Morocco's public image has undergone numerous transformations in recent years. An enduring portrait formed under the tutelage of the late King Hassan II (1961–1999) was that of an absolute monarchy whose external persona was benign enough but whose internal modus operandi was particularly brutal, including the use of torture, the imprisonment of thousands of political dissidents, and the application of a system of fear and intimidation intended to keep opponents in line. This more seamy side of the country was often minimized or camouflaged in the name of promoting a pro-Western image that included a “moderate” foreign policy sympathetic to Western regional ambitions. As part of this latter effort, Rabat willingly established a variety of diplomatic and intelligence contacts with Israel as a way to curry favor with European and American business, political, and military interests. That Morocco has also been for decades the desired destination for millions of Western tourists who have found the country, people, and culture hospitable and inviting has created a complex if not conflictual portrait of the Arab world's most geographically western nation.
The ascendancy to the throne in 1999 of Mohamed VI has added another layer of complexity to this already multifaceted political landscape as he has encouraged positive political change that has seen the release of scores of political prisoners and has liberalized important aspects of social policy, including a radical revision of the mudawwana, the personal status code. However, the country remains depressingly poor, with gross domestic product per capita well under $2,000. Despite government-sponsored eradication efforts, slums continue to encircle large cities and unemployment remains exceptionally high, with estimates ranging as high as 40 percent. Most ominous has been the involvement of Moroccans both at home and abroad in a wide range of terrorist attacks, including the suicide bombings in Casablanca on 16 May 2003, and in Madrid on 11 March 2004.
What then is one to make of these contrasting positive and negative images that today define Morocco? Marvine Howe makes an exceptionally successful effort in balancing context and content, allowing the reader to see where the country has been, where it is today, and what its future may look like. As a former New York Times reporter whose ties to the country and its leading personalities extend from the preindependence period (March 1956) until today, Howe is well positioned to provide both historical perspective and contemporary insight unmatched by few other observers of the country.
The book is divided into four parts, thirteen chapters plus an epilogue. Using a mixture of personal encounters, journalistic reports, and academic writings, the author weaves an organizationally coherent account of Morocco's principle identifying features beginning with a “tour du Maroc.” In succinct yet historically accurate manner, Howe provides a fair-minded overview of the preindependence period, focusing on such critical institutional actors as, inter alia, the monarchy, the nationalist political parties, and the French protectorate, along with the political motivations and activities of the relevant politicians, personalities, and players. The postindependence era is given equally balanced treatment as the author critically assesses the damaging effect on Hassan's rule of the political assassination of the left wing nationalist leader Mehdi Ben Barka, a prominent personality who, like many other noteworthy Moroccan figures, Howe knew personally. Although she presents no new or revealing information regarding the two failed assassination attempts directed against Hassan in 1971 and 1972, Howe correctly observes that those aborted coups ushered in “les années de plomb,” the many years of “lead” that saw the regime use systematic and extreme brutality as a means to eradicate all forms of opposition—including the cruel imprisonment of General Mohamed Oufkir's wife and young children in a desert encampment in retribution for their father's involvement in the 1972 coup.
The cruelty of the Hassanian epoch, although much attenuated by the late 1990s, created the political challenges—and opportunities—that Islamism and democratic pluralism were to exploit. The book's third and fourth parts elaborate on the Islamist challenge in both its moderate and more militant manifestations. Howe reveals her consistently fair-minded approach as she deconstructs Islamist discourse as provided by various spokespeople, including the rising new star of Moroccan Islamist politics, Nadia Yassine, the daughter of Shaykh Abdessalam Yassine, the aging but still charismatic leader of the Justice and Welfare Association. Although brief and at times somewhat superficial, Howe manages to give a relatively accurate picture of the full expanse of Islamist alternatives, including the most radical, the Salafiya Jihadia.
Subsequent chapters cover such important themes as the changing status of women, including the opportunities that the revised family code will provide for the large majority of otherwise marginalized poor women living in the countryside. Howe taps into a wide range of feminist thinking through her numerous interviews with both established scholars such as Fatema Mernissi and younger political activists such as Yasmina Baddou. This facet of Moroccan social existence is further contextualized within the broader changes and challenges that Morocco is experiencing today, including the impact of the Internet, the high expectations of the rising class of young professionals trained and socialized in the West, the corrosive consequences on state and society of the yet-unresolved western Saharan conflict, and the expansive influence of a revived Islamist social consciousness that permeates virtually every strata of Moroccan society and from which Islamist politics finds political sustenance.
Howe's bold confrontation with the regime's “democratic façade” serves both as the book's penultimate topic of discussion as well as the broader template to help predict the country's future. One cannot help but agree with the author's insistence that pseudodemocracy, as now practiced by the regime, is a formula for disaster not only for the Moroccan people themselves but also for many outside its borders. The Casablanca and Madrid bombings can serve either as the opportunity to launch “a new vision and profound structural changes” (p. 354) from which an embedded democracy will emerge that can ensure a more secure future or simply as an excuse to reactivate the “lead years” under the cover of “Islamic terrorism.” In this exceptionally well-written and sensitively interpreted account, Marvine Howe genuinely hopes for the former but, like many of her interlocutors, is fearful of the latter.
