Amongst political philosophers, the importance of the “old quarrel between philosophy and poetry” (Plato, Republic, trans. Allan Bloom, Basic Books, 607b5) has been well-established. Entire subfields of scholarship in political philosophy examine the intricacies of this quarrel, in politics, literature, and film. David Wiles’s Democracy, Theatre and Performance contributes to this effort by shedding light on precisely how blurred the lines between theatrical performance and democratic leadership have always been. Wiles is a theatre studies scholar, who brings his vast knowledge of theater and performance to one of the central challenges in democracy: creating and maintaining reasonable public discourse against the allure of theatricality and artifice.
Wiles offers an insightful perspective on one of the most enduring, and consternating, themes of democratic political theory, presenting democratic leadership as a type of performance art. He traces the place of theater in classical Greek, Puritan, revolutionary French, early American, and twentieth-century Indian societies, to show that theater has always been a staple of civic life and an instructional model for democratic leaders. Political theorists are accustomed to studying plays and speeches as literary artifacts; Wiles adds to this effort by emphasizing the equal importance and complexity of the performance of plays and speeches.
Wiles’s Introduction opens with the rhetorical query, “Perhaps, however, democracy has always required politicians to be actors, speaking the lines the audience wants to hear as their only means to stay in power. If so, is democracy inherently a form of theater?” (p. 1). The answer to this question is obvious to those who study democracy: a resounding yes. As Wiles notes, democratic citizens long for a democratic politics free from artifice, wherein well-intentioned people come together and engage in political debate guided by genuinely held, philosophically coherent, socially responsible, principles. Despite the tendency for democratic citizens to romanticize the societies designed by our predecessors as closer to this ideal than their own, a significant part of Wiles’s project is devoted to disabusing this tendency.
Wiles bookends his work with studies of classical Athens: Chapters 1 and 7 are devoted to examining a society that took both democracy and theater very seriously, perhaps more seriously than any other. Wiles examines the influence that poets, such as Aristophanes, could have over the democracy by depicting political leaders as either heroic or comedic. He also devotes significant time to Plato’s views on rhetoric. Though readers may disagree with Wiles’s characterization of Plato as vigorously opposed to both tragedy and democracy (p. 13), his examination of Plato’s discussions of rhetoric is well done.
The bulk of Wiles’s book concerns the ways that democratic leaders, either politicians or activists, have incorporated theatrical techniques into their rhetoric and speeches to gain followings and outmaneuver their opponents. He focuses in particular on the rise of various demagogues throughout history. Chapter 2 dissects the rivalry between Aeschines and Demosthenes, whose debate in 330 bce highlights the tension between democratic procedure on one hand, and populist patriotism on the other. Chapter 3 details the rise and fall of Oliver Cromwell during the English Revolution. This chapter’s examination of Puritan politics, which condemned theater and theatricality in public life, draws on works by Thomas Hobbes and John Milton to demonstrate how even the most rationalistic (Hobbes) and religious (Milton) thinkers remain enthralled by the power of performance. Chapter 4, “Oratory in the French Revolution,” shows the fluidity between artist and political figure during times of great upheaval. The leaders and agitators of the French Revolution were often well-known outside the realm of politics, as writers, actors, or artists, before becoming involved with revolutionary ideals.
Chapter 5 spans American democracy from the Founding through the nineteenth-century feminist movement, showing both the importance of theater as a “barometer of public opinion” (p. 117) and how various public figures, such as John Adams, Frederick Douglass, and Angelina Grimké, made use of theatrical performing techniques in their public speeches. Finally, Chapter 6 looks at Gandhi’s campaign for Indian independence from Great Britain, and his adept management of his public image to achieve the maximum political impact. In returning to Athens in the final chapter, Wiles considers more broadly the role of the theater in the culture of the city.
Each of these chapters is interesting in its own right, offering the reader a portrait of the various historical incarnations of democracy. Wiles ably highlights the commonalities of democratic politics across the ages, while also detailing the unique circumstances of each societal moment.
The book is not without flaws. At times, Wiles’s split focus on the role of theaters and theatrical performers in democratic societies, and the theatrical techniques employed by political leaders, renders his arguments a bit disjointed. While both topics are important for understanding the functioning of democracy, they perhaps should be examined separately, in order to draw out the nuances of each topic. For example, one of the most intriguing elements of Wiles’s study, from the perspective of political science, is his illumination of the actual theatrical and oratorical training that many political figures received prior to entering the realm of politics. Wiles’s expertise in this understudied area offers a valuable contribution to the study of democratic politics. Wiles’s interdisciplinary approach, combining political science and theater studies, has advantages as perspectives from each discipline shed new light on commonly observed political phenomena; but it also has disadvantages, in that the subject and argument of each intriguing chapter are not as tightly structured or thoroughly explored as one might wish.
Democracy, Theatre and Performance is well worth reading for scholars interested in the intersection of philosophy and poetry. Even casual observers of contemporary politics recognize the theatrical nature of democratic populism. While Athenian philosophers feared the impact of speechwriting on political discourse, contemporary political scientists bemoan the effects of viral videos and soundbites. In our own time, adept politicians must perform well on social media and position themselves closer to a clout-chasing influencer than a justice-minded statesman. As distasteful as those of us who study political philosophy may find this trend of rhetoric being elevated above truth, our distaste will not change the conditions of our politics. By examining the ways that previous democracies navigated the relationship between theater and politics, we may be able to glean lessons for our own time. As Wiles correctly argues, “The idea that reason and sincerity will suffice to shape the behavior of a demos is an illusion which tends paradoxically to open the door to demagogues with a better understanding of human behavior” (p. 169). This does not mean that reason and sincerity have no place in democratic politics. It is the task of political leaders and scholars to inform and guide the opinions of the demos in a more rational, moderate direction. It is imperative, therefore, that democratic citizens concerned with the direction of our politics disabuse ourselves of a nostalgic vision of a glorious past and seek to confront the realities of our present.
