Human rights exist in tension with the sovereign claims, territorial limits, and political authority of states. In this book, Benjamin Gregg theorizes ways in which citizens can assert their rights in order to transform existing states into rights-respecting political orders, which he conceptualizes as a human rights state. One's status as a human being, rather than the territory one inhabits, should, aspirationally, determine whether one bears at least a minimal set of rights. A pragmatic sensibility underlies Gregg's constructivist proposals for a nonideal politics aimed at addressing ways in which actually existing states violate or erect barriers to human rights. Gregg largely sets aside questions about the legitimacy or necessity of the state and instead focuses on how local movement, structural change, and normative grammar can help foster and reflect rights-based commitments and visions. One of the many great strengths of Gregg's account is its positive, politically astute, and cautiously hopeful tone. In his view, human rights are made and achieved, not discovered or given. They are best realized through persuasion from the local level on up by challenging, influencing, and modifying the resources of the state. Gregg does not replicate liberal gospel about the state belonging to and deriving its legitimacy from the people, nor does he characterize nation states as mutual-benefit schemes aimed at securing our rights and promoting justice. Instead, he takes states as they are and theorizes a metaphorical human rights state which functions as a critical moral standard alongside the corresponding nation state. Specifically, Gregg holds that we pursue justice without borders by reimagining the rights-respecting state such that rights trump, and so limit, territorial sovereignty.
Gregg's project for the free embrace of human rights features three parts. The first develops the metaphorical idea of a rights-respecting political order alongside and within the state. Advocates recognize themselves as mutually possessing human rights as a way of exceeding what a nation state currently provides or protects, prying open states while deterritorializing rights. Human rights are bound to the person, as if in a backpack metaphorically worn by and always traveling with the self-determining agents; human rights transcend state borders through belief, commitment, and practice.
Part 2 recommends three strategies for deploying a human rights state. First, Gregg suggests that human rights be conscientiously taught as a cognitive style. Specifically, this cognitive style imagines and develops locally plausible forms of human rights with careful regard for the context and well-being. Second, Gregg argues that developing human rights commitments rooted in the individual person, rather than the more exclusive citizen, will break down barriers to immigration and transcend narrowly nationalistic tendencies in overcoming authoritarian legacies. Third, Gregg suggests that we explore the use of cyberspace as a resource, at once deeply local yet globally connected, for bypassing state authorities to advance the cross-cultural, cross-border politics of human rights.
Part 3 defends the human rights state as a practicable cosmopolitan idea that is rooted in strong local political movements aimed at addressing aspects of national patriotism, the largely nondemocratic landscape of our international order, and human rights disasters such as mass atrocities and genocide. Gregg defends the cohabitation of localized patriotism and cosmopolitan regard. He focuses on the rule of law rather than democracy as the major precondition for the possibility of human rights. Finally, he argues that humanitarian intervention is justified when the possibility of local politics is destroyed as a result of brutal massacre or ethnic cleansing.
Gregg moves beyond a certain stalemate that exists between cosmopolitanism and nationalist approaches to global justice with his notion of domestically situated cosmopolitanism focused primarily on transforming the state. He richly interweaves local action and global concern by directly challenging those aspects of state sovereignty and domestic jurisdiction at odds with the human rights project. We reconcile nationalism and cosmopolitanism by cultivating a shared sense of cosmopolitan identity within our cultural practices, a kind of patriotism toward the state reconceived as rights-respecting. This novel yet realistic cosmopolitanism is, Gregg argues, best implemented by common people within a local community, not delivered from the philosophical clouds or globally dispersed through some sort of world organization.
A perhaps unavoidable worry with Gregg's juridical and constitutional approach to securing rights is that human rights become political instruments used to further necessitate and strengthen, as opposed to reforming and dismantling, nation states. Rights-based debate about political morality may then exist in spite of their being constitutionally codified and legally entrenched rather than because they are so. We must have constant vigilance concerning the potential disparities that can arise between the stated goals of helping to realize human rights and the practical effects of institutionalization. Despite Gregg's cautious and qualified approach, perhaps we cannot safely navigate the coercive apparatus of the state to reflect and advance the human rights state while simultaneously challenging and diminishing its power. The territoriality of the state has served as the bedrock of legal sovereignty. Can law celebrate and honor, without stifling or replacing, the shared, active moral imagination underlying Gregg's human rights state?
Gregg's approach to human rights as a socially constructed practice that originates locally through voluntary participation is a compelling conception of “doing” human rights. A rights-respecting order is an inclusive political project with a scientific open-mindedness coexisting with more comprehensive views rooted in theological or metaphysical traditions, since they too are avenues for engaging human rights. There is no smoking-gun, knock-down theory or argument, claim or insight that guarantees rights. Persuasion with accumulated evidence, refined arguments, and growing consensus based on our rational capacities and freely embraced commitments, as opposed to coercion, are the best means we have for advancing the human rights project. To the extent that such an undertaking helps individuals to develop assertive selfhood and a human rights personality, we will want to ensure that the political community recognizes the rights of those who are unable or unwilling to authorize or claim rights themselves, such as children, animals, marginalized humans, and perhaps future generations. As a normative project aimed at persuasion, the contest of ideas that underlie human rights rests on “the peculiarly forceless force of the better argument” to inform politics (23).
At first a polity of the imagination or metaphorical state without territory might sound silly, a perhaps desirable but impractical goal of undertaking a rights-based transformation of the state-based international order. However, in a world of extreme political violence, such theoretical pursuits appeal to our decent impulses, our capacity for well-reasoned moral reflection, and our commitment to change based on persuasion not coercion. As an inspired set of ideas, The Human Rights State is an informed and nuanced constructive strategy that connects deep philosophical insight with the practical importance of advancing a more rights-respecting cosmopolitan order. Human rights are theorized as an open-ended, down-to-earth political project with enormous transformative potential. Our rights are reclaimed from and asserted against existing nation states. In place of the physical, conceptual, and experiential barriers of statist logic, Gregg conceives the human rights state as promoting justice by embodying locally sourced cosmopolitan rights.
