Karl M. Kippola begins his study of masculinity in antebellum America by quoting Hector St. John de Crevecoeur, who asked in 1782 (in a question that predates the founding of the country), “What then is the American, this new man?” (1). It quickly becomes evident that a concise definition of American masculinity is complicated or, as Kippola states, that it is “impossible to talk of one American masculine model” (2). Recognizing that the “lives and artistry” of white men in the antebellum era has been repeatedly studied, Kippola situates his project by noting that in previous work, the masculinity of the men in question “is typically taken for granted and too frequently becomes invisible. Very few works address these men as men, nor do they directly deal with the multiple ways in which masculinity was performed” (3). Acts of Manhood traces popular understandings of masculinity during the antebellum period, ranging from such figures as Edwin Forrest to Edwin Booth. Kippola is careful to note some requisite caveats: his work analyzes only white masculine models and deals primarily with the most visible exemplars of masculinity (3). While his conclusion points to the intersections of gender, race, ethnicity, and class, his focus for the bulk of the book is the visible representation of (white) masculinity in popular culture.
Kippola admits that definitions of masculinity are not fixed and certain—that “masculinities are man-made, fluid constructs, which are continually adjusting to evolving expectations and demands” (2), and he notes that the popularity of actors such as Booth and Forrest often fell along class lines, thus complicating notions of manhood. Drawing upon the work of Amy S. Greenberg, Kippola works primarily with two popular conceptions of masculinity: restrained manhood and martial manhood, the former primarily associated with upper-class Americans, and the latter with the working-class (3). Much of this bifurcation of masculinity came to a head, as Kippola notes, with the Astor Place Riot, an emblematic event of the antebellum period that laid bare the class tensions boiling under the surface of the country in the years leading up to the Civil War.
Acts of Manhood is in conversation with several different areas of nineteenth-century theatre history. It continues the tradition of analyzing Jacksonian theatre (in works such as Bruce McConachie's Melodramatic Formations [U of Iowa P, 1992]), and studying the brash and powerful performances of Edwin Forrest as contrasted with the more subdued and introspective ones of Edwin Booth. It also operates in the vein of Rosemarie K. Bank's Theatre Culture in America, 1825–1860 (Cambridge UP, 1997) by looking past the stage performance and into larger cultural texts and ephemera, such as literature, advice manuals, and the political figures and rhetoric they employed. Lastly, it extends the study of cultural contexts subtending masculine representations as does, for instance, E. Anthony Rotundo in his American Manhood (Basic Books, 1993). But as Kippola accurately notes, his “study represents the first book-length exploration of masculinity on the antebellum American stage” (3). With relatively few books to date on masculinity and American theatre, Kippola's investigation is a welcome addition to this area of gender studies, which does not merely take for granted the social standing of men, but examines the performative construction of masculinity and how that construction plays out in the theatre.
Many of the strengths of Kippola's work are in the case studies that make up his chapters. Although these move forward chronologically, each has a different feel and focus. The first chapter, “Act Like a Man: Images and Rhetoric of Reconstructed Manhood,” is an analysis of American manhood as perceived through the oratory of its most popular political and religious figures, from Andrew Jackson and John Quincy Adams to Henry Ward Beecher. In Chapter 2, “‘A Glorious Image of Unperverted Manhood’: Edwin Forrest as Masculine Ideal,” Kippola provides an especially in-depth look at the career and life of the famous actor, examining why his popularity resounded (or did not) with the American people. Kippola frames his treatment of the Astor Place Riot (in Chapter 3, “A Masculine Identity Worth Dying For: The Astor Place Riot”) in terms of a play with acts and leading players, and deftly examines the causations and misinterpretations of—and the pettiness behind—much of the riot. Chapter 4, “Decorum and Delicacy: The Feminized Manliness of Edwin Booth,” is followed by the book's final chapter, “Impossibly Genial: The Masculine Transformations of John McCullough,” in which Kippola examines the too often critically ignored popular American actor John Edward McCullough, who functions, Kippola argues, as a masculine model mediating the extremes of masculinity represented by Forrest and Booth.
This last chapter provokes the only serious criticism I have of the work. By locating his study between 1828 and 1865, Kippola situates this chapter (and much of his analysis of Booth) almost as an addendum, since its subject matter falls outside the titular time frame. This is unfortunate, as some of the most original and fascinating material in Kippola's work is on the latter parts of the nineteenth century and the changing conceptions of masculinity after the war. Furthermore, while McCullough deserves more recognition than he has previously received, this study seems to waver between seeing him either as an unrecognized theatre great or as simply not as good as Forrest or Booth—the reviews upon which Kippola draws suggesting the latter.
Overall, however, Kippola's study is very detailed, heavily researched, and provides exciting new angles of interpretation on an important period of American theatre. Further, Kippola links the development of the American Dream and the self-conception of the nation to notions of American masculinity, noting that “by the end of the Civil War, not only had the nation's masculine identity fragmented, but the individual's own identity fragmented as well. He could not be entirely a man of action nor a man of feeling, yet he was pushed to make a choice—with the inevitable result that something would be lost in the process. That something, I suggest, was any hope of creating either a unified political body or a unified culture” (182–3). The ramifications of this split, Kippola suggests, are still with us today. Although it does not ultimately answer its opening question, Kippola's book is a refreshing addition both to studies of nineteenth-century American theatre and culture, and to works on gender and performativity.
