Moramay Lopez-Alonso begins this excellent study of Mexican living standards by making a profound point: we cannot write the history of poverty and inequality without some measure of living standards. Indeed, this book makes the point that the evaluation of policy must include a long-term analysis of outcomes of interest for the quality of life. Without them, the causal effects we estimate may well be due to transient circumstances, reversion to a long-term stable pattern, or another factor that even the best laid research designs in economic history could not overcome.
Mexico experienced two major upheavals from the middle of the nineteenth to twentieth centuries. The first was the 1857 constitution which led to land redistribution that favored the elite and (it is believed) increased inequality. The second was the revolution of the early twentieth century. This revolution expanded the scope of poverty alleviation and government welfare policies. Each of these events would likely have major implications for the extent of poverty, inequality, and general measures of well-being in the population. Scholars of Mexican history have certainly argued as much, but there is little systematic evidence to support claims and subsequent revisions. Lopez-Alonso fills a large and important gap in this narrative by carefully considering the anthropometric standard of living in Mexico before, during, and after these large changes.
The book begins with a fascinating policy history of Mexico. What I enjoyed most about this section of the book was the fact that Lopez-Alonso paid keen attention to the ideology guiding public policy. This is not restricted to the general archetypes of social justice such as Darwinism, but for the role of the government and private entities in providing for the public welfare. The one major takeaway from this section is that the government's desire to exert a larger role in public life came by way of restricting the authority of the Catholic Church to provide for public welfare beginning in the middle of the nineteenth century. Even worse, the private entities that were constructed had dubious legal status and with the church's role diminished there was no institution, public or private, to fill the void until the government made the alleviation of poverty an explicit goal in 1937.
This policy history is the most important piece of the narrative. Against this backdrop, the land reforms of the middle of the nineteenth century redistributed communal land, and even small ranchers found their landholdings confiscated according to the narrative. This created an inherent inequality in wealth that worked through the political process. The desire to remove the Catholic Church from authority over secular affairs was met with little desire for poverty alleviation. This does not imply, however, that living standards declined. As economic historians know, policy change may be great but living standards unresponsive.
The second section of the book tests quantitatively whether the reforms had significant impacts on Mexican living standards. The data in wellbeing comes from military records. Lopez-Alonso's primary data is a sample of over 12,000 military heights for cohorts born from the 1850s to 1950s. (Given that the data is a military sample the standard truncation correction is applied.) Supplementary sources such as passport records and data for heights of women involved in the military are used as well, but they are largely secondary. Scholars of height would be well-served by noting the thorough approach that Lopez-Alonso takes to the data description, which is complemented by photographs in addition to the tables of summary measures. This description makes it clear that the use of both rural and urban samples and the other descriptors in the data allow for a general picture of height but also distinctions by class, and how these measures diverge between groups.
The data show two key results. First, welfare declined after the constitutional land reforms. The cohorts born in the late nineteenth century were substantially shorter than the cohorts born earlier in the century. Second, the largest declines were concentrated among the agricultural workers who lost communal lands during the mid-nineteenth century reforms. Substantial rebounding occurred beginning for cohorts born after the twentieth-century revolution, when policy aims shifted. Some convergence for industrial classes occurred before that time, but the cohort heights of the poorest military men did not rebound until the 1950s. In the final section of the book, Lopez-Alonso argues that health interventions, the continued high fertility of the Mexican population, and a diet that was largely unchanged play a role. Since it is impossible to identify which factors played a more dominant role at any point in this history, this section serves to give readers access to all of the potential explanations.
Overall, this is a major contribution to the economic and policy history of Mexico and of the Americas more generally. The institutional changes in the nineteenth century make it difficult to generalize over the entire pattern of development, and Lopez-Alonso's work marries a thorough policy history in a time of political upheaval with a measure of policy effects. If there is a missing piece to this work, it is that the policy history does not include more engagement with political economy. As the policy goals changed the players did as well, but open questions are why these changes came about and how they were shaped by economic and political events.
What is most impressive about this book is that the narrative is interested in policy history. Before we set out to measure the effects of policy we should, as historians, think about policy over the long term. What is it that policymakers are trying to achieve? Ex ante, was their assessment of the scope of problem correct? Ex post, did they use every tool available to achieve their policy goals? Lopez-Alonso marries an interesting conceptual approach to a wealth of new anthropometric data and extends the scope of the field. I had never before considered height data as a tool for policy analysis, but the focus of this volume shows that height as a measure of living standards can inform policy debates as well as more abstract discussions of living standards.
