In this insightful biography, Paul Mosley and Barbara Ingham provide a careful reconstruction of the personal and intellectual trajectory of W. Arthur Lewis (1915–1991). Arthur Lewis was one of the fathers of development economics and the first Caribbean to be awarded the Nobel Prize in Economics, and his life connected several crucial junctures in the global history of the twentieth century. Indeed, Lewis’s life linked the world of economic theory and the politics of reform in developing countries, the decline of the British Empire with the high hopes (and the following disappointment) of postcolonial Africa, and the heated political context of the Caribbean with the rise of ‘development’ as a Nobel-winning branch of economic analysis. It is difficult to imagine two scholars more suited to the task of reconstructing Lewis’s life. Like Lewis, Mosley and Ingham have combined an academic interest in poverty and development with policy work as advisors to developing countries. Furthermore, both the authors spent part of their careers at the University of Manchester. As it will become clear later, this has some significant implications for the book’s overall contribution.
Starting with Lewis’s childhood in the poverty-stricken Caribbean island of St. Lucia, the authors follow their subject at the London School of Economics (LSE), where he obtained his Bachelor in Commerce and his PhD. Chapter 3 focuses on Lewis’s work at the Colonial Office in the 1940s and 1950s. It was here, argue the authors, that, by emphasizing market failures and the need for state intervention in developing countries, selective industrialization, the importance of increasing agricultural productivity, and the crucial role that mass education could have played to increase productivity in agricultural and industrial sectors (pp. 58–66), Lewis planted the seed for what would be known as “development economics” in the postwar years. Of course, this does not imply that the reception of Lewis’s vision went unchallenged: by looking at Lewis’s work in bodies like the Colonial Economic Advisory Committee and the Colonial Development Corporation, Mosley and Ingham reconstruct the intellectual, political, and practical challenges met by Lewis in his attempt to turn his ideas into policy. This tension would indeed be a recurring feature in the economist’s life.
Chapters 4 and 5 discuss the years between 1948 and 1957, when Lewis occupied the Stanley Jevons Chair in political economy at the University of Manchester. Not only did this institution provide the setting for Lewis’s most important theoretical contribution, the dual model of economic development with unlimited supplies of labor (Lewis Reference Lewis1954), but helped reconstruct Lewis’s trajectory as a political activist and social reformer in Britain. Chapter 6 discusses Lewis’s work as an economic advisor to Ghana’s first postcolonial government in 1957–58. Lewis, who had already written an influential report on Ghana’s economic development during his years at the Colonial Office (Lewis Reference Lewis1953), saw in advising the first British colony in Sub-Saharan Africa to become independent a great opportunity. However, he ended up handing in his resignation before the end of the contract and leaving the country in bitter disappointment. Interestingly, Lewis’s failure to make Ghanaian politicians adopt his recommendations is analyzed through the lens of Albert O. Hirschmann’s discussion of economic advisors in the developing world, and the taxonomy developed by Dudley Seers in his provoking article “Why Visiting Economists Fail” (Seers Reference Seers1962).
But neither the betrayal of his hopes about Ghana nor memories of the difficult times at the Colonial Office could convince the economist to withdraw into an ivory tower. His native Caribbean would provide another setting for Lewis’s attempt to put his expertise at the service of mankind. Between 1959 and 1963, he took the position as chancellor of the University College of West Indies. This also proved to be a disheartening experience, between the opposition with which Lewis’s ideas about the management of the university were met and the disappointment of his hopes about a larger West Indian political federation—which, in Lewis’s view, could have played a crucial role in fostering the islands’ economic development. In 1963 Lewis accepted a job as professor of Development Economics at Princeton. Chapter 8 explores the last decades of Lewis’s life, culminating with the award of the first Nobel Prize in the field of development economics (shared with Theodore Schulz) in 1979, until his death in 1991. Although Lewis eventually returned to advise the West Indies in the 1970s, the chapter’s focus is on his teaching and research at Princeton. For example, it provides an excellent presentation of the economist’s work in global economic history in the late 1960s and 1970s (pp. 224–248). The last chapter offers a brief reflection on Lewis’s legacy. This, according to the authors, can be found in his contribution to the understanding of the way markets operate in developing countries, in his attempt to uncover the determinants of growth, and, more importantly, in the awareness that “economics concerns life more than numbers” (Lewis, quoted at p. 269).
The book is written very clearly. Furthermore, it is extremely well documented, relying on a considerable amount of published and archival material gathered in Britain, the United States, and the Caribbean. However, an appraisal of the volume’s contribution would be incomplete without comparing it with Robert L. Tignor’s W. Arthur Lewis and the Birth of Development Economics (Tignor Reference Tignor2006), the first book-length biography of the economist. Although both volumes roughly cover the same ground, there are some significant differences in focus and approach that make them complementary. Tignor’s biography, for example, is truly masterful in its discussion of Lewis’s experience in Ghana. Through an extensive analysis of the country’s economic and political history, and by drawing on evidence collected in the Ghanaian national archives and in the World Bank archives, Tignor’s biography remains, alongside the classic Tony Killick (Reference Killick1978) and Fusao Ariga (Reference Ariga2001), the most detailed account of planning design and implementation in early independent Ghana.
