Contemporary affairs in the Middle East continue to heighten the significance of Kurdish studies. Although Kurds are still counted as a people without an official state, they play an ever more visible role in the making of politics in modern-day Turkey, Iraq, and Iran. Understanding how and why Kurds have been historically denied a state, but remain an influential component of the region's politics, remains an issue of intense scholarly study. Yet, as Janet Klein attests to in Margins of Empire, harsh political realities and nationalist taboos make investigating Kurdish history difficult. In the case of Turkey, orthodox Kemalist dogma long dictated that Kurdishness was simply a gross localized corruption of Turkish identity. While Kurdish resistance (particularly in the form of the Kurdish Workers Party) has helped to undermine Ankara's position toward Kurdish nationalism, ongoing violence and tensions still inhibits scholars from conducting research both in the countryside and in Turkey's main archives and libraries.
The challenges of composing a thoroughly researched historical study of war and Kurdish politics in contemporary eastern Anatolia makes Janet Klein's new book, in and of itself, a welcome addition to the field. Margins of Empire is anything but a one-dimensional study. Her treatment of the book's principle subject, the building and evolution of the so-called Hamidiye light cavalry corps in eastern Anatolia at the turn of the 20th century, addresses a variety of historical threads related to Kurdish history. Her rendering of how Kurds came to be incorporated into the Hamidiye corps provides a rich prism through which to examine the modern invention and transformation of eastern Anatolian politics and society. Above all, as a work grounded in the complexities of Ottoman rule and reform at the turn of 20th century, Margins of Empire affirms a great many studies of the age of high imperialism.
Klein's depiction of the Hamidiye's origins consciously reflects her effort to contextualize and analyze the maturation of the late Ottoman Empire. Istanbul's policy of establishing a corps of light cavalry units among various Kurdish tribes symbolized, at first glance, the much broader imperial undertaking of securing its eastern border from the dual threats of invasion and sedition. This policy, however, did not simply derive from military necessity, efficiency, or even convenience. Forming the Hamidiye corps (named after the reigning sultan, Abdülhamid II) was the culmination of a series of imperial ventures such as the elimination of the older system of autonomous tribal emirates meant to strengthen Istanbul's hold over eastern Anatolia. In establishing these militias, as it was reasoned in the capital, the fluidity of the old political and social order of this “frontier” region would give way to the construction of a centrally controlled and militarized “border” culture: a culture developed and increasingly governed by local militia leaders possessing direct ties to Istanbul.
The story of how Istanbul sought to centralize and modernize imperial governance throughout the 19th and 20th centuries is a well-researched topic in Ottoman studies. Margins of Empire contributes to broadening this vein of research. The narrative Janet Klein presents entreats the reader to think about the establishment of the Hamidiye as an imperial project defined by a core contradiction. Istanbul, Klein argues, saw in the Hamidiye a means of exerting greater centralized control over this portion of the Anatolian periphery without having to completely “re-engineer” or reconstitute the political or social fabric of Kurdish society. As a result, in relying upon a select number of tribal emirs to form the backbone of this imperial security force (a force that would bring greater control and order to the region), the formation of the Hamidiye ultimately served to reinforce the regional autonomy and factionalism found in Kurdish society before the onset of the Ottoman reform period.
According to Klein, mobilizing the military potential of eastern Anatolia's Kurdish population offered the empire a number of other benefits. At a time when elements in the capital began to perceive the loyalties of the empire's Christians (particularly Armenians) as increasingly suspect, Abdülhamid II's regime reasoned that a more direct relationship with the Sunni Kurdish population could help offset any potential separatist uprising on the empire's eastern border. Employing and equipping Kurdish militias provided a pretext to groom and “civilize” this generally isolated and marginalized portion of the Ottoman population. Despite some apprehension on the part of both imperial officials and some Kurdish notables, the Hamidiye became quickly rooted in eastern Anatolian society. Even with the official abrogation of the unit's existence after the fall of Abdülhamid II in 1909, local Armenian resistance and strategic interests compelled Istanbul to retain the Hamidiye corps in all but name into World War I and beyond.
Janet Klein clearly and successfully argues that the Hamidiye helped to lay the foundation for how Kurds experience ethnic, tribal, and regional politics in contemporary eastern Anatolia. Militarizing the Kurdish population highlighted their existence and significance as an ethnic group. It was a measure that also instigated greater interest (both at home and by foreign powers) in their political loyalties and their collective utility as imperial agents. The Hamidiye transformed, and reinforced, the “tribal character” of Kurdish society. Smaller and weaker tribes, for example, utilized the Hamidiye as a means of exerting greater influence of regional affairs. Perhaps of greatest importance, Hamidiye recruitment instigated and heightened growing ethnic and sectarian divides throughout eastern Anatolia. In keeping with the Islamist tone of Abdülhamid II's reign, the mass recruitment of Sunni Kurds into the Hamidiye underscored the political, social, and economic chasm between eastern Anatolia's Armenian volk and the region's largely Muslim government. Klein contends, however, that the Hamidiye was not a natural expression or result of Kurdish enmity towards local Armenian civilians, pointing out time and again that amicable communal relations existed between Kurds and Armenians in various parts of Anatolia. The role that Hamidiye troopers would play in the Armenian Genocide should instead be viewed as an outgrowth of localized competition over land and the growing militarization of large sections of the Ottoman borderlands.
Scholars of empire and colonialism will delight in the explicit and implicit historical parallels found in Margins of Empire. Janet Klein's analysis of how the mobilization and militarization of indigenous peripheral populations shapes regional politics is a theme found in studies throughout the 19th- and early 20th-century colonial world. In looking at the pageantry and systems of patronage that accompanied the construction of the Hamidiye, Margins of Empire affirms the pervasiveness of the mission civilisatrice in the Ottoman Empire. It may also be said that Klein adds further evidence to Ussama Makdisi's contention that a nesting form of Orientalism informed and defined Istanbul's policies towards eastern Anatolia.
Even though the narrative outlined in Margins of Empire concludes at the outset of World War I, Klein's research offers a premise with which scholars of 20th-century Turkish and Kurdish history could approach important contemporary topics. The Hamidiye, Klein argues, became a blueprint for the future recruitment of pro-Ankara militias used to fight Kurdish separatists. At a local level, Margins of Empire foreshadows, to some degree, the ongoing resonance of tribal politics in Turkish domestic politics. In short, Klein contributes much to Ottoman, Turkish, and Kurdish studies. Margins of Empire will certainly stand as a cornerstone for future research into the construction of Kurdish identity and politics as well as the making of modern eastern Anatolia.
