It is rare for the pages of this journal to dedicate space to reviewing what the author of Politics Latin America clearly positions as a ‘textbook’. Yet amongst Latin Americanists from distinct disciplinary backgrounds, it has long been both deficit and a challenge that there is no single-volume text which can be proffered to the undergraduate fresh to study of the region in the confidence that it might perform the daunting task of comprehensively presenting the politics of the region with authority, acuity and readability. The many editions of Skidmore and Smith's admirable volume, Modern Latin America, attest to those authors' integrity and relative success in that sense, and comparable works have made valiant attempts to deal with the complexity of Latin American politics in a form which does not frighten the life out of students recently introduced to study of the region. It is just this field into which O'Toole enters, with this ambitious, clearly thought-out, and well-balanced volume.
The book is split into five sections. The first gives an overview of Latin American political history from independence to the 1980s, certainly concise, but nevertheless providing a clear view of the central historical dynamics, actors and factors that the student of twentieth-century politics will need to build on. Thereafter, the book is divided thematically into four further sections focussed on Institutions, Processes and Actors; International Relations; Political Ideas; and Economic Ideas. Each of these sections is further subdivided to deal with specific areas. Section Two (Institutions, Processes and Actors) for example, deals with democratisation; the presidency; legislatures, parties, the judiciary and public administration; and civil society and emergent actors. Whilst clearly the 80–100 pages dedicated to each of the five sections in the book is far from exhaustive, O'Toole's analyses are clear and engaged with the key schools of thought around each of the central issues, and are strong enough to stand up to rigorous examination whilst at the same time serving as a bridge into more detailed readings for the inquisitive student. In that sense, the design and layout of the book should be commended; each chapter has inset boxes containing case studies linked to the theme of the chapter. This allows O'Toole to develop a fluent narrative around the most significant characteristics of the issue at hand without becoming bogged-down in the fine detail which can often derail even the most engaged of students. So, for example, his chapter on Inter-State Relations within Latin America, which moves through discussions of responses to US power, policy options, sovereignty, security, democracy and human rights, also includes insets on nuclear weapons programmes in the Southern Cone, on anti-Americanism, on the theories and debates of institutionalism and realism, and on the OAS, amongst others. And throughout the book, each chapter ends with a list of discussion points, useful websites, and recommended reading, a useful and time-efficient resource for student and teacher alike. Equally usefully, amongst the appendices are an extensive glossary, which runs from absolutism to Zapatista, and a list of dramatis personae, both clearly set out and are a boon to the student no matter what their level of knowledge or confusion may be.
As O'Toole notes in his preface, it is perhaps somewhat ironic that in order to complete this book, he has been ‘exiled’ from the classroom. If so, the exile has been worthwhile. This is a volume which will become invaluable to those attempting to guide the neophyte through the maze of politics in Latin America, and I suspect that it will, over time, become just as much of a core reading as Skidmore and Smith has become for many a student of Latin American politics and history.
