David Greenberg's Republic of Spin is an ambitious, well-written, and thought-provoking study of the strategies and techniques of presidential image-making and persuasion since the turn of the twentieth century. Drawing on primary sources as well as an impressive body of interdisciplinary scholarship, Greenberg does not break a lot of new ground. Yet as he recalls how presidents from William McKinley to Barack Obama have burnished their images and “sold” their political agendas, he reminds us of some memorable moments in the history of presidential rhetoric, and he draws insights from a diverse array of political commentators and intellectuals who have written about the topic. The result is a useful, entertaining, and timely book on the evolution of the modern “public” or “rhetorical” presidency.
Greenberg begins by reminding us that what we now call “spin”—the deliberate and strategic manipulation of ideas and images in politics—is nothing new. It did not begin with the “selling of the president” in 1968, nor even with the advent of mass communication. Rather, “spin”—at least in the “broadest sense of the term”—has been with us since ancient times, as political leaders have always “given thought to the words and images” that allow them to “remain popular and achieve their goals” (4). Yet as scholars of the modern rhetorical presidency have taught us, Theodore Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson brought dramatic changes to how U.S. presidents promote themselves and, in the process, greatly enhanced the visibility and power of the office itself. Describing the presidency as a “bully pulpit,” Theodore Roosevelt became the first to make “courting public opinion” central to the job, while Wilson articulated an intellectual and political rationale for a powerful chief executive who leads by shaping and articulating public opinion. Jeffrey Tulis and others have lamented the rise of the rhetorical presidency as a dangerous departure from the Founders' constitutional vision—a change that disrupted the constitutional balance and encouraged demagoguery. But Greenberg reminds us that the story is more complicated than that. Citing both champions and critics of the rhetorical presidency, Greenberg recalls how presidents have used “spin” to deceive and manipulate, but also to educate and inspire. He also recognizes how evolving communication technologies made it inevitable that the presidents would communicate more directly with the public. Ultimately, he sides with scholarly “realists” who accept the inevitability of “spin” but seek to demystify and tame it, working to improve democracy by “educating citizens about how political words and images and symbols work” (6).
The Republic of Spin performs that educational mission well. Entertaining and accessible, the book not only provides an exhaustive survey of presidents and their rhetorical successes and failures, but also introduces a long list of supporting actors who round out the story. This “cast of characters” includes “spin doctors”—speechwriters and media consultants, advertisers and public relations experts, press secretaries and pollsters—who advised the various presidents, as well as intellectuals and journalists who contributed to the history of “spin” as advocates or critics. In the early part of the book, for example, Greenberg tells the story of Edward Bernays, who was a propagandist for the Committee on Public Information during World War I, then spent the next decade “proselytizing for public relations” (171), arguing that the techniques of the so-called Creel Committee could be put to peaceful purposes for the good of humanity. Championing public relations as a “science” and a “profession,” Bernays shamelessly exploited his connection to a famous uncle, Sigmund Freud, and staged publicity stunts like an Easter parade down Fifth Avenue by young feminists who demonstrated their liberation by puffing away on the products of his client, the American Tobacco Company. As Greenberg tells the story, Bernays “never made clear what was supposedly scientific about his method” (171), but he did develop a professional code of ethics for the profession. Later, as Hitler and Goebbels stoked fears of Nazi propaganda in the United States, Bernays had a change of heart, renouncing “the amoral principles that underpinned his rhetoric of professionalism” (203) and distinguishing between “democratic methods” of persuasion and the “illiberal nature of totalitarian propaganda” (205).
Greenberg devotes the first 125 pages of the book to profiling the presidents, “spin doctors,” and journalists of the Progressive Era—a part of the book he labels “The Age of Publicity.” The presidents discussed in these pages are well-known to readers of this journal, of course, as are many others in his “cast of characters,” including George Creel, Joseph Tumulty, John Dewey, and Walter Lippmann. As Greenberg recalls the public discourse of this era, we are reminded of just how far we have fallen. Theodore Roosevelt and Wilson, Greenberg reminds us, were “the two most intellectual and literate presidents since the founders” (83), and comparing almost any of their speeches from, say, the 1912 campaign to today's campaign speeches can't help but lead to nostalgia. By the same token, it seems noteworthy that Greenberg includes almost no contemporary political journalists or commentators in his list of historically significant “intellectuals and journalists.” Theodore Roosevelt may have complained about the muckrakers of his day, but in comparison to today's so-called journalists, writers like Jacob Riis, Ida Tarbell, Lincoln Steffens, and H. L. Mencken seem almost God-like. And even the worst “spin doctors” of the Progressive Era were less intellectually dishonest and ethically challenged than the modern political consultants Greenberg discusses toward the end of the book—a list that includes the likes of Roger Ailes, Frank Luntz, Karl Rove, and Dick Morris.
In a sense, then, Greenberg's title, Republic of Spin, is unfortunate, even a bit misleading. We have not always been a republic of spin in the narrower, more negative sense of that term—a republic of deliberate deception and poll-tested speech, of shallow, ratings-driven journalism, and “spin doctors” willing to say or do anything to win. The United States has a rich tradition of lofty, inspirational presidential rhetoric and spirited yet honest political debate, encouraged and sustained by a journalistic profession committed to the public good. That is what we've lost in today's world of “spin,” and that loss now threatens the very survival of the republic itself.
