a superb outline of evidence, interpretative context and above all the implications of different readings, whose value reaches far beyond its subject. A.’s exploration of historiographical trends draws attention to the underlying assumptions and frameworks that govern historical interpretation, and to the ways that different approaches and questions lead to different research outcomes. Arguments are often laid out in more detail than usually encountered in academic prose, and there is a forensic feel to the writing, where the author pre-empts the possible objections of his readers and attempts to forestall misunderstandings. In essence the book makes a simple point, but it is made most thoroughly, with all ramifications of the argument explored; over the course of the book it becomes the basis for a meticulous unravelling of a historian's practice. The argument is thoughtfully constructed; only at the end does the author reveal his own stake in the question of Roman amoralism, and ultimately its urgent relevance for us all. This is a short work which is concise, entertaining, accessible, honest and thorough, and all these qualities would make it an excellent resource for training graduate students in the techniques of ancient history and awareness of their limitations.
Catalina Balmaceda's survey of virtus Romana in Roman historiography is executed with a broader brush. It tackles not just the question what virtus means to Roman historians (for instance as a special form of courage that serves to explain Rome's military success), but also the roles that each historian played in shaping political thinking in relation to the concept. Four historians are allocated a chapter in turn, tracing a chronological trajectory for the role of virtus: Sallust's works (ch. 2) convey dark warnings about the loss of virtus in the late Republic, but also open up virtus to a wider social range; Livy (ch. 3) has a more optimistic take, presenting ancient virtus as a source of inspiration to the present, and also charting its changing relation to Roman identity and freedom; Velleius Paterculus’ celebration of virtus restored within the person of Tiberius underpins his panegyrical approach to the emperor (ch. 4), and depicts virtus as a unifying theme that binds republican past and early imperial present together, its continuity under the new regime mitigating the violent changes that Rome has undergone; finally, Tacitus’ career, as mapped out through his works (ch. 5), sees him gradually developing a new model of virtus for the Principate, which privileges the virtues of moderatio and constantia above all, and locates acts of courage in resistance to fear and flattery. The picture is a familiar one, but plotted out in thorough, detailed study of the four historians.
One of the challenging aspects of the term virtus is its incorporation of a range of intertwined yet distinct meanings, from manhood, through military prowess and courage, to general moral excellence; it can also denote a single specific quality, or can be used in the plural virtutes to mean moral qualities in general, or virtuous deeds. B. differentiates between two categories of meaning, virtus–virilis (courage, military prowess) and virtus–humana (general moral excellence), and rightly points out that these coexist throughout the period in question. Although this binary framework can be a useful tool for analysis, it is too categorical to do full justice to the way authors exploit the richness of the concept. Moreover, the potential for semantic slippage makes it hard to keep a handle on the topic, despite the systematic structure of the book, and the tightness of B.’s argument sometimes falls foul of this. A study which starts from the multiple meanings of the Latin term virtus becomes in places confusingly untethered, when it strays into discussion of general moral excellence and the cluster of individual virtues that constitute it, without reference to virtus. The discussion of female virtue in Livy is one such place; another is in ch. 5 where it is hard to follow the logic that proceeds: Tacitus uses the term virtus very little; instead he emphasises the importance of the qualities of modestia and constantia; he is thereby modifying the meaning of the term virtus by incorporating modestia and constantia within it. B. makes many valuable observations about the ancient texts, but it is not always clear how the framing arguments are grounded and tessellated.
In her conclusion, B. conjures up a light-hearted scene of debate between her four historians (244–5), where each man embodies the approach of his works as summarised in her preceding chapters. Sallust deplores the snowballing moral corruption of his day, Livy interrupts to laud the inspirational and exemplary value of ancient mores, Velleius enthusiastically agrees but adds that now virtus has been reinvigorated, Tacitus explains that the new challenges of the Principate demand a new kind of virtus, standing by one's principles. This thought-experiment at once sums up the strengths and limitations of the book. It provides accessible summaries of a considerable body of Roman historiography, offering a panoramic view, which clearly brings out the differences between the four authors, and shows how their representations of virtus and political virtue are in dialogue with the political climates in which they lived. Chs 2–5 would make especially good reading for students new to Roman historiography, with their lucid character sketches of the historians and their aims, and their concise summaries of scholarly debates. B.’s historians are powerful autonomous agents in Roman history, who deliberately reshape their compatriots’ understanding of key moral ideas as a practical contribution to Roman society. A biographical approach is taken towards interpretation of the historiography: Velleius praised Tiberius because ‘what he had seen gave him some reason to believe that Tiberius’ virtutes … were something real’ (144); ‘Tacitus is disappointed at the circumstances’ of fear and flattery under Tiberius (226). The confident claims about the intentions of authors and clear depiction of thematic trends risk obscuring complexity in the texts and gaps in our understanding, and the self-assured interpretations of each work will not seem persuasive or definitive to all readers. The work does not so much probe the subtleties of the Latin term virtus, as offer a broad narrative frame in which one might do so, with intriguing insights about the material along the way.
