Recent decades have witnessed a surge of studies in the history of Roman law, particularly within its socio-political, economic and cultural contexts, thus extending the enquiry well beyond the exegesis of Roman legal texts which dominated the scholarship of the nineteenth and the better part of the twentieth century. Nonetheless, since most of our evidence, juristic and otherwise, pertains to the Classical period of Roman law, the legal environment of the late Republic remains considerably more obscure. The volume under review addresses this limitation by focusing on Cicero, whose work presents a wealth of material concerning this crucial period in the development of Roman law.
The volume, comprising eleven contributions by scholars whose specialisms range from Classics to legal history and jurisprudence, sets out to offer a re-assessment of Cicero's place in the traditional narratives of Roman law of the late Republic. More precisely, it aims to challenge the view of Cicero as ‘an outsider’, whose outlook differed considerably from that of the Roman jurists (1). The contributors were asked, instead, to treat Cicero and his œuvre as part of a broader legal culture of the late Republic. The concept of ‘legal culture’ and the potential benefits of its application to this particular period of Roman history are helpfully summarised in the editor's introduction (3–6). Though not unproblematic, thinking of legal ‘culture’ as opposed to, for instance, a legal ‘system’ or ‘framework’ has the potential to open up more stimulating debates concerning the societal factors affecting legal development, dissemination of legal knowledge, availability of legal advice and so on. The volume aims to contribute to some of these debates, and is organised around three key themes: law, legal profession and legal practice.
The first section (On Law) opens with Philip Thomas’ analysis of Cicero's Topica as a textbook on legal methodology. Thomas argues that Cicero, as the middleman between Roman law and Greek science, played a crucial role in the development of late republican law, and demonstrates how the perceived divide between the jurists and orators in the Roman world is largely a product of modern interpretation. Olga Tellegen-Couperus and Jan Willem Tellegen then look at the Roman law of succession in the light of Hellenistic philosophical influences. Taking the concept of voluntas testatoris as a case study, the authors stress the under-appreciated influence of the New Academy, observed both in Cicero's work and in the juristic sources. Finally, Benedikt Forschner takes a closer look at Cicero's legal philosophy. The author foregrounds the coherence between Cicero's philosophical writings and his forensic speeches and illustrates how philosophical arguments could be employed in legal practice, a phenomenon also detectable in the legal discourse of the jurists. All three contributions identify Cicero as a key figure in the development of late republican legal theory and methodology, despite the common tendency to downplay his relevance.
The second section (On Lawyers) focuses on the nature of the legal profession. Yasmina Benferhat investigates the social position of late republican jurists through Cicero's representations of Scaevola, Rufus and Trebatius to argue that, for Cicero, rather unsurprisingly, ‘being a specialist in civil law was not enough for political life in Rome’ (74). However, the author's subsequent assertion that, with the end of the Republic, ‘Roman civil law became the civil law of an Empire’ (86) fails to appreciate the considerable plurality of laws operable throughout the Roman Empire, at least until 212 c.e. In the following contribution, Christine Lehne-Gstreinthaler highlights the legal expertise of some of the less illustrious professionals such as court representatives, magistrates’ advisors, clerks and businessmen. The author successfully demonstrates the versatility of the legal profession in the late Republic, as well as the penetration of legal knowledge into the lower strata of society, including freedmen. The otherwise very compelling argument is somewhat obscured, in my view, by the author's insistence on calling people involved in these occupations ‘jurists’, while admitting that they were neither referred to as jurists by others nor, indeed, considered themselves such. Matthijs Wibier then explores the reception of Cicero in the early Empire: treated in the juristic sources as a legal authority, alongside other late republican jurisconsults, Cicero should be seen as an integral part of the Roman juristic tradition. The perceived antagonism between legal scholarship and legal oratory, Wibier accurately suggests, must be indicative of an open conversation between the two. The section closes with Jill Harries’ analysis of the curious continuity of (the perception of) law from the late Republic to the late Empire in the juristic tradition. Harries exposes various modes of construction of a legal continuum by the jurists as members of the ‘enlightened elite’, and draws an interesting parallel in this respect between Rome and modern Russia. Overall, this section places Cicero firmly within the Roman juristic tradition and foregrounds his role in shaping the legal culture of the late Republic, still perceptible in the later imperial sources.
The final section (On Legal Practice) opens with Saskia T. Roselaar's examination of the mechanisms behind the integration of Italy into the Roman legal framework as a result of the Social War. Roselaar underlines the heterogeneity of Italian communities in the first century b.c.e. and illustrates, through Cicero's speeches, the legal prejudice that continued to haunt some of the Italians even after 70 b.c.e. Jennifer Hilder then draws on the anonymous Rhetorica ad Herennium and Cicero's De inventione to demonstrate how they can illuminate a variety of strategies used in the late republican courts, as well as the level of legal knowledge expected of the advocates and the jurors. Similarly, Michael C. Alexander looks at Cicero's speeches in combination with rhetorical handbooks to explore the apparent contradiction between multiple charges and unitary punishment in late republican criminal trials. The author argues that multiple charges found in forensic speeches should be understood as a common strategy in trials where only a single charge needed to be proved to achieve a conviction. The section closes with Catherine Steel's analysis of the role that forensic activity played in the making of elite senatorial careers in late republican Rome. Steel stresses, in particular, the importance of specialist advice and elite support networks that were available to young aspiring politicians when undertaking their first public prosecution. Put together, the four contributions illuminate the everyday legal environment in which Cicero operated.
In sum, the volume provides a considerably more nuanced view of the legal world of the late Republic by highlighting Cicero as indispensable for our understanding of that world. The contributions touch upon most aspects of Cicero's multifaceted career and œuvre, although Cicero's correspondence with Roman officials in the provinces, which provides a mass of information on legal developments beyond Rome and Italy, is largely bypassed. A discussion of these, perhaps in combination with Cicero's own governorship of Cilicia, could have added another dimension to the section on legal practice, which is primarily focused on forensic speeches. Greater consistency regarding the provision of translations and, indeed, a consolidated bibliography would have further improved this otherwise very fine volume. The editor aptly remarks in the postscript that ‘a systematic study of Roman legal culture of the late Republic remains to be written’ (230). The volume under review is a most welcome step in that direction.