At the beginning of the book, Mosley and Ingham claim that they tried to fill some of the gaps in Tignor’s account (p. 13). But far from merely being an exercise in gap-filling, this volume makes several original and important contributions. These mostly result in a series of relocations that force us to rethink the geographical and institutional spaces of Lewis’s evolution. First, Mosley and Ingham do an excellent job at exploring the role played by what Lewis called the LSE’s “marvellous intellectual feasts” in shaping his outlook (see also Ingham and Mosley Reference Ingham and Mosley2013). Given Lewis’s lifelong anti-colonialism and Fabian socialist sympathies, one is left to wonder what his economic analysis would have been like if he had not been exposed at a young age to the ideas of Friedrich A. Hayek, Lionel Robbins, and, especially, Arnold Plant. To his training as an economist, the authors rightly add the variety of other intellectual traditions in sociology and politics to which Lewis was exposed during the LSE years. Second, the authors show convincingly the importance of Manchester as a specific historical and institutional site for the making of the economist’s ideas and identity. While Tignor (2006, ch. 3) discussed the reception of Lewis’s 1950s work in the development economics community at large, Mosley and Ingham firmly locate the same work in the very specific context of Manchester. This has two main implications. First, it leads the authors to uncover an interesting (and previously underexplored) connection between Lewis and South African anthropologist Max Gluckman. This connection certainly mattered for Lewis’s formation as a development economist: it was through Gluckman, for example, that Lewis came to “represent rural subsistence households not as a unit within which maximizing behaviour can be observed (as in conventional neo-classical economics) but rather as a redistributive extended family network” (pp. 98–99). Furthermore, the relationship between Lewis and Gluckman might represent a potentially valuable building block in rethinking the still under-researched connection between economic anthropology and development economics (p. 23). As rightly pointed out by James Ferguson (1997, p. 170), the rise of the concept of “development,” and the place it came to occupy in the social sciences, should be understood within the trajectory of specific academic disciplines and their reciprocal interaction. Second, the authors uncover for the first time the work of Lewis as a social reformer in a mature, industrial economy. If Lewis’s work in Africa and the Caribbean is well known, his attempt to create a community center for the Afro-Caribbean communities in Manchester provides a new, more localized, context to think about the interaction between Lewis’s ideas about education and policy.
On the other hand, given that Tignor, primarily an economic historian of Africa, treated his biography of Lewis as “a contribution to African history as much as an overview of a life of pioneering achievement” (Tignor Reference Tignor2006, p. ix), it would have been perhaps desirable, given Mosley’s and Ingham’s backgrounds as economists, to devote even more space to the making of Lewis’s analytical vision. In particular, it would have been interesting to know more about Lewis’s reading and interpretation of classical political economists. Lewis’s Theory of Economic Growth famously defined its scope of inquiry by claiming that the “last great book covering this wide range was John Stuart Mill’s Principles of Political Economy, published in 1848” (Lewis Reference Lewis1955, p. 5). Similarly, the 1954 article on economic development with unlimited supplies of labor begins by saying, “This essay is written in the classical tradition, making the classical assumption, and asking the classical question” (Lewis Reference Lewis1954, p. 391). Although the authors briefly discuss the influence of classical political economists on Lewis (for example, pp. 111, 263), a more extensive treatment of this aspect could have helped foster the debate on the impact of classical political economy on development economics, a crucial theme in the historiography of the latter discipline (see, for example, the essays in Meier Reference Meier1994). On the other hand, it is very likely that this and other potential gaps that remain in Lewis’s intellectual biography have also to do with the lack of archival evidence and the economist’s private nature. Footnote 1
Overall, this book represents an important contribution to the literature on W. Arthur Lewis, so far mostly concerned with specific episodes of his life, or with the applicability of his ideas to particular economic contexts. At a more general level, through the incorporation of new evidence and its fine-grained contextual reading, it is a work that enriches the historiography on development economics, in which biography has become a prominent genre. As part of a larger editorial project, not only does the book strengthen the presence of development economists in the pantheon of the Great Thinkers in Economics series, but it seems to mark, in contrast with some other volumes in the collection, a ‘thicker’ approach to life-writing. Indeed, like some other biographies of leading development economists (for example, Dosman Reference Dosman2008 and Adelman Reference Adelman2013), the volume combines a crisp presentation of economic ideas with rich reconstructions of institutional contexts and snapshots of the history of developing countries, where the idea of “economic development” is inseparable from its embodiment in the contingencies of politics. From this point of view, the book truly reflects Lewis’s life.
